Re: DB2 support
Hi William, I have been running OpenJPA against DB2 v9 with no major issues, and I believe others on the forums have been doing so as well. Admittedly this isn't a certification, but it's at least anecdotal evidence that DB2 v9 will work. For KODO I'd have to refer you to BEA's support statement, but I'd be surprised if they did not support DB2 as well. I'm not sure what you mean by cases to run OpenJPA/KODO on DB2. If you're looking for instructions on how to run the OpenJPA unit tests against DB2 I can help you with that. If you'd prefer to try running your own application against DB2 all you need to do is add the appropriate connection properties to persistence.xml : Something like this should work. . . . properties . . . property name=openjpa.ConnectionDriverName value= com.ibm.db2.jcc.DB2Driver / property name=openjpa.ConnectionURL value=jdbc:db2://localhost:5/TEST / property name=openjpa.ConnectionUserName value=db2user / property name=openjpa.ConnectionPassword value=db2password / . . . /properties . . . Regards, Michael DIck On 5/9/07, William Cai [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi list, AFAIK, the latest DB2 version is DB2 enterprise server edition V9.1. But but current OpenJDK only supports DB2 UDB v8.1. Do we have any plans to certify DB2 UDB V8.2 and DB2 v9 recently? Or more realistically -- are there any cases to run OpenJPA/KODO on DB2 UDB v8.2 or DB2 v9? Any input is greatly appreciated. Thanks, William Database Name Database Version JDBC Driver Name JDBC Driver Version Apache Derby 10.1.2.1 Apache Derby Embedded JDBC Driver 10.1.2.1 Borland Interbase 7.1.0.202 Interclient 4.5.1 Borland JDataStore 6.0 Borland JDataStore 6.0 DB2 8.1 IBM DB2 JDBC Universal Driver 1.0.581
Re: DB2 support
OK, now that I found the relevant section in the documentation I understand what William is asking for. What level of testing do we need to do before we can add a new version of DB2 to the list of supported databases? Is just running our unit test bucket sufficient to add a new database to the list or do we need a more formal process? On 5/9/07, Michael Dick [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi William, I have been running OpenJPA against DB2 v9 with no major issues, and I believe others on the forums have been doing so as well. Admittedly this isn't a certification, but it's at least anecdotal evidence that DB2 v9 will work. For KODO I'd have to refer you to BEA's support statement, but I'd be surprised if they did not support DB2 as well. I'm not sure what you mean by cases to run OpenJPA/KODO on DB2. If you're looking for instructions on how to run the OpenJPA unit tests against DB2 I can help you with that. If you'd prefer to try running your own application against DB2 all you need to do is add the appropriate connection properties to persistence.xml : Something like this should work. . . . properties . . . property name=openjpa.ConnectionDriverName value= com.ibm.db2.jcc.DB2Driver / property name=openjpa.ConnectionURL value=jdbc:db2://localhost:5/TEST / property name=openjpa.ConnectionUserName value=db2user / property name=openjpa.ConnectionPassword value=db2password / . . . /properties . . . Regards, Michael DIck On 5/9/07, William Cai [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi list, AFAIK, the latest DB2 version is DB2 enterprise server edition V9.1. But but current OpenJDK only supports DB2 UDB v8.1. Do we have any plans to certify DB2 UDB V8.2 and DB2 v9 recently? Or more realistically -- are there any cases to run OpenJPA/KODO on DB2 UDB v8.2 or DB2 v9? Any input is greatly appreciated. Thanks, William Database Name Database Version JDBC Driver Name JDBC Driver Version Apache Derby 10.1.2.1 Apache Derby Embedded JDBC Driver 10.1.2.1 Borland Interbase 7.1.0.202 Interclient 4.5.1 Borland JDataStore 6.0 Borland JDataStore 6.0 DB2 8.1 IBM DB2 JDBC Universal Driver 1.0.581
Re: DB2 support
What level of testing do we need to do before we can add a new version of DB2 to the list of supported databases? Is just running our unit test bucket sufficient to add a new database to the list or do we need a more formal process? That's a very good question, and one that I don't think has been discussed in the context of OpenJPA yet. One thing we can do is say that a DB is certified if it passes all of the existing unit tests against that DB. A better solution might be to say that a DB is certified if the JPA TCK passes 100% against that database, but that would make the certification process a bit more cumbersome, since obtaining the TCK requires an NDA to be signed. Also, we should determine how this should impact the release cycle. Should be disallow a release until each and every supported DB version has passed everything 100%? Thoughts? On May 9, 2007, at 6:09 AM, Michael Dick wrote: OK, now that I found the relevant section in the documentation I understand what William is asking for. What level of testing do we need to do before we can add a new version of DB2 to the list of supported databases? Is just running our unit test bucket sufficient to add a new database to the list or do we need a more formal process? On 5/9/07, Michael Dick [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi William, I have been running OpenJPA against DB2 v9 with no major issues, and I believe others on the forums have been doing so as well. Admittedly this isn't a certification, but it's at least anecdotal evidence that DB2 v9 will work. For KODO I'd have to refer you to BEA's support statement, but I'd be surprised if they did not support DB2 as well. I'm not sure what you mean by cases to run OpenJPA/KODO on DB2. If you're looking for instructions on how to run the OpenJPA unit tests against DB2 I can help you with that. If you'd prefer to try running your own application against DB2 all you need to do is add the appropriate connection properties to persistence.xml : Something like this should work. . . . properties . . . property name=openjpa.ConnectionDriverName value= com.ibm.db2.jcc.DB2Driver / property name=openjpa.ConnectionURL value=jdbc:db2://localhost:5/TEST / property name=openjpa.ConnectionUserName value=db2user / property name=openjpa.ConnectionPassword value=db2password / . . . /properties . . . Regards, Michael DIck On 5/9/07, William Cai [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi list, AFAIK, the latest DB2 version is DB2 enterprise server edition V9.1. But but current OpenJDK only supports DB2 UDB v8.1. Do we have any plans to certify DB2 UDB V8.2 and DB2 v9 recently? Or more realistically -- are there any cases to run OpenJPA/KODO on DB2 UDB v8.2 or DB2 v9? Any input is greatly appreciated. Thanks, William Database Name Database Version JDBC Driver Name JDBC Driver Version Apache Derby 10.1.2.1 Apache Derby Embedded JDBC Driver 10.1.2.1 Borland Interbase 7.1.0.202 Interclient 4.5.1 Borland JDataStore 6.0 Borland JDataStore 6.0 DB2 8.1 IBM DB2 JDBC Universal Driver 1.0.581
Re: DB2 support
On May 9, 2007, at 6:09 AM, Michael Dick wrote: OK, now that I found the relevant section in the documentation I understand what William is asking for. What level of testing do we need to do before we can add a new version of DB2 to the list of supported databases? Is just running our unit test bucket sufficient to add a new database to the list or do we need a more formal process? Well, since we're an open source project, the only formal process is what we as a community decide to do. My personal opinion is that if someone runs tests that pass on a database, that's sufficient to say that we support it. Of course, support in an open source project is a matter of interpretation. If someone has a problem, we basically tell them that they should file a JIRA, provide a reproducible test case, and provide a patch licensed to Apache that fixes the issue. One of the committers will review the patch and check it in if they like it. Now, support for a product based on OpenJPA is a completely different matter, and the Apache OpenJPA project doesn't really have an opinion. Craig On 5/9/07, Michael Dick [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi William, I have been running OpenJPA against DB2 v9 with no major issues, and I believe others on the forums have been doing so as well. Admittedly this isn't a certification, but it's at least anecdotal evidence that DB2 v9 will work. For KODO I'd have to refer you to BEA's support statement, but I'd be surprised if they did not support DB2 as well. I'm not sure what you mean by cases to run OpenJPA/KODO on DB2. If you're looking for instructions on how to run the OpenJPA unit tests against DB2 I can help you with that. If you'd prefer to try running your own application against DB2 all you need to do is add the appropriate connection properties to persistence.xml : Something like this should work. . . . properties . . . property name=openjpa.ConnectionDriverName value= com.ibm.db2.jcc.DB2Driver / property name=openjpa.ConnectionURL value=jdbc:db2://localhost:5/TEST / property name=openjpa.ConnectionUserName value=db2user / property name=openjpa.ConnectionPassword value=db2password / . . . /properties . . . Regards, Michael DIck On 5/9/07, William Cai [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi list, AFAIK, the latest DB2 version is DB2 enterprise server edition V9.1. But but current OpenJDK only supports DB2 UDB v8.1. Do we have any plans to certify DB2 UDB V8.2 and DB2 v9 recently? Or more realistically -- are there any cases to run OpenJPA/KODO on DB2 UDB v8.2 or DB2 v9? Any input is greatly appreciated. Thanks, William Database Name Database Version JDBC Driver Name JDBC Driver Version Apache Derby 10.1.2.1 Apache Derby Embedded JDBC Driver 10.1.2.1 Borland Interbase 7.1.0.202 Interclient 4.5.1 Borland JDataStore 6.0 Borland JDataStore 6.0 DB2 8.1 IBM DB2 JDBC Universal Driver 1.0.581 Craig Russell Architect, Sun Java Enterprise System http://java.sun.com/products/jdo 408 276-5638 mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] P.S. A good JDO? O, Gasp! smime.p7s Description: S/MIME cryptographic signature
