Re: Python to use a non open source bug tracker? - Trac?

2006-10-04 Thread Harry George
Fredrik Lundh [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

 Steve Holden wrote:
 
  But sadly people are much happier complaining on c.l.py than exerting
  themselves to support the community with an open source issue tracker.
 
 you're not on the infrastructure list, I hear.  python.org could still need a
 few more roundup volunteers, but it's not like nobody's prepared to con-
 tribute manhours.  don't underestimate the community.
 
 /F 
 
 
 

I'm not on the infrastructure list either.  But I wonder why it is
Roundup or else non-python COTS?  I gave up on Roundup a while ago
due to too many crashes.  I'm now using Trac:

a) Open Source
b) Python
c) Adequate functionality (for me at least)

http://trac.edgewall.org/

I'm not trying to sell Trac, but I would like to know what drove the
developers away from it.

-- 
Harry George
PLM Engineering Architecture
-- 
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list


Re: Python to use a non open source bug tracker? - Trac?

2006-10-04 Thread Martin v. Löwis
Harry George schrieb:
 I'm not on the infrastructure list either.  But I wonder why it is
 Roundup or else non-python COTS?  I gave up on Roundup a while ago
 due to too many crashes.  I'm now using Trac:
 
 a) Open Source
 b) Python
 c) Adequate functionality (for me at least)
 
 http://trac.edgewall.org/
 
 I'm not trying to sell Trac, but I would like to know what drove the
 developers away from it.

IMO, the biggest concern was that it didn't really scale. I.e. if you
have a thousand open and several thousand closed reports in the
database, you need excellent support for queries, sorting, and alike.
Trac doesn't quite have the same power that the other tools do.
For example, to save a query/report, you actually have to write it in
SQL. For a complex report (with multiple groups), you cannot change
the order of items returned on the page (for a simple search, clicking
on the headings changes the order).

To see what I mean, please try to find out how many open reports
for the module report system are currently entered in the tracker
at

http://trac.edgewall.org/report

How many of these are for 0.9.x?

There is also searching, which doesn't give a tabular view of all
tickets, but instead gives a Web search result page (similar
to what a search engine produces). This makes it difficult to scan
systematically for, say, all titles.

Regards,
Martin
-- 
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list