Re: Re: Plasma 4 bug reports: Open for bugs
Done.
Re: Re: Plasma 4 bug reports: Open for bugs
On Fri, 02 Feb 2018 07:46:11 -0800 Marco Martin wrote >On Thu, Feb 1, 2018 at 10:19 PM, David Edmundson > wrote: >> In bugzilla a product can be "Open for bug entry" or not. >> It can also be done at a per-version level. >> >> When unset a user will not see it in the "enter bug" list, or the version >> won't be listed. If they force it, they'll get a message like: >> https://bugs.kde.org/enter_bug.cgi?product=Aktion >> >> Currently Plasma 4 is "open for bug entry". >> >> One can also enter a bug on the 4.x entries on products like systemsettings, >> kscreenlocker etc. >> >> Should we disable them? It still gets a few every month and it's wasting the >> user's time if we're clearly not going to do anything with it. > >+1 for closing 4.x >-- >Marco Martin +2. Let's do it. Who has the power? If someone can get me access, I can take care of this and all subsequent requests of this nature. I have an unusual love for well-functioning bug trackers. Nate
Re: Plasma 4 bug reports: Open for bugs
On Thu, Feb 1, 2018 at 10:19 PM, David Edmundson wrote: > In bugzilla a product can be "Open for bug entry" or not. > It can also be done at a per-version level. > > When unset a user will not see it in the "enter bug" list, or the version > won't be listed. If they force it, they'll get a message like: > https://bugs.kde.org/enter_bug.cgi?product=Aktion > > Currently Plasma 4 is "open for bug entry". > > One can also enter a bug on the 4.x entries on products like systemsettings, > kscreenlocker etc. > > Should we disable them? It still gets a few every month and it's wasting the > user's time if we're clearly not going to do anything with it. +1 for closing 4.x -- Marco Martin
Re: Plasma 4 bug reports: Open for bugs
On Fri, Feb 2, 2018 at 5:43 AM, Martin Flöser wrote: > Am 2018-02-01 22:19, schrieb David Edmundson: > >> In bugzilla a product can be "Open for bug entry" or not. >> It can also be done at a per-version level. >> >> When unset a user will not see it in the "enter bug" list, or the >> version won't be listed. If they force it, they'll get a message like: >> https://bugs.kde.org/enter_bug.cgi?product=Aktion >> >> Currently Plasma 4 is "open for bug entry". >> >> One can also enter a bug on the 4.x entries on products like >> systemsettings, kscreenlocker etc. >> > > kscreenlocker is still a product in 5. > To clarify, I'm suggesting in addition to turning off the product Plasma4, we turn off reporting on 4.x on the products that are still relevant in 5.x. >If we apply that rule for more prodcuts, it would be super awesome to automate. I just noticed that all 5.11 versions were still open for bugs. There's a script in releaseme for creating versions in all products. I'm sure it could be made to disable versions.
Re: Plasma 4 bug reports: Open for bugs
Am 2018-02-01 22:19, schrieb David Edmundson: In bugzilla a product can be "Open for bug entry" or not. It can also be done at a per-version level. When unset a user will not see it in the "enter bug" list, or the version won't be listed. If they force it, they'll get a message like: https://bugs.kde.org/enter_bug.cgi?product=Aktion Currently Plasma 4 is "open for bug entry". One can also enter a bug on the 4.x entries on products like systemsettings, kscreenlocker etc. kscreenlocker is still a product in 5. Should we disable them? It still gets a few every month and it's wasting the user's time if we're clearly not going to do anything with it. +1 FWIW: I've already disabled new bugs on plasmashell 5.0 -> 5.7, I know Martin does the same in kwin I'm even more strict. For KWin the following rules are applied: * latest two minor version of current release (e.g. currently 5.11.5 and 5.11.4) * latest two minor version of current LTS release (e.g. currently 5.8.7 and 5.8.8) * latest development release * master The main thinking is: I'm not interested in triaging bugs for 5.10, we won't do fixes any more. Neither am I interested in bugs for 5.11.3 -> distros should update. So next week this will change to: * 5.11.95 will be disabled * 5.8.x will be disabled * 5.11.4 will be disabled If we apply that rule for more prodcuts, it would be super awesome to automate. I just noticed that all 5.11 versions were still open for bugs. Cheers Martin
Plasma 4 bug reports: Open for bugs
In bugzilla a product can be "Open for bug entry" or not. It can also be done at a per-version level. When unset a user will not see it in the "enter bug" list, or the version won't be listed. If they force it, they'll get a message like: https://bugs.kde.org/enter_bug.cgi?product=Aktion Currently Plasma 4 is "open for bug entry". One can also enter a bug on the 4.x entries on products like systemsettings, kscreenlocker etc. Should we disable them? It still gets a few every month and it's wasting the user's time if we're clearly not going to do anything with it. FWIW: I've already disabled new bugs on plasmashell 5.0 -> 5.7, I know Martin does the same in kwin David
