#32601 [Bgs]: Related to Bug #18648 Single entry form POST gives incorrect variable content.
ID: 32601
User updated by: sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Reported By: sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Status: Bogus
Bug Type: Apache related
Operating System: Windows XP
PHP Version: 4.3.9
New Comment:
Ok, thank you for explaining, and sorry to have taken up your time.
Previous Comments:
[2005-05-03 09:18:07] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
This is simply how IE works, or doesn't work, depending on your
perspective. Try it with a browser that actually works, like Firefox.
It has nothing to do with bug #18648.
I think the easiest way to prove this to you is to get you to simply
change the test case to use a GET instead of a POST so you can see
exactly what the browser is sending to PHP. On IE when you hit enter
in the single text field, it just sends:
ptitle=
but when you click the submit button it sends:
ptitle=&submit=Submit
This sort of question really doesn't belong in our bug reporting
system. Please use the appropriate mailing list next time.
[2005-05-03 07:52:39] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
The related bug report to this seemed to indicate it was to do with
PHP. Why is this any different now? I've tried the suggested solutions
in Bug #18648, but unlike others there could not solve it.
[2005-05-03 07:00:41] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
This has nothing to do with PHP. PHP just shows you what your browser
is sending.
[2005-05-03 06:42:00] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
This was marked bogus, but was my last comment taken into account?
[2005-04-06 19:08:29] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Sorry to confuse, but I've just discovered someting new.
When simply pressing enter:
array(2) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" ["submit"]=> string(6) "Submit" }
When pressing enter and the cursor is in the box (as is the norm when
you have just finished typing something):
array(1) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" }
The remainder of the comments for this report are too long. To view
the rest of the comments, please view the bug report online at
http://bugs.php.net/32601
--
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=32601&edit=1
#32601 [Bgs]: Related to Bug #18648 Single entry form POST gives incorrect variable content.
ID: 32601
Updated by: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Reported By: sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Status: Bogus
Bug Type: Apache related
Operating System: Windows XP
PHP Version: 4.3.9
New Comment:
This is simply how IE works, or doesn't work, depending on your
perspective. Try it with a browser that actually works, like Firefox.
It has nothing to do with bug #18648.
I think the easiest way to prove this to you is to get you to simply
change the test case to use a GET instead of a POST so you can see
exactly what the browser is sending to PHP. On IE when you hit enter
in the single text field, it just sends:
ptitle=
but when you click the submit button it sends:
ptitle=&submit=Submit
This sort of question really doesn't belong in our bug reporting
system. Please use the appropriate mailing list next time.
Previous Comments:
[2005-05-03 07:52:39] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
The related bug report to this seemed to indicate it was to do with
PHP. Why is this any different now? I've tried the suggested solutions
in Bug #18648, but unlike others there could not solve it.
[2005-05-03 07:00:41] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
This has nothing to do with PHP. PHP just shows you what your browser
is sending.
[2005-05-03 06:42:00] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
This was marked bogus, but was my last comment taken into account?
[2005-04-06 19:08:29] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Sorry to confuse, but I've just discovered someting new.
When simply pressing enter:
array(2) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" ["submit"]=> string(6) "Submit" }
When pressing enter and the cursor is in the box (as is the norm when
you have just finished typing something):
array(1) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" }
[2005-04-06 18:19:16] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
There we go. You're getting just correct input.
No bug here. (ALWAYS use the superglobals $_GET, $_POST, etc)
The remainder of the comments for this report are too long. To view
the rest of the comments, please view the bug report online at
http://bugs.php.net/32601
--
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=32601&edit=1
#32601 [Bgs]: Related to Bug #18648 Single entry form POST gives incorrect variable content.
ID: 32601
User updated by: sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Reported By: sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Status: Bogus
Bug Type: Apache related
Operating System: Windows XP
PHP Version: 4.3.9
New Comment:
The related bug report to this seemed to indicate it was to do with
PHP. Why is this any different now? I've tried the suggested solutions
in Bug #18648, but unlike others there could not solve it.
Previous Comments:
[2005-05-03 07:00:41] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
This has nothing to do with PHP. PHP just shows you what your browser
is sending.
[2005-05-03 06:42:00] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
This was marked bogus, but was my last comment taken into account?
[2005-04-06 19:08:29] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Sorry to confuse, but I've just discovered someting new.
When simply pressing enter:
array(2) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" ["submit"]=> string(6) "Submit" }
When pressing enter and the cursor is in the box (as is the norm when
you have just finished typing something):
array(1) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" }
[2005-04-06 18:19:16] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
There we go. You're getting just correct input.
No bug here. (ALWAYS use the superglobals $_GET, $_POST, etc)
[2005-04-06 14:26:54] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Sorry, my mistake - I misread your question.
Output is:
array(2) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" ["submit"]=> string(6) "Submit" }
The remainder of the comments for this report are too long. To view
the rest of the comments, please view the bug report online at
http://bugs.php.net/32601
--
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=32601&edit=1
#32601 [Bgs]: Related to Bug #18648 Single entry form POST gives incorrect variable content.
ID: 32601
User updated by: sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Reported By: sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Status: Bogus
Bug Type: Apache related
Operating System: Windows XP
PHP Version: 4.3.9
New Comment:
Sorry to confuse, but I've just discovered someting new.
When simply pressing enter:
array(2) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" ["submit"]=> string(6) "Submit" }
When pressing enter and the cursor is in the box (as is the norm when
you have just finished typing something):
array(1) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" }
Previous Comments:
[2005-04-06 18:19:16] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
There we go. You're getting just correct input.
No bug here. (ALWAYS use the superglobals $_GET, $_POST, etc)
[2005-04-06 14:26:54] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Sorry, my mistake - I misread your question.
Output is:
array(2) { ["ptitle"]=> string(0) "" ["submit"]=> string(6) "Submit" }
[2005-04-06 14:23:08] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
The result is:
array(1) { ["ptitle"]=> string(4) "text" }
I found a work-around last night, using "if ($_POST) { .. }" rather
than "if ($submit) { .. }", but it still doesn't explain why $submit is
not recognised.
[2005-04-06 13:51:12] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
What does this output when you press simply enter:
test.php:
[2005-04-06 01:58:06] sarah dot lee at seh dot ox dot ac dot uk
Description:
This is related to Bug #18648 Single entry form POST gives incorrect
variable content.
My problems seem to be similar to that of other users on that thread, a
form with a single text box doesn't really submit if the enter button is
pressed.
I'm using Apache 1.3 on Windows. In my httpd.conf, I don't have any
InputFilters/OutputFilters, just
AddType application/x-httpd-php .php
I've tried the other fixes suggested: doesn't fix it, and nor does .
I seem to be the only one mentioning it with Apache 1.3. Is there
anything that can be done to solve it?
Reproduce code:
---
In an include:
In the PHP script:
if ($submit) {
...
}
Expected result:
I expect the data to be carried to the PHP script, as it would if the
submit button were actually clicked.
Actual result:
--
The page just gets refreshed with the data before any text was entered
into the text box, and enter pressed.
--
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=32601&edit=1
