Re: [PATCH] brcm: add CLM BLOB files for Luxul devices
Hi Josh, I'm OpenWrt developer and those CLM BLOBs have significant meaning for this project. They allow OpenWrt users to use their devices with full WiFi support (not limited to some generic fallback setup level). For that let me speak up regarding this PATCH case. On 12.06.2023 18:57, Josh Boyer wrote: On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 11:05 AM Rip Route wrote: The files were compiled from source obtained through Luxul's contract manufacturer of these devices. OK, it's not clear to me whether we can accept these. We have no idea what your contract specified, what sources were used, what the license on them is, or if you had authority to release them at all. I'm not questioning your integrity by any means, but we have very little way to know Broadcom is agreeable to these being included in the linux-firmware repo. If Broadcom wants to submit them or provide a Signed-off-by statement, we might be able to take them then. I fully understand your concerns. Those are binary files and it's hard to tell what they contain at first sight. It'd be perfect to have Broadcom simply approve them but I'm afraid it's unlikely. I see linux-wireless@ and Broadcom lists were cc-ed but we didn't get any feedback. I know some firmware contributions took Broadcom months or years in the past. So I'd try to analyze what we have here and try to review it. First of all: CLM (BLOB) is a binary formatted data. It doesn't contain any actual CPU-executable code. It gets uploaded to FullMAC (closed source) firmware and gets parsed by it. So what we have here is not actual firmware (executable binary) built from proprietary C sources full of logic and possibly some patent. We have binary files containing (literally) numbers and strings. They just use a binary undocumented format. I actually took a moment to reverse engineer those files and write basic tools for them. BLOB is a simple container format with header containing offsets, sizes and CRC32 sums. I developed "bcmblob" tool for parsing BLOBs and extracting from them: https://git.openwrt.org/?p=project/firmware-utils.git;a=commitdiff;h=f730ad2fa0b4728e2bd66771d22cf642909e020e CLM BLOB is a BLOB file containing CLM and chipset version. I also developed absolutely basic tool "bcmclm" for parsing CLM files: https://git.openwrt.org/?p=project/firmware-utils.git;a=commitdiff;h=916633160dc92ccae6a0ad8fd900f2d75b5b5ff0 Given that, in my I-am-not-a-lawyer opinion, those files are safe to accept and distribute. If I were to compare them to something it'd be an XLS stylesheet file. It's a binary undocumented format but what it actually contains are sets of values. I don't think it raises any concerns to use a custom binary format. We're clearly fine sharing .xls, .exe or .rar files. I also don't think you can stop anyone from sharing a list of 2 GHz, 5 GHz or 6 GHz channels. Or their rates. Or flags (like radar etc.). Or allowed TX power levels. Just numbers in general. Do you think that with my basic technical summary and Luxul-provided info you can accept those files? ___ openwrt-devel mailing list openwrt-devel@lists.openwrt.org https://lists.openwrt.org/mailman/listinfo/openwrt-devel
Re: [PATCH] brcm: add CLM BLOB files for Luxul devices
The sender domain has a DMARC Reject/Quarantine policy which disallows sending mailing list messages using the original "From" header. To mitigate this problem, the original message has been wrapped automatically by the mailing list software.--- Begin Message --- You scamming Idiots , don’t you know whom you are sending emails to Thanks Sridhar Sent from my iPhone > On Jun 12, 2023, at 3:38 PM, Rip Route wrote: > > There is no intent to be argumentative here, but a brief explanation > of our thoughts may be in order. > > CLM BLOBs are designed by Broadcom for vendors like us. They support > them officially in their upstream brcmfmac driver and firmware > released for brcmfmac. It was Broadcom's intention to allow companies > to provide CLM data as external files for devices without suport > built into their firmware. > > By submitting those files we take the responsibility of allowing > their redistribution. > > This situation is similar to random companies submitting NVRAM files > to linux-firmware repo. Some calibration data can be stored in > text-based NVRAM files; CLM BLOBs also contain calibration data. > Just stored in binary format. It's really just a set of numeric > values stored as multiple arrays. The unusal part (and probably not > very optimal) is binary form. > > This same data could be readily extracted from the device firmware > image. > > dan > >> On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 10:58 AM Josh Boyer wrote: >> >>> On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 11:05 AM Rip Route wrote: >>> >>> The files were compiled from source obtained through Luxul's contract >>> manufacturer of these devices. >> >> OK, it's not clear to me whether we can accept these. We have no idea >> what your contract specified, what sources were used, what the license >> on them is, or if you had authority to release them at all. I'm not >> questioning your integrity by any means, but we have very little way >> to know Broadcom is agreeable to these being included in the >> linux-firmware repo. If Broadcom wants to submit them or provide a >> Signed-off-by statement, we might be able to take them then. >> >> josh >> >>> On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 6:29 AM Josh Boyer wrote: On Thu, Jun 1, 2023 at 1:31 PM Dan Haab wrote: > > From: Dan Haab > > Add per-device regulatory configuration files for complete channel > support and > maximum transmission power per regulatory domain. Where did you get these files from? Given that they're likely from Broadcom, we'd expect a Broadcom Signed-off-by or review at least. josh > Signed-off-by: Dan Haab > --- > WHENCE | 15 +++ > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 28224 bytes > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 34368 bytes > 3 files changed, 15 insertions(+) > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > > diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE > index 32d71481..d3fc870d 100644 > --- a/WHENCE > +++ b/WHENCE > @@ -2630,6 +2630,21 @@ File: brcm/brcmfmac4371-pcie.bin > > Licence: Redistributable. See LICENCE.broadcom_bcm43xx for details. > > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > +Link: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3150-v1.clm_blob -> > brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > + > +Licence: Redistributable. > + > +CLM (Country Locale Matrix) BLOB files contain regulatory configuration > data. > +It's to be parsed and used by a wireless driver. > + > +Permission is hereby granted to use and redistribute those files as > required. > + > +These firmware files are distributed in the hope that they will be > useful, but > +WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of > MERCHANTABILITY or > +FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. > + > File: brcm/brcmfmac4373.bin > File: cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin > Link: brcm/brcmfmac43012-sdio.bin -> ../cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin > diff --git a/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > b/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > new file mode 100644 > index > ..32ca36d7df48ecc5e899e89da347e16a8bcfdcb4 > GIT binary patch > literal 28224 > zcmeHwYkV8ob>E#kcODoF9y6E=5CBOKAP7PfNr7C51i>LRgg_FcKnNlr3Zkf$mf`Xz > zY3((uDz3Usw(EE;uQ!|Rw#{bkI_cU;wsq??w$t>Twt2X1+UC(m(mL-)`=KBEvES5l > zXD}c|Qd&wYIZkZ+eh}{5x%WK(=iGDeKw!CczHB0dw9PO65(l3c-t5Kt(8~zDW=&mW > zP4+V3n!x8q<+oSa_1W6$KxMu)kB|=YX2vIT<2ly9_nH`gZfbney|z9Mb3XR*<&W=v > z;`W{5z{Gg|^nnTG+n;!0`};oe@v#ReaefXl*>1p__d4x6&`yn$v_-bxA@6>JFu7iX > zccvuoye+@?H5uAGynhtlBgNpYH-lgNYOvGy75H>t9LFh~m
Re: [PATCH] brcm: add CLM BLOB files for Luxul devices
There is no intent to be argumentative here, but a brief explanation of our thoughts may be in order. CLM BLOBs are designed by Broadcom for vendors like us. They support them officially in their upstream brcmfmac driver and firmware released for brcmfmac. It was Broadcom's intention to allow companies to provide CLM data as external files for devices without suport built into their firmware. By submitting those files we take the responsibility of allowing their redistribution. This situation is similar to random companies submitting NVRAM files to linux-firmware repo. Some calibration data can be stored in text-based NVRAM files; CLM BLOBs also contain calibration data. Just stored in binary format. It's really just a set of numeric values stored as multiple arrays. The unusal part (and probably not very optimal) is binary form. This same data could be readily extracted from the device firmware image. dan On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 10:58 AM Josh Boyer wrote: > > On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 11:05 AM Rip Route wrote: > > > > The files were compiled from source obtained through Luxul's contract > > manufacturer of these devices. > > OK, it's not clear to me whether we can accept these. We have no idea > what your contract specified, what sources were used, what the license > on them is, or if you had authority to release them at all. I'm not > questioning your integrity by any means, but we have very little way > to know Broadcom is agreeable to these being included in the > linux-firmware repo. If Broadcom wants to submit them or provide a > Signed-off-by statement, we might be able to take them then. > > josh > > > On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 6:29 AM Josh Boyer wrote: > >> > >> On Thu, Jun 1, 2023 at 1:31 PM Dan Haab wrote: > >> > > >> > From: Dan Haab > >> > > >> > Add per-device regulatory configuration files for complete channel > >> > support and > >> > maximum transmission power per regulatory domain. > >> > >> Where did you get these files from? Given that they're likely from > >> Broadcom, we'd expect a Broadcom Signed-off-by or review at least. > >> > >> josh > >> > >> > Signed-off-by: Dan Haab > >> > --- > >> > WHENCE | 15 +++ > >> > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 28224 bytes > >> > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 34368 bytes > >> > 3 files changed, 15 insertions(+) > >> > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > >> > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > >> > > >> > diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE > >> > index 32d71481..d3fc870d 100644 > >> > --- a/WHENCE > >> > +++ b/WHENCE > >> > @@ -2630,6 +2630,21 @@ File: brcm/brcmfmac4371-pcie.bin > >> > > >> > Licence: Redistributable. See LICENCE.broadcom_bcm43xx for details. > >> > > >> > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > >> > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > >> > +Link: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3150-v1.clm_blob -> > >> > brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > >> > + > >> > +Licence: Redistributable. > >> > + > >> > +CLM (Country Locale Matrix) BLOB files contain regulatory configuration > >> > data. > >> > +It's to be parsed and used by a wireless driver. > >> > + > >> > +Permission is hereby granted to use and redistribute those files as > >> > required. > >> > + > >> > +These firmware files are distributed in the hope that they will be > >> > useful, but > >> > +WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of > >> > MERCHANTABILITY or > >> > +FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. > >> > + > >> > File: brcm/brcmfmac4373.bin > >> > File: cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin > >> > Link: brcm/brcmfmac43012-sdio.bin -> ../cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin > >> > diff --git a/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > >> > b/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > >> > new file mode 100644 > >> > index > >> > ..32ca36d7df48ecc5e899e89da347e16a8bcfdcb4 > >> > GIT binary patch > >> > literal 28224 > >> > zcmeHwYkV8ob>E#kcODoF9y6E=5CBOKAP7PfNr7C51i>LRgg_FcKnNlr3Zkf$mf`Xz > >> > zY3((uDz3Usw(EE;uQ!|Rw#{bkI_cU;wsq??w$t>Twt2X1+UC(m(mL-)`=KBEvES5l > >> > zXD}c|Qd&wYIZkZ+eh}{5x%WK(=iGDeKw!CczHB0dw9PO65(l3c-t5Kt(8~zDW=&mW > >> > zP4+V3n!x8q<+oSa_1W6$KxMu)kB|=YX2vIT<2ly9_nH`gZfbney|z9Mb3XR*<&W=v > >> > z;`W{5z{Gg|^nnTG+n;!0`};oe@v#ReaefXl*>1p__d4x6&`yn$v_-bxA@6>JFu7iX > >> > zccvuoye+@?H5uAGynhtlBgNpYH-lgNYOvGy75H>t9LFh~ms2?(=f@Z;*o#%(qbOdl > >> > zs;WNK@ALWnsqu6=ol9HkJL$L5@1(z+{viF0Y&M(AnxnaVK5yo&{9E~V@*fn;f(5T_ > >> > zc-`54Yx|w;4{p46 >> > zPki}<4|tyU@LocQL}a26uOP{?$K&yOy_rmAJX6ZNoVk~IJM(_#YvbcnQ&Xj>d!^FO > >> > z&d$p__jcaidH>~CU%vP9+xPC>d;jgX-+S-9_uu>4`|pF!BO}F;TO+TGygBm4k*^ku > >> > zw{G2f<<^_GzWB;3ue|xnSKoZ|%`d|1s|ayAcb}UF3kUern28PB?;Pd`CvZB}4XjhF > >> > zM>vBwQYLQ*iIIHu5;#ni;%DK3H|Chjr0C>P`6d}`FhDH9Ky > >> > z+$cB8nTqQ32ZEX&GN_6;%o9PBWRC*Y?)HZ
Re: [PATCH] brcm: add CLM BLOB files for Luxul devices
The sender domain has a DMARC Reject/Quarantine policy which disallows sending mailing list messages using the original "From" header. To mitigate this problem, the original message has been wrapped automatically by the mailing list software.--- Begin Message --- Idiots Thanks Sridhar Sent from my iPhone > On Jun 12, 2023, at 12:00 PM, Josh Boyer wrote: > > On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 11:05 AM Rip Route wrote: >> >> The files were compiled from source obtained through Luxul's contract >> manufacturer of these devices. > > OK, it's not clear to me whether we can accept these. We have no idea > what your contract specified, what sources were used, what the license > on them is, or if you had authority to release them at all. I'm not > questioning your integrity by any means, but we have very little way > to know Broadcom is agreeable to these being included in the > linux-firmware repo. If Broadcom wants to submit them or provide a > Signed-off-by statement, we might be able to take them then. > > josh > >>> On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 6:29 AM Josh Boyer wrote: >>> >>> On Thu, Jun 1, 2023 at 1:31 PM Dan Haab wrote: From: Dan Haab Add per-device regulatory configuration files for complete channel support and maximum transmission power per regulatory domain. >>> >>> Where did you get these files from? Given that they're likely from >>> Broadcom, we'd expect a Broadcom Signed-off-by or review at least. >>> >>> josh >>> Signed-off-by: Dan Haab --- WHENCE | 15 +++ ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 28224 bytes ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 34368 bytes 3 files changed, 15 insertions(+) create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE index 32d71481..d3fc870d 100644 --- a/WHENCE +++ b/WHENCE @@ -2630,6 +2630,21 @@ File: brcm/brcmfmac4371-pcie.bin Licence: Redistributable. See LICENCE.broadcom_bcm43xx for details. +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob +Link: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3150-v1.clm_blob -> brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob + +Licence: Redistributable. + +CLM (Country Locale Matrix) BLOB files contain regulatory configuration data. +It's to be parsed and used by a wireless driver. + +Permission is hereby granted to use and redistribute those files as required. + +These firmware files are distributed in the hope that they will be useful, but +WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or +FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + File: brcm/brcmfmac4373.bin File: cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin Link: brcm/brcmfmac43012-sdio.bin -> ../cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin diff --git a/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob b/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob new file mode 100644 index ..32ca36d7df48ecc5e899e89da347e16a8bcfdcb4 GIT binary patch literal 28224 zcmeHwYkV8ob>E#kcODoF9y6E=5CBOKAP7PfNr7C51i>LRgg_FcKnNlr3Zkf$mf`Xz zY3((uDz3Usw(EE;uQ!|Rw#{bkI_cU;wsq??w$t>Twt2X1+UC(m(mL-)`=KBEvES5l zXD}c|Qd&wYIZkZ+eh}{5x%WK(=iGDeKw!CczHB0dw9PO65(l3c-t5Kt(8~zDW=&mW zP4+V3n!x8q<+oSa_1W6$KxMu)kB|=YX2vIT<2ly9_nH`gZfbney|z9Mb3XR*<&W=v z;`W{5z{Gg|^nnTG+n;!0`};oe@v#ReaefXl*>1p__d4x6&`yn$v_-bxA@6>JFu7iX zccvuoye+@?H5uAGynhtlBgNpYH-lgNYOvGy75H>t9LFh~ms2?(=f@Z;*o#%(qbOdl zs;WNK@ALWnsqu6=ol9HkJL$L5@1(z+{viF0Y&M(AnxnaVK5yo&{9E~V@*fn;f(5T_ zc-`54Yx|w;4{p46>>> zPki}<4|tyU@LocQL}a26uOP{?$K&yOy_rmAJX6ZNoVk~IJM(_#YvbcnQ&Xj>d!^FO z&d$p__jcaidH>~CU%vP9+xPC>d;jgX-+S-9_uu>4`|pF!BO}F;TO+TGygBm4k*^ku zw{G2f<<^_GzWB;3ue|xnSKoZ|%`d|1s|ayAcb}UF3kUern28PB?;Pd`CvZB}4XjhF zM>vBwQYLQ*iIIHu5;#ni;%DK3H|Chjr0C>P`6d}`FhDH9Ky z+$cB8nTqQ32ZEX&GN_6;%o9PBWRC*Y?)HZxdUbi_Ty3>}zHwo#*}AxXseRcv+_iC~ zH#af)T>kXbbYaGvE1j|C%V#SKn^&K|cKwB|?;Ggt>rV_MQ-kTD%y9O^$VqpwJ2ZW8 z!06avCYi&7Tsr%i5?hy^Xe^#}6*)N3o#wL79vpBK`|(p7S4J4w!-HLV`^6Y_nH%(| z+pcNCk>c#)Qf_bX@u=sHFUa^Q#$odK6I{^>k3YrXWx3iM)WtP~Yxjdbb~#rMP8=O` zr|viL!RhVGE&(RT#+Ah-*_A|g!QFCu4Ej--gd;AS_8!sW+w9@e?-54(V|0(nkzuJH z*5}AbHI6c6{~qz9ZhvS14;(ei^#;S=F@yK%hwNj;;pkx-9;KKA^YP;icCGN(F`j=s z`Uhg~xcGL(b3nJa^weT+We-xvQ{>?R@ofrYC`8oMAS_R?jIk6IbmX=dEgJ?wH;cHc z9kDv<2gexn=rBAyE*voqcCvN!Lxb;_u|*iMXNvHH(jWA@8%u8fe>>> z=!VD>6L{*eRsE={xDstXDWQi4>%P?sp=Ta3Pb)aSi{s*{W&Edx%C)DD%4ZDpr@asy zGo@z_8|rXih9etSo+Z4$y;=NwXmz&GkGmz>OUugMR$lq$zx((9;aC6TfBMhA_Up=j z`LF-&zyH>6|BwIqt>01i25ekW_lEq&Z>oEPe)soucR4T2xGSXYuI!Zss3h%^1O4mY z__=@l^Z(?Z{
Re: [PATCH] brcm: add CLM BLOB files for Luxul devices
On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 11:05 AM Rip Route wrote: > > The files were compiled from source obtained through Luxul's contract > manufacturer of these devices. OK, it's not clear to me whether we can accept these. We have no idea what your contract specified, what sources were used, what the license on them is, or if you had authority to release them at all. I'm not questioning your integrity by any means, but we have very little way to know Broadcom is agreeable to these being included in the linux-firmware repo. If Broadcom wants to submit them or provide a Signed-off-by statement, we might be able to take them then. josh > On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 6:29 AM Josh Boyer wrote: >> >> On Thu, Jun 1, 2023 at 1:31 PM Dan Haab wrote: >> > >> > From: Dan Haab >> > >> > Add per-device regulatory configuration files for complete channel support >> > and >> > maximum transmission power per regulatory domain. >> >> Where did you get these files from? Given that they're likely from >> Broadcom, we'd expect a Broadcom Signed-off-by or review at least. >> >> josh >> >> > Signed-off-by: Dan Haab >> > --- >> > WHENCE | 15 +++ >> > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 28224 bytes >> > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 34368 bytes >> > 3 files changed, 15 insertions(+) >> > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob >> > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob >> > >> > diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE >> > index 32d71481..d3fc870d 100644 >> > --- a/WHENCE >> > +++ b/WHENCE >> > @@ -2630,6 +2630,21 @@ File: brcm/brcmfmac4371-pcie.bin >> > >> > Licence: Redistributable. See LICENCE.broadcom_bcm43xx for details. >> > >> > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob >> > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob >> > +Link: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3150-v1.clm_blob -> >> > brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob >> > + >> > +Licence: Redistributable. >> > + >> > +CLM (Country Locale Matrix) BLOB files contain regulatory configuration >> > data. >> > +It's to be parsed and used by a wireless driver. >> > + >> > +Permission is hereby granted to use and redistribute those files as >> > required. >> > + >> > +These firmware files are distributed in the hope that they will be >> > useful, but >> > +WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of >> > MERCHANTABILITY or >> > +FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. >> > + >> > File: brcm/brcmfmac4373.bin >> > File: cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin >> > Link: brcm/brcmfmac43012-sdio.bin -> ../cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin >> > diff --git a/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob >> > b/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob >> > new file mode 100644 >> > index >> > ..32ca36d7df48ecc5e899e89da347e16a8bcfdcb4 >> > GIT binary patch >> > literal 28224 >> > zcmeHwYkV8ob>E#kcODoF9y6E=5CBOKAP7PfNr7C51i>LRgg_FcKnNlr3Zkf$mf`Xz >> > zY3((uDz3Usw(EE;uQ!|Rw#{bkI_cU;wsq??w$t>Twt2X1+UC(m(mL-)`=KBEvES5l >> > zXD}c|Qd&wYIZkZ+eh}{5x%WK(=iGDeKw!CczHB0dw9PO65(l3c-t5Kt(8~zDW=&mW >> > zP4+V3n!x8q<+oSa_1W6$KxMu)kB|=YX2vIT<2ly9_nH`gZfbney|z9Mb3XR*<&W=v >> > z;`W{5z{Gg|^nnTG+n;!0`};oe@v#ReaefXl*>1p__d4x6&`yn$v_-bxA@6>JFu7iX >> > zccvuoye+@?H5uAGynhtlBgNpYH-lgNYOvGy75H>t9LFh~ms2?(=f@Z;*o#%(qbOdl >> > zs;WNK@ALWnsqu6=ol9HkJL$L5@1(z+{viF0Y&M(AnxnaVK5yo&{9E~V@*fn;f(5T_ >> > zc-`54Yx|w;4{p46> > zPki}<4|tyU@LocQL}a26uOP{?$K&yOy_rmAJX6ZNoVk~IJM(_#YvbcnQ&Xj>d!^FO >> > z&d$p__jcaidH>~CU%vP9+xPC>d;jgX-+S-9_uu>4`|pF!BO}F;TO+TGygBm4k*^ku >> > zw{G2f<<^_GzWB;3ue|xnSKoZ|%`d|1s|ayAcb}UF3kUern28PB?;Pd`CvZB}4XjhF >> > zM>vBwQYLQ*iIIHu5;#ni;%DK3H|Chjr0C>P`6d}`FhDH9Ky >> > z+$cB8nTqQ32ZEX&GN_6;%o9PBWRC*Y?)HZxdUbi_Ty3>}zHwo#*}AxXseRcv+_iC~ >> > zH#af)T>kXbbYaGvE1j|C%V#SKn^&K|cKwB|?;Ggt>rV_MQ-kTD%y9O^$VqpwJ2ZW8 >> > z!06avCYi&7Tsr%i5?hy^Xe^#}6*)N3o#wL79vpBK`|(p7S4J4w!-HLV`^6Y_nH%(| >> > z+pcNCk>c#)Qf_bX@u=sHFUa^Q#$odK6I{^>k3YrXWx3iM)WtP~Yxjdbb~#rMP8=O` >> > zr|viL!RhVGE&(RT#+Ah-*_A|g!QFCu4Ej--gd;AS_8!sW+w9@e?-54(V|0(nkzuJH >> > z*5}AbHI6c6{~qz9ZhvS14;(ei^#;S=F@yK%hwNj;;pkx-9;KKA^YP;icCGN(F`j=s >> > z`Uhg~xcGL(b3nJa^weT+We-xvQ{>?R@ofrYC`8oMAS_R?jIk6IbmX=dEgJ?wH;cHc >> > z9kDv<2gexn=rBAyE*voqcCvN!Lxb;_u|*iMXNvHH(jWA@8%u8fe> > z=!VD>6L{*eRsE={xDstXDWQi4>%P?sp=Ta3Pb)aSi{s*{W&Edx%C)DD%4ZDpr@asy >> > zGo@z_8|rXih9etSo+Z4$y;=NwXmz&GkGmz>OUugMR$lq$zx((9;aC6TfBMhA_Up=j >> > z`LF-&zyH>6|BwIqt>01i25ekW_lEq&Z>oEPe)soucR4T2xGSXYuI!Zss3h%^1O4mY >> > z__=@l^Z(?Z{> > zAN<3w{{A2Q;UE3+pZw|n`k8<9vtRqx;Yirqin+%QN88MmbWdwns&FJVSU=A;{>9mk >> > zef;H5?Ea> > z%3DA3_TPBtZ~m>n?V9jM-~F-oe(l$P<2OJ5g}?K~AODHJ`@U<> > zlwyDUz|l|qKX<$U`fCwmxV#o43mbSM?N7IK~M5*mG!virTr >> > zJeYqX>p#gP7jx#5OlCl3`@iz>qTsN#_po1i68^66t{jW|ZG13Ne&7e+_?#OVKl-j4 >> > z3t#&3VXxMXr;h8{!pxo;4@$%WSZ0bbxf+ia&I#W=0e|ehJrRHMrw$AGvtMhtIe^8z >> > zJMp8$eB-d*hg}wq)XzUGW)H&n`eA}@cnl=n0Qo4{@%mBZ_PoK+xpC#Am> > zK
Re: [PATCH] brcm: add CLM BLOB files for Luxul devices
The files were compiled from source obtained through Luxul's contract manufacturer of these devices. dan On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 6:29 AM Josh Boyer wrote: > > On Thu, Jun 1, 2023 at 1:31 PM Dan Haab wrote: > > > > From: Dan Haab > > > > Add per-device regulatory configuration files for complete channel support > > and > > maximum transmission power per regulatory domain. > > Where did you get these files from? Given that they're likely from > Broadcom, we'd expect a Broadcom Signed-off-by or review at least. > > josh > > > Signed-off-by: Dan Haab > > --- > > WHENCE | 15 +++ > > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 28224 bytes > > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 34368 bytes > > 3 files changed, 15 insertions(+) > > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > > > > diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE > > index 32d71481..d3fc870d 100644 > > --- a/WHENCE > > +++ b/WHENCE > > @@ -2630,6 +2630,21 @@ File: brcm/brcmfmac4371-pcie.bin > > > > Licence: Redistributable. See LICENCE.broadcom_bcm43xx for details. > > > > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > > +Link: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3150-v1.clm_blob -> > > brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > > + > > +Licence: Redistributable. > > + > > +CLM (Country Locale Matrix) BLOB files contain regulatory configuration > > data. > > +It's to be parsed and used by a wireless driver. > > + > > +Permission is hereby granted to use and redistribute those files as > > required. > > + > > +These firmware files are distributed in the hope that they will be useful, > > but > > +WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY > > or > > +FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. > > + > > File: brcm/brcmfmac4373.bin > > File: cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin > > Link: brcm/brcmfmac43012-sdio.bin -> ../cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin > > diff --git a/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > > b/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > > new file mode 100644 > > index > > ..32ca36d7df48ecc5e899e89da347e16a8bcfdcb4 > > GIT binary patch > > literal 28224 > > zcmeHwYkV8ob>E#kcODoF9y6E=5CBOKAP7PfNr7C51i>LRgg_FcKnNlr3Zkf$mf`Xz > > zY3((uDz3Usw(EE;uQ!|Rw#{bkI_cU;wsq??w$t>Twt2X1+UC(m(mL-)`=KBEvES5l > > zXD}c|Qd&wYIZkZ+eh}{5x%WK(=iGDeKw!CczHB0dw9PO65(l3c-t5Kt(8~zDW=&mW > > zP4+V3n!x8q<+oSa_1W6$KxMu)kB|=YX2vIT<2ly9_nH`gZfbney|z9Mb3XR*<&W=v > > z;`W{5z{Gg|^nnTG+n;!0`};oe@v#ReaefXl*>1p__d4x6&`yn$v_-bxA@6>JFu7iX > > zccvuoye+@?H5uAGynhtlBgNpYH-lgNYOvGy75H>t9LFh~ms2?(=f@Z;*o#%(qbOdl > > zs;WNK@ALWnsqu6=ol9HkJL$L5@1(z+{viF0Y&M(AnxnaVK5yo&{9E~V@*fn;f(5T_ > > zc-`54Yx|w;4{p46 > zPki}<4|tyU@LocQL}a26uOP{?$K&yOy_rmAJX6ZNoVk~IJM(_#YvbcnQ&Xj>d!^FO > > z&d$p__jcaidH>~CU%vP9+xPC>d;jgX-+S-9_uu>4`|pF!BO}F;TO+TGygBm4k*^ku > > zw{G2f<<^_GzWB;3ue|xnSKoZ|%`d|1s|ayAcb}UF3kUern28PB?;Pd`CvZB}4XjhF > > zM>vBwQYLQ*iIIHu5;#ni;%DK3H|Chjr0C>P`6d}`FhDH9Ky > > z+$cB8nTqQ32ZEX&GN_6;%o9PBWRC*Y?)HZxdUbi_Ty3>}zHwo#*}AxXseRcv+_iC~ > > zH#af)T>kXbbYaGvE1j|C%V#SKn^&K|cKwB|?;Ggt>rV_MQ-kTD%y9O^$VqpwJ2ZW8 > > z!06avCYi&7Tsr%i5?hy^Xe^#}6*)N3o#wL79vpBK`|(p7S4J4w!-HLV`^6Y_nH%(| > > z+pcNCk>c#)Qf_bX@u=sHFUa^Q#$odK6I{^>k3YrXWx3iM)WtP~Yxjdbb~#rMP8=O` > > zr|viL!RhVGE&(RT#+Ah-*_A|g!QFCu4Ej--gd;AS_8!sW+w9@e?-54(V|0(nkzuJH > > z*5}AbHI6c6{~qz9ZhvS14;(ei^#;S=F@yK%hwNj;;pkx-9;KKA^YP;icCGN(F`j=s > > z`Uhg~xcGL(b3nJa^weT+We-xvQ{>?R@ofrYC`8oMAS_R?jIk6IbmX=dEgJ?wH;cHc > > z9kDv<2gexn=rBAyE*voqcCvN!Lxb;_u|*iMXNvHH(jWA@8%u8fe > z=!VD>6L{*eRsE={xDstXDWQi4>%P?sp=Ta3Pb)aSi{s*{W&Edx%C)DD%4ZDpr@asy > > zGo@z_8|rXih9etSo+Z4$y;=NwXmz&GkGmz>OUugMR$lq$zx((9;aC6TfBMhA_Up=j > > z`LF-&zyH>6|BwIqt>01i25ekW_lEq&Z>oEPe)soucR4T2xGSXYuI!Zss3h%^1O4mY > > z__=@l^Z(?Z{ > zAN<3w{{A2Q;UE3+pZw|n`k8<9vtRqx;Yirqin+%QN88MmbWdwns&FJVSU=A;{>9mk > > zef;H5?Ea > z%3DA3_TPBtZ~m>n?V9jM-~F-oe(l$P<2OJ5g}?K~AODHJ`@U< > zlwyDUz|l|qKX<$U`fCwmxV#o43mbSM?N7IK~M5*mG!virTr > > zJeYqX>p#gP7jx#5OlCl3`@iz>qTsN#_po1i68^66t{jW|ZG13Ne&7e+_?#OVKl-j4 > > z3t#&3VXxMXr;h8{!pxo;4@$%WSZ0bbxf+ia&I#W=0e|ehJrRHMrw$AGvtMhtIe^8z > > zJMp8$eB-d*hg}wq)XzUGW)H&n`eA}@cnl=n0Qo4{@%mBZ_PoK+xpC#Am > zKg=91 > z*B{qC?!>(lY9~|fFD#y=>5eJzVbAUfzE=xxV}vxPQesSoA$h-+Zqc > > zevE4P_~qbXSJ%(GwY$3xunI5xFgUw|SV3 > zdsE$PMt1Eihb?o8bJ$C*1 > > za1sx$^=xDJVO8Q&EoP5N?6A3yO6X6$+-x0o{G)yMC^=mWe|OZd$1K9$dRz;;R&=A| > > zX(Ic0i}mpjc>cnkOO#S@EmB+Dp?P > zF_Zc6jyaxrntY6X_~DiJ!DZ7$^pl*69y3w?nQa > z!e@U){-nn@N0pkv(XqX > zdoJ8>@juH{YvyzSiUBuY+aFz@vhOt;Yj<9zA+-PVXP^FgDr4Y#wqDa5(4>Pd%`| > > zcQ@&K!R2BvHCUV-brYGJxY#km!{q#471w!K`XP^m4*O&e1%Gj>xM#A1er%#HnB7g| > > zQF#7tsW+ebBblR&`<-6oerMH}hZFcmKXqcz|EN{l@d}>f*9zZVUx4}0I^pS-0nc{P > > z&OgcWRXA={esH_+*vI~E!hh_E?h0WYmBk)b@*K4n``$?r`(haTLfBE(dF&PZQE+pe > > zef?2`9=D`AO6q4{BEbJiz0dVy#MiiR4SULJxYHq3k
Re: [PATCH] brcm: add CLM BLOB files for Luxul devices
On Thu, Jun 1, 2023 at 1:31 PM Dan Haab wrote: > > From: Dan Haab > > Add per-device regulatory configuration files for complete channel support and > maximum transmission power per regulatory domain. Where did you get these files from? Given that they're likely from Broadcom, we'd expect a Broadcom Signed-off-by or review at least. josh > Signed-off-by: Dan Haab > --- > WHENCE | 15 +++ > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 28224 bytes > ...rcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob | Bin 0 -> 34368 bytes > 3 files changed, 15 insertions(+) > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > create mode 100644 brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > > diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE > index 32d71481..d3fc870d 100644 > --- a/WHENCE > +++ b/WHENCE > @@ -2630,6 +2630,21 @@ File: brcm/brcmfmac4371-pcie.bin > > Licence: Redistributable. See LICENCE.broadcom_bcm43xx for details. > > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > +File: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > +Link: brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3150-v1.clm_blob -> > brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xwr-3100-v1.clm_blob > + > +Licence: Redistributable. > + > +CLM (Country Locale Matrix) BLOB files contain regulatory configuration data. > +It's to be parsed and used by a wireless driver. > + > +Permission is hereby granted to use and redistribute those files as required. > + > +These firmware files are distributed in the hope that they will be useful, > but > +WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or > +FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. > + > File: brcm/brcmfmac4373.bin > File: cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin > Link: brcm/brcmfmac43012-sdio.bin -> ../cypress/cyfmac43012-sdio.bin > diff --git a/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > b/brcm/brcmfmac4366c-pcie.luxul,xap-1610-v1.clm_blob > new file mode 100644 > index > ..32ca36d7df48ecc5e899e89da347e16a8bcfdcb4 > GIT binary patch > literal 28224 > zcmeHwYkV8ob>E#kcODoF9y6E=5CBOKAP7PfNr7C51i>LRgg_FcKnNlr3Zkf$mf`Xz > zY3((uDz3Usw(EE;uQ!|Rw#{bkI_cU;wsq??w$t>Twt2X1+UC(m(mL-)`=KBEvES5l > zXD}c|Qd&wYIZkZ+eh}{5x%WK(=iGDeKw!CczHB0dw9PO65(l3c-t5Kt(8~zDW=&mW > zP4+V3n!x8q<+oSa_1W6$KxMu)kB|=YX2vIT<2ly9_nH`gZfbney|z9Mb3XR*<&W=v > z;`W{5z{Gg|^nnTG+n;!0`};oe@v#ReaefXl*>1p__d4x6&`yn$v_-bxA@6>JFu7iX > zccvuoye+@?H5uAGynhtlBgNpYH-lgNYOvGy75H>t9LFh~ms2?(=f@Z;*o#%(qbOdl > zs;WNK@ALWnsqu6=ol9HkJL$L5@1(z+{viF0Y&M(AnxnaVK5yo&{9E~V@*fn;f(5T_ > zc-`54Yx|w;4{p46 zPki}<4|tyU@LocQL}a26uOP{?$K&yOy_rmAJX6ZNoVk~IJM(_#YvbcnQ&Xj>d!^FO > z&d$p__jcaidH>~CU%vP9+xPC>d;jgX-+S-9_uu>4`|pF!BO}F;TO+TGygBm4k*^ku > zw{G2f<<^_GzWB;3ue|xnSKoZ|%`d|1s|ayAcb}UF3kUern28PB?;Pd`CvZB}4XjhF > zM>vBwQYLQ*iIIHu5;#ni;%DK3H|Chjr0C>P`6d}`FhDH9Ky > z+$cB8nTqQ32ZEX&GN_6;%o9PBWRC*Y?)HZxdUbi_Ty3>}zHwo#*}AxXseRcv+_iC~ > zH#af)T>kXbbYaGvE1j|C%V#SKn^&K|cKwB|?;Ggt>rV_MQ-kTD%y9O^$VqpwJ2ZW8 > z!06avCYi&7Tsr%i5?hy^Xe^#}6*)N3o#wL79vpBK`|(p7S4J4w!-HLV`^6Y_nH%(| > z+pcNCk>c#)Qf_bX@u=sHFUa^Q#$odK6I{^>k3YrXWx3iM)WtP~Yxjdbb~#rMP8=O` > zr|viL!RhVGE&(RT#+Ah-*_A|g!QFCu4Ej--gd;AS_8!sW+w9@e?-54(V|0(nkzuJH > z*5}AbHI6c6{~qz9ZhvS14;(ei^#;S=F@yK%hwNj;;pkx-9;KKA^YP;icCGN(F`j=s > z`Uhg~xcGL(b3nJa^weT+We-xvQ{>?R@ofrYC`8oMAS_R?jIk6IbmX=dEgJ?wH;cHc > z9kDv<2gexn=rBAyE*voqcCvN!Lxb;_u|*iMXNvHH(jWA@8%u8fe z=!VD>6L{*eRsE={xDstXDWQi4>%P?sp=Ta3Pb)aSi{s*{W&Edx%C)DD%4ZDpr@asy > zGo@z_8|rXih9etSo+Z4$y;=NwXmz&GkGmz>OUugMR$lq$zx((9;aC6TfBMhA_Up=j > z`LF-&zyH>6|BwIqt>01i25ekW_lEq&Z>oEPe)soucR4T2xGSXYuI!Zss3h%^1O4mY > z__=@l^Z(?Z{ zAN<3w{{A2Q;UE3+pZw|n`k8<9vtRqx;Yirqin+%QN88MmbWdwns&FJVSU=A;{>9mk > zef;H5?Ea z%3DA3_TPBtZ~m>n?V9jM-~F-oe(l$P<2OJ5g}?K~AODHJ`@U< zlwyDUz|l|qKX<$U`fCwmxV#o43mbSM?N7IK~M5*mG!virTr > zJeYqX>p#gP7jx#5OlCl3`@iz>qTsN#_po1i68^66t{jW|ZG13Ne&7e+_?#OVKl-j4 > z3t#&3VXxMXr;h8{!pxo;4@$%WSZ0bbxf+ia&I#W=0e|ehJrRHMrw$AGvtMhtIe^8z > zJMp8$eB-d*hg}wq)XzUGW)H&n`eA}@cnl=n0Qo4{@%mBZ_PoK+xpC#Am zKg=91 z*B{qC?!>(lY9~|fFD#y=>5eJzVbAUfzE=xxV}vxPQesSoA$h-+Zqc > zevE4P_~qbXSJ%(GwY$3xunI5xFgUw|SV3 zdsE$PMt1Eihb?o8bJ$C*1 > za1sx$^=xDJVO8Q&EoP5N?6A3yO6X6$+-x0o{G)yMC^=mWe|OZd$1K9$dRz;;R&=A| > zX(Ic0i}mpjc>cnkOO#S@EmB+Dp?P zF_Zc6jyaxrntY6X_~DiJ!DZ7$^pl*69y3w?nQa z!e@U){-nn@N0pkv(XqX zdoJ8>@juH{YvyzSiUBuY+aFz@vhOt;Yj<9zA+-PVXP^FgDr4Y#wqDa5(4>Pd%`| > zcQ@&K!R2BvHCUV-brYGJxY#km!{q#471w!K`XP^m4*O&e1%Gj>xM#A1er%#HnB7g| > zQF#7tsW+ebBblR&`<-6oerMH}hZFcmKXqcz|EN{l@d}>f*9zZVUx4}0I^pS-0nc{P > z&OgcWRXA={esH_+*vI~E!hh_E?h0WYmBk)b@*K4n``$?r`(haTLfBE(dF&PZQE+pe > zef?2`9=D`AO6q4{BEbJiz0dVy#MiiR4SULJxYHq3k*A2l6*0UbdsdWi#T(wci7o6Y > zV0WkhL)mo6Q&sm-AR8$BBKB-c;pe+lg-zsHN8wi`Zd3KF?{zPtaD($Sq;O3IB4JGK > za|Xd&jc^#`GvEtton{)EYlQ0v$*p0IM}#v3EHDX(XHgB;{NX9h<8&j@1Rb!)lEXQ_ > zXVf3Ix_5Ys4_ks~JQxP;84KRRoHNLsTSDP7@sy=-Ne!3%;Sn|$q!BP~k#Jq`xU!8C > zkOIsoAnvXJ|H=10eCLMUi+~E7jtXgLZbOqWR<>eH1p`A9cXT9t0fjA3xBwD?x*qs{ > z$|P$@mSJQ~$ubQNXZ@aR#zW+SfwG3Dm_m~&k2!`)W1dA5RZNdS@&P;&5UoCMHRF{@ > zp5sP1