Re: [SUMMARY] NFS between Linux and Solaris

2003-10-22 Thread Dominic RIVERA
If you're running a kernel before 2.4.19 try upgrading your kernel. I
ran into some issues with pre 2.4.19 kernels that would do some strange
things, apparantly someone did some major nfs work in 2.4.19.

-Dominic

Dominic Rivera
(503) 947-7308
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 [EMAIL PROTECTED] 10/22/03 13:24 PM 
Well, I wish I could say I have an authoritative answer on what caused
it, but I can no longer reproduce the problem.  I've tried the same
thing with the following mount options, all of which work fine:

vers=2,proto=udp
vers=3,proto=udp
vers=3
vers=3,proto=udp,noac
(no options)

At this point, I have to assume some other system and/or network anomoly
was causing the problem.  If I can reproduce and resolve the symptoms,
I'll re-summarize.

-J.

On Wed, 2003-10-22 at 15:20, Jason Dixon wrote:
 Hi folks-
 
 My apologies if this is out there somewhere, but I've googled this to
 death without finding a satisfactory answer.  I'm attempting to tar
copy
 a large repository (actually, the RHAS3.0 iso images) from a Linux NFS
 server to a Solaris NFS client.  At various intervals, the transfer
 invariably dies with a file not found error.  The cause of this
error
 can be explained by the sudden disappearance of directories in the
 top-level of the exported share.
 
 Remounting the share causes the directories (and everything recursive
 therein) to reappear, but the problem reoccurs the next time I try the
 transfer.  I've tried a number of different flags, up to and including
 all of the following:
 
 vers=2,proto=udp,ro,noac
 
 Unfortunately, there's been no effect.  Has anyone run into this?  Is
it
 a known incompatibility between NFS implementations?  The problem is
 easily reproducible.  The server is running Red Hat Advanced Server
2.1
 Update 2 on a DL380.  The client is running Solaris 8 on an E250. 
Both
 servers, while on separate VLANs, are in the same general networking
 vicinity.  Any ideas/solutions will be greatly appreciated.
 
 TIA,
-- 
Jason Dixon, RHCE
DixonGroup Consulting
http://www.dixongroup.net


-- 
redhat-list mailing list
unsubscribe mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list


-- 
redhat-list mailing list
unsubscribe mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list


Re: [SUMMARY] NFS between Linux and Solaris

2003-10-22 Thread Jason Dixon
On Wed, 2003-10-22 at 20:46, Dominic RIVERA wrote:
 If you're running a kernel before 2.4.19 try upgrading your kernel. I
 ran into some issues with pre 2.4.19 kernels that would do some strange
 things, apparantly someone did some major nfs work in 2.4.19.

Unfortunately, *all* Red Hat Advanced Server 2.1 kernels are built on
2.4.9.  The newest is 2.4.9e-27, and Red Hat won't officially support
anything you build yourself.  :)

-- 
Jason Dixon, RHCE
DixonGroup Consulting
http://www.dixongroup.net


-- 
redhat-list mailing list
unsubscribe mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list


RE: [SUMMARY] NFS between Linux and Solaris

2003-10-22 Thread Kenneth Goodwin
  -Original Message-
  From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of Jason
Dixon
  Sent: Wednesday, October 22, 2003 4:23 PM
  To: Red Hat Mailing List
  Subject: [SUMMARY] NFS between Linux and Solaris


  Well, I wish I could say I have an authoritative answer
on
  what caused
  it, but I can no longer reproduce the problem.  I've
tried the same
  thing with the following mount options, all of which work
fine:

  vers=2,proto=udp
  vers=3,proto=udp
  vers=3
  vers=3,proto=udp,noac
  (no options)

  At this point, I have to assume some other system and/or
  network anomoly
  was causing the problem.  If I can reproduce and resolve
the
  symptoms,
  I'll re-summarize.

  -J.

  On Wed, 2003-10-22 at 15:20, Jason Dixon wrote:
   Hi folks-
  
   My apologies if this is out there somewhere, but I've
  googled this to
   death without finding a satisfactory answer.  I'm
  attempting to tar copy
   a large repository (actually, the RHAS3.0 iso images)
from
  a Linux NFS
   server to a Solaris NFS client.  At various intervals,
the transfer
   invariably dies with a file not found error.  The
cause
  of this error
   can be explained by the sudden disappearance of
directories in the
   top-level of the exported share.
  
   Remounting the share causes the directories (and
  everything recursive
   therein) to reappear, but the problem reoccurs the next
  time I try the
   transfer.  I've tried a number of different flags, up
to
  and including
   all of the following:
  
   vers=2,proto=udp,ro,noac
  
   Unfortunately, there's been no effect.  Has anyone run
  into this?  Is it
   a known incompatibility between NFS implementations?
The
  problem is
   easily reproducible.  The server is running Red Hat
  Advanced Server 2.1
   Update 2 on a DL380.  The client is running Solaris 8
on
  an E250.  Both
   servers, while on separate VLANs, are in the same
general
  networking
   vicinity.  Any ideas/solutions will be greatly
appreciated.
  
   TIA,
  --
  Jason Dixon, RHCE
  DixonGroup Consulting
  http://www.dixongroup.net


There is one thing wrong on redhat 7.1 that just bit me
yesterday.
maybe it is related to what is happening to you
might still be an unknown bug in the later releases.
At least worth a moments thought in terms of your situation.

I have Compaq proliants and redhat 7.1 (and later?) uses the
TLAN ethernet
driver on these systems.

This 7.1 system on an internal network that has not been
patched since the install
(yes, bad admin, bad admin, but its due for its REDHAT 9.0
upgrade)
deadlocked the ethernet interface after I started
both INBOUND and an OUTBOUND FTP sessions that pushed large
files
(like your NFS transfers)
into and off of the system. ISO images for Informix -
multiple 400K files.

We also had a large NFS transfer inbound from SUN solaris
2.6 server.
So the ethernet driver and software layer was very busy,
saturated in fact.

no sign of a resource problem on the box. netstat or
otherwise.

looks like I have a driver and/or TCP/IP software layer
bug to be patched. Sounds somewhat similiarlike what is
happening to you as well.
maybe it is not an NFS problem but an issue with the
underlying
network stack.

You are fine as long as traffic stays below some magic
threshold.
Push the interface past that point and weird stuff starts to
happen
until you get total failure usually requiring a reboot or
maybe
an interface reset via ifconfig.

The symptoms I got (see dmesg - /var/log/messages output if
it happens again)
were a kernel declaration  that the link had failed, it then
started
an endless loop of auto-negoitiation with the switch. Could
not seem to resync
even after i unplugged the cable for a few minutes. needed
to reboot to fix.

(I will have to lock those ports to 100/full someday soon
and turn off auto.)

You might be approaching that magic threshold with what you
are doing and causing
different symptoms (directory vanishing) than what i am
seeing here.



-- 
redhat-list mailing list
unsubscribe mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list