Bug #16093 [Com]: mail does not work

[s dot hajric at hs-hkb dot ba]

Edit report at http://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=16093edit=1

 ID: 16093
 Comment by: s dot hajric at hs-hkb dot ba
 Reported by:sc2 at gmx dot at
 Summary:mail does not work
 Status: Bogus
 Type:   Bug
 Package:Mail related
 Operating System:   suse 7.1
 PHP Version:4.1.2
 Block user comment: N

 New Comment:

dhhfjfgjfjf


Previous Comments:

[2004-07-28 19:44:56] mark at intuitiveisp dot com

This is a Bug... It should return true or false 100% of the 

time...  If it can't get a shell it should log an error 

somewhere.


[2002-03-15 19:52:04] mfisc...@php.net

PHP needs an executeable shell to run the sendmail binary; make sure a
sheel is executeable at least by the apache user (/bin/sh or
/bin/bash).



Anyway it's a system configuration error, not a PHP bug.


[2002-03-15 07:30:53] sc2 at gmx dot at

What's the return value of mail(), is it false ?

nope



Have you tried calling sendmail from command line if it properly
works?

this works fine, it works to fine to send mail from a cgi form. It only
looks that the php doesnt contact sendmail.

on other servers/Dist. works fine.



sorry for bad. english


[2002-03-15 07:09:18] mfisc...@php.net

What's the return value of mail(), is it false ?



Have you tried calling sendmail from command line if it properly works?


[2002-03-15 06:27:30] sc2 at gmx dot at

The mail send function does not work.

there are no errors.



the sendmail path is correct (php.ini / configure scan) and sendmail
works fine

(manuall + cgi mail)



there no errors to see in logs.



sendmail never becomes a mail from php

(if i use a php mail script, then sendmail log neves shows 

from   to . so i think php never contact sendmail to send the
mail)



on other servers (redhat and other dist.) i dont have problems with mail
functions.



if you need more information please say it.



thank you-





-- 
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=16093edit=1

#16093 [Com]: mail does not work

[mark at intuitiveisp dot com]

 ID:   16093
 Comment by:   mark at intuitiveisp dot com
 Reported By:  sc2 at gmx dot at
 Status:   Bogus
 Bug Type: Mail related
 Operating System: suse 7.1
 PHP Version:  4.1.2
 New Comment:

This is a Bug... It should return true or false 100% of the 
time...  If it can't get a shell it should log an error 
somewhere.


Previous Comments:


[2002-03-15 19:52:04] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

PHP needs an executeable shell to run the sendmail binary; make sure a
sheel is executeable at least by the apache user (/bin/sh or
/bin/bash).

Anyway it's a system configuration error, not a PHP bug.



[2002-03-15 07:30:53] sc2 at gmx dot at

What's the return value of mail(), is it false ?
nope

Have you tried calling sendmail from command line if it properly
works?
this works fine, it works to fine to send mail from a cgi form. It only
looks that the php doesnt contact sendmail.
on other servers/Dist. works fine.

sorry for bad. english



[2002-03-15 07:09:18] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

What's the return value of mail(), is it false ?

Have you tried calling sendmail from command line if it properly works?



[2002-03-15 06:27:30] sc2 at gmx dot at

The mail send function does not work.
there are no errors.

the sendmail path is correct (php.ini / configure scan) and sendmail
works fine
(manuall + cgi mail)

there no errors to see in logs.

sendmail never becomes a mail from php
(if i use a php mail script, then sendmail log neves shows 
from   to . so i think php never contact sendmail to send the
mail)

on other servers (redhat and other dist.) i dont have problems with
mail functions.

if you need more information please say it.

thank you-




-- 
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=16093edit=1