Bug #10351 Updated: Parsing problem with nested ? : structures
ID: 10351
Updated by: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Reported By: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Status: Open
Bug Type: Feature/Change Request
Operating System: Sun OS 5.7
PHP Version: 4.0.3pl1
New Comment:
I think the key here is not precedence, but associativity. The ?:
operator is listed as being left-associative which, I think, means your
simplified example will be evaluated like this:
(1 ? (1 ? "3" : "2") : 1) ? "1" : "0"
which will, indeed, result in 1!
A right-associative ?: would be grouped as you expected, like this:
1 ? (1 ? "3" : "2") : (1 ? "1" : "0")
-- ergo, in C ?: must be right-associative!!
(As a side-note, operator associativity is listed in the operator
precedence table with no real explanation of what it means, or link to
such explanation -- perhaps this should be made a documentation feature
request?)
Previous Comments:
[2002-04-29 11:13:40] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
See comment starting with "I checked...".
[2002-04-29 10:34:57] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
I checked, and < has a higher precedence than ?: as one
would expect. For example, with $dHour = 5, this is
equivalent to:
$departmeals = 1 ? 1 ? "3" : "2" : 1 ? "1" : "0";
which should evaluate to "3" but evaluates to "1" instead.
The C language has no trouble with this construction:
sun-66% cat temp.c
#include
main(){
printf("%s\n",1 ? 1 ? "3" : "2" : 1 ? "1" : "0");
}
sun-66% cc temp.c
sun-66% a.out
3
[2002-04-27 15:19:22] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
it does execute correctly, given the relative precedence of the '<' and
'?:' operators.
[2001-04-16 16:14:48] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
The following statement does not execute correctly:
$departmeals = $dHour < 10.5 ? $dHour < 6.0 ? "3" : "2"
:
$dHour < 18.0 ? "1" : "0";
No error message--it just returns the wrong result. It does execute
correctly if parentheses are added:
$departmeals = $dHour < 10.5 ? ($dHour < 6.0 ? "3" : "2")
:
($dHour < 18.0 ? "1" : "0");
The original is not ambiguous; it should parse and execute correctly.
--
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=10351&edit=1
Bug #10351 Updated: Parsing problem with nested ? : structures
ID: 10351
Updated by: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Reported By: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
-Status: Closed
+Status: Open
Bug Type: Feature/Change Request
Operating System: Sun OS 5.7
PHP Version: 4.0.3pl1
New Comment:
See comment starting with "I checked...".
Previous Comments:
[2002-04-29 10:34:57] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
I checked, and < has a higher precedence than ?: as one
would expect. For example, with $dHour = 5, this is
equivalent to:
$departmeals = 1 ? 1 ? "3" : "2" : 1 ? "1" : "0";
which should evaluate to "3" but evaluates to "1" instead.
The C language has no trouble with this construction:
sun-66% cat temp.c
#include
main(){
printf("%s\n",1 ? 1 ? "3" : "2" : 1 ? "1" : "0");
}
sun-66% cc temp.c
sun-66% a.out
3
[2002-04-27 15:19:22] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
it does execute correctly, given the relative precedence of the '<' and
'?:' operators.
[2001-04-16 16:14:48] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
The following statement does not execute correctly:
$departmeals = $dHour < 10.5 ? $dHour < 6.0 ? "3" : "2"
:
$dHour < 18.0 ? "1" : "0";
No error message--it just returns the wrong result. It does execute
correctly if parentheses are added:
$departmeals = $dHour < 10.5 ? ($dHour < 6.0 ? "3" : "2")
:
($dHour < 18.0 ? "1" : "0");
The original is not ambiguous; it should parse and execute correctly.
--
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=10351&edit=1
Bug #10351 Updated: Parsing problem with nested ? : structures
ID: 10351
Updated by: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Reported By: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Status: Closed
Bug Type: Feature/Change Request
Operating System: Sun OS 5.7
PHP Version: 4.0.3pl1
New Comment:
I checked, and < has a higher precedence than ?: as one
would expect. For example, with $dHour = 5, this is
equivalent to:
$departmeals = 1 ? 1 ? "3" : "2" : 1 ? "1" : "0";
which should evaluate to "3" but evaluates to "1" instead.
The C language has no trouble with this construction:
sun-66% cat temp.c
#include
main(){
printf("%s\n",1 ? 1 ? "3" : "2" : 1 ? "1" : "0");
}
sun-66% cc temp.c
sun-66% a.out
3
Previous Comments:
[2002-04-27 15:19:22] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
it does execute correctly, given the relative precedence of the '<' and
'?:' operators.
[2001-04-16 16:14:48] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
The following statement does not execute correctly:
$departmeals = $dHour < 10.5 ? $dHour < 6.0 ? "3" : "2"
:
$dHour < 18.0 ? "1" : "0";
No error message--it just returns the wrong result. It does execute
correctly if parentheses are added:
$departmeals = $dHour < 10.5 ? ($dHour < 6.0 ? "3" : "2")
:
($dHour < 18.0 ? "1" : "0");
The original is not ambiguous; it should parse and execute correctly.
--
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=10351&edit=1
Bug #10351 Updated: Parsing problem with nested ? : structures
ID: 10351 Updated by: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reported By: [EMAIL PROTECTED] -Status: Open +Status: Closed Bug Type: Feature/Change Request Operating System: Sun OS 5.7 PHP Version: 4.0.3pl1 New Comment: it does execute correctly, given the relative precedence of the '<' and '?:' operators. Previous Comments: [2001-04-16 16:14:48] [EMAIL PROTECTED] The following statement does not execute correctly: $departmeals = $dHour < 10.5 ? $dHour < 6.0 ? "3" : "2" : $dHour < 18.0 ? "1" : "0"; No error message--it just returns the wrong result. It does execute correctly if parentheses are added: $departmeals = $dHour < 10.5 ? ($dHour < 6.0 ? "3" : "2") : ($dHour < 18.0 ? "1" : "0"); The original is not ambiguous; it should parse and execute correctly. -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=10351&edit=1
