gopherlib deprecated in 2.5

2006-11-22 Thread Szabolcs Nagy
I've just seen that gopherlib is deprecated in python 2.5
http://docs.python.org/lib/module-gopherlib.html

we still use this protocol (though there are only few working gopher
servers are left on the net)

My friend just wrote a standard compliant gopher server (pygopherd had
some problems oslt) and it's much better for hierarchycal content
sharing than the http (which is overrated and misused in this respect).

So i don't really understand why would one remove it from python. It's
a friendly, tiny, simple, standard protocol.

what is the opinion of the comp.lang.python crowd?

-- 
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list


Re: gopherlib deprecated in 2.5

2006-11-22 Thread Terry Reedy

Szabolcs Nagy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote in message 
news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 I've just seen that gopherlib is deprecated in python 2.5
 http://docs.python.org/lib/module-gopherlib.html

 we still use this protocol (though there are only few working gopher
 servers are left on the net)

 My friend just wrote a standard compliant gopher server (pygopherd had
 some problems oslt) and it's much better for hierarchycal content
 sharing than the http (which is overrated and misused in this respect).

 So i don't really understand why would one remove it from python. It's
 a friendly, tiny, simple, standard protocol.

The devolopers thought that perhaps gopherlib was unused in new or 
updated-to-new releases code.  Even if it is by a few, there is still the 
question of whether gopherlib should be in the stdlib in preference to 
modules that would be useful to more people or whether it should be a 
downloadable module at PyPI.  The latter would require someone to take 
ownership of it.

You might consider posting a note on py dev (easily accessible via gmane) 
to let them know there is at least one current user.

Terry Jan Reedy



-- 
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list