#24684 [Bgs]: PHP 4.3.1 + no longer compatible with O'reilly WebSite Pro 3.0
ID: 24684 User updated by: webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Reported By: webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Status: Bogus Bug Type: CGI related Operating System: Win 2000 SP4 PHP Version: 4.3.1 New Comment: Greetings, I've tried three different ways to get PHP 4.3.1 + to run on server software that works fine with 4.3.0 - CLI is just one thing I tried as specified in my bogus bug report. I do understand the difference. You changed something in 4.3.1. What happened, at least tell us that and I'll leave this issue alone and stick with 4.3.0. Thank you. Previous Comments: [2003-07-16 20:53:20] [EMAIL PROTECTED] DO NOT use the 'Add comment' link when you add comments to your own bug report, use the 'Edit Submission'.. And this is bogus, CLI is not CGI. [2003-07-16 16:31:20] webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Greetings, Thank you very much for your expedient response, it is greatly appreciated. I downloaded and installed the latest snap shot and switched between 1 and 0 on the cgi.fix_pathinfo setting as you suggested, but alas the problem (bug?) still remains with the 4.3.2 snap shot on WebSite Pro 3. [2003-07-16 15:12:40] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Try latest stable snapshot from http://snaps.php.net/ Then try setting cgi.fix_pathinfo in your php.ini file. I don't know which setting (0 or 1) works with that webserver, but one of them should. [2003-07-16 14:44:51] webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Description: Greetings, PHP I have spent the last few days trying to find a successful combination that will work with O'reilly WebSite 3.0 as well as PHP 4.3.0 does. Versions 4.3.1 and higher (including 5 beta) seems to be no longer compatible with this web server software. I use the CGI configuration w/o cgi redirect on two other identical severs - which works seamlessly with PHP 4.3.0 and O'reilly WebSite 3.0. After failed attempts with versions 4.3.1+ on this new server, I tried this same PHP 4.3.0 configuration and again works perfectly. But now with 4.3.1 + all I receive is the No Input File Specified messages or page not found is some cases. I'm only presenting the 3 notes below to prove incompatibility... please do not take them as support questions or a false bugs reports; I do realize they would be if submitted separately as such. Solutions Tried for 4.3.1 + 1. I tried the CLI folder's php.exe, which works past the default php.exe only to the point were the simplest echo of hello world needs to have a line break before any PHP or html code - or you receive a CGI 500 error. 2. So I place a line break before any code to get the script to output properly - but of course I then can not use sessions. (headers already sent message). 3. I then tried the isapi extension configuration - which too does not work with sessions on WebSite Pro 3 - due to the fact that the session_start function creates a new session file on every page refresh. This new lack of compatibility may or may not be a bug, but I feel it needs to be professionally addressed by the PHP staff. Even a notice on the web site, though heart breaking, would suffice. Thank you for your kind attention. Reproduce code: --- html head titletest/title /head body ?PHP echo 'hello world'; ? /body /html Expected result: Hello World Actual result: -- : : : : : hello world : : Content-length: 589 500 Server Error The server encountered an error and was unable to complete your request. Message: CGI output from C:/WebSite/htdocs/test.php contained no blank line separating header and data (most likely a broken CGI program) Please contact the server administrator at [EMAIL PROTECTED] and inform them of the time the error occured, plus anything you know of that may have caused the error. -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=24684edit=1
#24684 [Bgs]: PHP 4.3.1 + no longer compatible with O'reilly WebSite Pro 3.0
ID: 24684 User updated by: webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Reported By: webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Status: Bogus Bug Type: CGI related Operating System: Win 2000 SP4 PHP Version: 4.3.1 New Comment: Greetings, Let me clarify this. The only successful combination that WebSite Pro 3 has with PHP 4.3.0 and lower is the following: You must use the php.exe (the default one, not CLI's folder of php.exe of course). You must set wwwserver/shellcgi as the content type. You must set cgi.force_redirect = 0 This has successfully worked on three servers using WSP 3 since PHP 4 was on the table until 4.3.1. I only tried the other configuration I mentioned, in my past correspondence on this issue, out of desperation not as a final solution. Sorry if I'm being a pest, but something changed. I just want you to know that I'm too much in love with PHP to disrespect you guys. Thank you for time and kind help! Best wishes! Previous Comments: [2003-07-17 11:21:52] webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Greetings, I've tried three different ways to get PHP 4.3.1 + to run on server software that works fine with 4.3.0 - CLI is just one thing I tried as specified in my bogus bug report. I do understand the difference. You changed something in 4.3.1. What happened, at least tell us that and I'll leave this issue alone and stick with 4.3.0. Thank you. [2003-07-16 20:53:20] [EMAIL PROTECTED] DO NOT use the 'Add comment' link when you add comments to your own bug report, use the 'Edit Submission'.. And this is bogus, CLI is not CGI. [2003-07-16 16:31:20] webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Greetings, Thank you very much for your expedient response, it is greatly appreciated. I downloaded and installed the latest snap shot and switched between 1 and 0 on the cgi.fix_pathinfo setting as you suggested, but alas the problem (bug?) still remains with the 4.3.2 snap shot on WebSite Pro 3. [2003-07-16 15:12:40] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Try latest stable snapshot from http://snaps.php.net/ Then try setting cgi.fix_pathinfo in your php.ini file. I don't know which setting (0 or 1) works with that webserver, but one of them should. [2003-07-16 14:44:51] webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Description: Greetings, PHP I have spent the last few days trying to find a successful combination that will work with O'reilly WebSite 3.0 as well as PHP 4.3.0 does. Versions 4.3.1 and higher (including 5 beta) seems to be no longer compatible with this web server software. I use the CGI configuration w/o cgi redirect on two other identical severs - which works seamlessly with PHP 4.3.0 and O'reilly WebSite 3.0. After failed attempts with versions 4.3.1+ on this new server, I tried this same PHP 4.3.0 configuration and again works perfectly. But now with 4.3.1 + all I receive is the No Input File Specified messages or page not found is some cases. I'm only presenting the 3 notes below to prove incompatibility... please do not take them as support questions or a false bugs reports; I do realize they would be if submitted separately as such. Solutions Tried for 4.3.1 + 1. I tried the CLI folder's php.exe, which works past the default php.exe only to the point were the simplest echo of hello world needs to have a line break before any PHP or html code - or you receive a CGI 500 error. 2. So I place a line break before any code to get the script to output properly - but of course I then can not use sessions. (headers already sent message). 3. I then tried the isapi extension configuration - which too does not work with sessions on WebSite Pro 3 - due to the fact that the session_start function creates a new session file on every page refresh. This new lack of compatibility may or may not be a bug, but I feel it needs to be professionally addressed by the PHP staff. Even a notice on the web site, though heart breaking, would suffice. Thank you for your kind attention. Reproduce code: --- html head titletest/title /head body ?PHP echo 'hello world'; ? /body /html Expected result: Hello World Actual result: -- : : : : : hello world : : Content-length: 589 500 Server Error The server encountered an error and was unable to complete your request. Message: CGI output from C:/WebSite/htdocs/test.php contained no blank line separating header and data (most likely a broken CGI program) Please contact the server administrator at [EMAIL PROTECTED] and inform them of the time the error occured, plus anything you know of that may have caused
#24684 [Com]: PHP 4.3.1 + no longer compatible with O'reilly WebSite Pro 3.0
ID: 24684 Comment by: webmaster at wisesoftwareinc dot com Reported By: webmaster at wiseosoftwareinc dot com Status: Feedback Bug Type: CGI related Operating System: Win 2000 SP4 PHP Version: 4.3.1 New Comment: Greetings, Thank you very much for your expedient response, it is greatly appreciated. I downloaded and installed the latest snap shot and switched between 1 and 0 on the cgi.fix_pathinfo setting as you suggested, but alas the problem (bug?) still remains with the 4.3.2 snap shot on WebSite Pro 3. Previous Comments: [2003-07-16 15:12:40] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Try latest stable snapshot from http://snaps.php.net/ Then try setting cgi.fix_pathinfo in your php.ini file. I don't know which setting (0 or 1) works with that webserver, but one of them should. [2003-07-16 14:45:50] webmaster at wiseosoftwareinc dot com email address correction: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2003-07-16 14:44:51] webmaster at wiseosoftwareinc dot com Description: Greetings, PHP I have spent the last few days trying to find a successful combination that will work with O'reilly WebSite 3.0 as well as PHP 4.3.0 does. Versions 4.3.1 and higher (including 5 beta) seems to be no longer compatible with this web server software. I use the CGI configuration w/o cgi redirect on two other identical severs - which works seamlessly with PHP 4.3.0 and O'reilly WebSite 3.0. After failed attempts with versions 4.3.1+ on this new server, I tried this same PHP 4.3.0 configuration and again works perfectly. But now with 4.3.1 + all I receive is the No Input File Specified messages or page not found is some cases. I'm only presenting the 3 notes below to prove incompatibility... please do not take them as support questions or a false bugs reports; I do realize they would be if submitted separately as such. Solutions Tried for 4.3.1 + 1. I tried the CLI folder's php.exe, which works past the default php.exe only to the point were the simplest echo of hello world needs to have a line break before any PHP or html code - or you receive a CGI 500 error. 2. So I place a line break before any code to get the script to output properly - but of course I then can not use sessions. (headers already sent message). 3. I then tried the isapi extension configuration - which too does not work with sessions on WebSite Pro 3 - due to the fact that the session_start function creates a new session file on every page refresh. This new lack of compatibility may or may not be a bug, but I feel it needs to be professionally addressed by the PHP staff. Even a notice on the web site, though heart breaking, would suffice. Thank you for your kind attention. Reproduce code: --- html head titletest/title /head body ?PHP echo 'hello world'; ? /body /html Expected result: Hello World Actual result: -- : : : : : hello world : : Content-length: 589 500 Server Error The server encountered an error and was unable to complete your request. Message: CGI output from C:/WebSite/htdocs/test.php contained no blank line separating header and data (most likely a broken CGI program) Please contact the server administrator at [EMAIL PROTECTED] and inform them of the time the error occured, plus anything you know of that may have caused the error. -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=24684edit=1
