[Pce] EKR Discuss on draft-ietf-pce-pceps (was RE: Alexey Melnikov's Discuss on draft-ietf-pce-pceps-15: (with DISCUSS and COMMENT))

[Dhruv Dhody]

Hi EKR,

I have been told that my response [1] to your mail [2] has not reach some of 
the mailboxes.

Thus on advice of our AD, I am starting a new thread to reach closure on this.

The open point is -
EKR suggested that we use the StartTLS message to indicate the local policy if 
the PCEP speaker is willing to connect without TLS. Whereas the current 
document does this by using the error message in case it is unwilling or unable 
to start the TLS.

EKR proposal works, but will require us to add a new PCEP object - StartTLS 
object, as unfortunately there is no way to carry the information in the 
current message/objects format defined.

As an editor, my opinion was to avoid making a change in encoding if possible, 
especially if the benefit is not big and the default setting is strict TLS.

But if the opinion is towards "mandating" making the change, I can put out a 
version for review soon.

All the other comments are handled in -16 [3]. Thanks for all the comments and 
discussions!

Regards,
Dhruv

[1] https://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/pce/current/msg05487.html
[2] https://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/pce/current/msg05486.html
[3] https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-pce-pceps-16


___
Pce mailing list
Pce@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce

Re: [Pce] Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

[Igor Bryskin]

Hi JP,

Thanks for the great discussions we have had over the last 15 years.
I wish you very best,  I am sure you do and will excell in everything you put 
your mind, focus and effort on.

Cheers,
Igor
From:JP Vasseur (jvasseur)
To:pce@ietf.org,Julien Meuric,jonathan.hardw...@metaswitch.com,Deborah A 
Brungard,Adrian Farrel,d.k...@lancaster.ac.uk,Dhruv Dhody,
Date:2017-08-22 10:30:36
Subject:[Pce] Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

Dear WG,

Almost 12 years since we started the PCE WG ! More than 30 RFCs, many 
re-charterings, closely working with several other WGs (MPLS, CCAMP, OSPF, 
ISIS, …) and of course many implementations and deployments in the field 
applying the PCE architecture to several areas !

As you might have noticed I have been fairly silent for the past two years, 
driving several quite hectic projects related to Machine Learning for the 
network (Security, Wireless, IoT, …) not involving too much of standardization 
work (yet). As discussed a few times, the PCE may also play a great role in 
ML/AI for central global optimization :-)

As agreed with our AD Deborah I have completed a transition phase, and it is a 
great time for me to step down as PCE co-chair.

I would like to warmly thank my friend Adrian whom I started the PCE WG with in 
2005 and many years of close collaboration, Julien Meuric who has been a 
terrific co-chair, and Jonathan who stepped up as new co-chair at light speed, 
not forgetting Dan for years as secretary and now Dhruv.

See you all soon !

Cheers,

JP.


___
Pce mailing list
Pce@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce

Re: [Pce] Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

[Dhruv Dhody]

Hi JP,

Thanks for pioneering the PCE work.
Also, thanks for the guidance you provided.

All the best with new initiatives! Hope to see you again!

Regards,
Dhruv

From: JP Vasseur (jvasseur) [mailto:jvass...@cisco.com]
Sent: 22 August 2017 20:00
To: pce@ietf.org; Julien Meuric ; 
jonathan.hardw...@metaswitch.com; Deborah A Brungard ; Adrian 
Farrel ; d.k...@lancaster.ac.uk; Dhruv Dhody 

Subject: Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

Dear WG,

Almost 12 years since we started the PCE WG ! More than 30 RFCs, many 
re-charterings, closely working with several other WGs (MPLS, CCAMP, OSPF, 
ISIS, …) and of course many implementations and deployments in the field 
applying the PCE architecture to several areas !

As you might have noticed I have been fairly silent for the past two years, 
driving several quite hectic projects related to Machine Learning for the 
network (Security, Wireless, IoT, …) not involving too much of standardization 
work (yet). As discussed a few times, the PCE may also play a great role in 
ML/AI for central global optimization :-)

As agreed with our AD Deborah I have completed a transition phase, and it is a 
great time for me to step down as PCE co-chair.

I would like to warmly thank my friend Adrian whom I started the PCE WG with in 
2005 and many years of close collaboration, Julien Meuric who has been a 
terrific co-chair, and Jonathan who stepped up as new co-chair at light speed, 
not forgetting Dan for years as secretary and now Dhruv.

See you all soon !

Cheers,

JP.


___
Pce mailing list
Pce@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce

Re: [Pce] Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

[Jonathan Hardwick]

Thanks, JP, for initiating this work and for your huge contribution to it!
Very best wishes for your new projects.  Hope to see you again soon!

Cheers
Jon

From: JP Vasseur (jvasseur) [mailto:jvass...@cisco.com]
Sent: 22 August 2017 15:30
To: pce@ietf.org; Julien Meuric ; Jonathan Hardwick 
; Deborah A Brungard ; Adrian 
Farrel ; d.k...@lancaster.ac.uk; Dhruv Dhody 

Subject: Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

Dear WG,

Almost 12 years since we started the PCE WG ! More than 30 RFCs, many 
re-charterings, closely working with several other WGs (MPLS, CCAMP, OSPF, 
ISIS, …) and of course many implementations and deployments in the field 
applying the PCE architecture to several areas !

As you might have noticed I have been fairly silent for the past two years, 
driving several quite hectic projects related to Machine Learning for the 
network (Security, Wireless, IoT, …) not involving too much of standardization 
work (yet). As discussed a few times, the PCE may also play a great role in 
ML/AI for central global optimization :-)

As agreed with our AD Deborah I have completed a transition phase, and it is a 
great time for me to step down as PCE co-chair.

I would like to warmly thank my friend Adrian whom I started the PCE WG with in 
2005 and many years of close collaboration, Julien Meuric who has been a 
terrific co-chair, and Jonathan who stepped up as new co-chair at light speed, 
not forgetting Dan for years as secretary and now Dhruv.

See you all soon !

Cheers,

JP.


___
Pce mailing list
Pce@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce

Re: [Pce] Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

[daniel]

Thanks for your leadership and many contributions JP – long may they continue! 
The PCE architecture(s) and protocol are IETF jewels…

 

BR, Dan. 



 

From: JP Vasseur (jvasseur) [mailto:jvass...@cisco.com] 
Sent: 22 August 2017 15:30
To: pce@ietf.org; Julien Meuric ; 
jonathan.hardw...@metaswitch.com; Deborah A Brungard ; Adrian 
Farrel ; King, Daniel ; Dhruv 
Dhody 
Subject: Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

 

Dear WG, 

 

Almost 12 years since we started the PCE WG ! More than 30 RFCs, many 
re-charterings, closely working with several other WGs (MPLS, CCAMP, OSPF, 
ISIS, …) and of course many implementations and deployments in the field 
applying the PCE architecture to several areas !

 

As you might have noticed I have been fairly silent for the past two years, 
driving several quite hectic projects related to Machine Learning for the 
network (Security, Wireless, IoT, …) not involving too much of standardization 
work (yet). As discussed a few times, the PCE may also play a great role in 
ML/AI for central global optimization :-) 

 

As agreed with our AD Deborah I have completed a transition phase, and it is a 
great time for me to step down as PCE co-chair.

 

I would like to warmly thank my friend Adrian whom I started the PCE WG with in 
2005 and many years of close collaboration, Julien Meuric who has been a 
terrific co-chair, and Jonathan who stepped up as new co-chair at light speed, 
not forgetting Dan for years as secretary and now Dhruv. 

 

See you all soon !

 

Cheers,

 

JP.

 

 

___
Pce mailing list
Pce@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce

Re: [Pce] Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

[BRUNGARD, DEBORAH A]

Hi JP,

We thank you for initiating PCE and all these years of service! PCE would not 
be what it is today without you.

We look forward to seeing you again at IETF – hopefully to kick off another 
great idea!
All the best-
Deborah


From: JP Vasseur (jvasseur) [mailto:jvass...@cisco.com]
Sent: Tuesday, August 22, 2017 10:30 AM
To: pce@ietf.org; Julien Meuric ; 
jonathan.hardw...@metaswitch.com; BRUNGARD, DEBORAH A ; Adrian 
Farrel ; d.k...@lancaster.ac.uk; Dhruv Dhody 

Subject: Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

Dear WG,

Almost 12 years since we started the PCE WG ! More than 30 RFCs, many 
re-charterings, closely working with several other WGs (MPLS, CCAMP, OSPF, 
ISIS, …) and of course many implementations and deployments in the field 
applying the PCE architecture to several areas !

As you might have noticed I have been fairly silent for the past two years, 
driving several quite hectic projects related to Machine Learning for the 
network (Security, Wireless, IoT, …) not involving too much of standardization 
work (yet). As discussed a few times, the PCE may also play a great role in 
ML/AI for central global optimization :-)

As agreed with our AD Deborah I have completed a transition phase, and it is a 
great time for me to step down as PCE co-chair.

I would like to warmly thank my friend Adrian whom I started the PCE WG with in 
2005 and many years of close collaboration, Julien Meuric who has been a 
terrific co-chair, and Jonathan who stepped up as new co-chair at light speed, 
not forgetting Dan for years as secretary and now Dhruv.

See you all soon !

Cheers,

JP.


___
Pce mailing list
Pce@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce

Re: [Pce] Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

[Khasanov Boris]

Hi JP,

From one side it is a bit sad to hear that news, but surely it will be huge 
advantage for those new projects to get you onboard.
Your accomplishments say much more than any words.
Warmest wishes!

SY,
Boris


From: Pce [mailto:pce-boun...@ietf.org] On Behalf Of JP Vasseur (jvasseur)
Sent: Tuesday, August 22, 2017 5:30 PM
To: pce@ietf.org; Julien Meuric; jonathan.hardw...@metaswitch.com; Deborah A 
Brungard; Adrian Farrel; d.k...@lancaster.ac.uk; Dhruv Dhody
Subject: [Pce] Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

Dear WG,

Almost 12 years since we started the PCE WG ! More than 30 RFCs, many 
re-charterings, closely working with several other WGs (MPLS, CCAMP, OSPF, 
ISIS, …) and of course many implementations and deployments in the field 
applying the PCE architecture to several areas !

As you might have noticed I have been fairly silent for the past two years, 
driving several quite hectic projects related to Machine Learning for the 
network (Security, Wireless, IoT, …) not involving too much of standardization 
work (yet). As discussed a few times, the PCE may also play a great role in 
ML/AI for central global optimization :-)

As agreed with our AD Deborah I have completed a transition phase, and it is a 
great time for me to step down as PCE co-chair.

I would like to warmly thank my friend Adrian whom I started the PCE WG with in 
2005 and many years of close collaboration, Julien Meuric who has been a 
terrific co-chair, and Jonathan who stepped up as new co-chair at light speed, 
not forgetting Dan for years as secretary and now Dhruv.

See you all soon !

Cheers,

JP.


___
Pce mailing list
Pce@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce

[Pce] Best Wishes for the future of PCE WG !

[JP Vasseur (jvasseur)]

Dear WG,

Almost 12 years since we started the PCE WG ! More than 30 RFCs, many 
re-charterings, closely working with several other WGs (MPLS, CCAMP, OSPF, 
ISIS, …) and of course many implementations and deployments in the field 
applying the PCE architecture to several areas !

As you might have noticed I have been fairly silent for the past two years, 
driving several quite hectic projects related to Machine Learning for the 
network (Security, Wireless, IoT, …) not involving too much of standardization 
work (yet). As discussed a few times, the PCE may also play a great role in 
ML/AI for central global optimization :-)

As agreed with our AD Deborah I have completed a transition phase, and it is a 
great time for me to step down as PCE co-chair.

I would like to warmly thank my friend Adrian whom I started the PCE WG with in 
2005 and many years of close collaboration, Julien Meuric who has been a 
terrific co-chair, and Jonathan who stepped up as new co-chair at light speed, 
not forgetting Dan for years as secretary and now Dhruv.

See you all soon !

Cheers,

JP.


___
Pce mailing list
Pce@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce