[Qemu-devel] Re: virtio-blk.c handling of i/o which is not a 512 multiple

2011-03-31 Thread Conor Murphy
Hi Christoph,

I had already updated my driver to reject non 512 multiple sized requests. I
rolled back this update and applied your patch and I now get a non-zero status
response and no qemu crash!

Thanks for your help,
Conor






[Qemu-devel] Re: virtio-blk.c handling of i/o which is not a 512 multiple

2011-03-30 Thread Stefan Hajnoczi
On Wed, Mar 30, 2011 at 9:15 AM, Conor Murphy
conor_murphy_v...@hotmail.com wrote:
 I'm trying to write a virtio-blk driver for Solaris. I've gotten it to the 
 point
 where Solaris can see the device and create a ZFS file system on it.

 However when I try and create a UFS filesystem on the device, the VM crashed
 with the error
 *** glibc detected *** /usr/bin/qemu-kvm: double free or corruption (!prev):
 0x7f2d38000a00 ***

This is a bug in QEMU.  A guest must not be able to trigger a crash.

 I can reproduce the problem with a simple dd, i.e.
 dd if=/dev/zero of=/dev/rdsk/c2d10p0 bs=5000 count=1

I think this a raw character device, which is why you're even able to
perform non-blocksize accesses?  Have you looked at how other drivers
(like the Xen pv blkfront) handle this?

 My driver will create a virtio-blk request with two elements in the sg list, 
 one
 for the first 4096 byes and the other for the remaining 904.

 From stepping through with gdb, virtio_blk_handle_write will sets n_sectors 
 to 9
 (5000 / 512). Later on the code, n_sectors is used the calculate the size of 
 the
 buffer required but 9 * 512 is too small and so when the request is process it
 ends up writing past the end of the buffer and I guest this triggers the glibc
 error.

We need to validate that (qiov-size % BDRV_SECTOR_SIZE) == 0 and
reject invalid requests.

 Is there a requirement for virtio-blk guest drivers that all i/o requests are
 sized in multiples of 512 bytes?

There is no strict requirement according to the virtio specification,
but maybe there should be:

http://ozlabs.org/~rusty/virtio-spec/virtio-spec-0.8.9.pdf

Stefan