Re: Modified Pentax F 35-70 lens does over 1:1 macro magnification without rings (is it good ???)

2005-07-05 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi

On Jul 5, 2005, at 6:55 AM, Joaquim Carvalho wrote:


A guy that does lens repairs showed me a Pentax 35-70mm macro lens
modified to do 1.6:1 magnification without rings, more than any  
standard

Pentax lens can do. I took it home to make some tests.


I would be very interested to know what the modifications entail.


I took a close-up picture of the MX speed selector:

http://x64.com/joaquim/photo/photo05/
Second picture is a pixel by pixel center crop.


Looks pretty good. I don't expect it to compete with a true macro  
lens in ultimate quality, but the only way to say for sure would be  
to test the modified zoom at the same magnification against a  
particular macro lens with an appropriate target.



Is this lens good? Will a 50mm F4.0 or F2.8 be sharper?


I have the A50/2.8 Macro as well as the F35-70/3.5-4.5 Macro, which  
achieves 1:4 magnification.


There is no question that at 1:4 magnification, the A50/2.8 Macro  
prime lens has better rectilinear correction as well as higher  
resolution than the zoom.


Godfrey



Re: Modified Pentax F 35-70 lens does over 1:1 macro magnification without rings (is it good ???)

2005-07-05 Thread Andre Langevin

A sramp for example.


A live sramp of course...


...I meant a stamp!

Andre



Re: Modified Pentax F 35-70 lens does over 1:1 macro magnification without rings (is it good ???)

2005-07-05 Thread Andre Langevin



Is this lens good? Will a 50mm F4.0 or F2.8 be sharper?


You would need to compare it using a subject with very fine details, 
unlike the speed dial.  A sramp for example.


Andre



Modified Pentax F 35-70 lens does over 1:1 macro magnification without rings (is it good ???)

2005-07-05 Thread Joaquim Carvalho
Sorry to post again but I'm very intrigued with this, I do not have 
experience with true macro lenses, I want your comments on this:

A guy that does lens repairs showed me a Pentax 35-70mm macro lens 
modified to do 1.6:1 magnification without rings, more than any standard 
Pentax lens can do. I took it home to make some tests.

I took a close-up picture of the MX speed selector:

http://x64.com/joaquim/photo/photo05/
Second picture is a pixel by pixel center crop.

An ant would have been more interesting but it's 4:00 in the morning and
I couldn't find any. I'll post an ant picture as soon as I can find one.

Is this lens good? Will a 50mm F4.0 or F2.8 be sharper?