Unfixable corruptions with Reiser 3.6

2006-06-29 Thread hanasaki
Recently had to do a reboot and had not errors, just replayed
transactions at reboot.  Just to be safe, I rebooted into Knoppix 5.0x
and did a reiserfsck which reported there were errors that needed to be
fixed with --rebuild-tree  The failed output of this is below.  This has
happened quite often and I have done a full reinstall several times.
This is much more of an issue than ever was experienced with ext3 or
even ext2.

///

216224 directory entries were hashed with r5 hash.
r5 hash is selected
Flushing..finished
Read blocks (but not data blocks) 1049994
Leaves among those 44826
- corrected leaves 1
- leaves all contents of which could not be
saved and deleted 3
Objectids found 215800

uname -a  = a custom kernel from kernel.org download and build
Linux deskstation 2.6.17.1hanaden #1 SMP PREEMPT Wed Jun 28 18:34:21 CDT
2006 i686 GNU/Linux

Has been occurring with lower kernel numbers and those that come with
both Debian and Ubuntu


How do deal with : rebuild-tree gives leaves all contents of which could not be,saved and deleted?

2006-06-29 Thread hanasaki
Recently had to do a reboot and had not errors, just replayed
transactions at reboot.  Just to be safe, I rebooted into Knoppix 5.0x
and did a reiserfsck which reported there were errors that needed to be
fixed with --rebuild-tree  The failed output of this is below.  This has
happened quite often and I have done a full reinstall several times.
This is much more of an issue than ever was experienced with ext3 or
even ext2.

///

216224 directory entries were hashed with r5 hash.
r5 hash is selected
Flushing..finished
Read blocks (but not data blocks) 1049994
Leaves among those 44826
- corrected leaves 1
- leaves all contents of which could not be
saved and deleted 3
Objectids found 215800

uname -a  = a custom kernel from kernel.org download and build
Linux deskstation 2.6.17.1hanaden #1 SMP PREEMPT Wed Jun 28 18:34:21 CDT
2006 i686 GNU/Linux

Has been occurring with lower kernel numbers and those that come with
both Debian and Ubuntu


v3.6 vs v4? and how to migrate?

2006-06-29 Thread hanasaki
Is Reiser v4 production ready?
What is the procedure for migrating 3 = 4?
What are the reasons to migrate 3 = 4?
What are the reasons to stay on 3?

TIA


Re: How do deal with : rebuild-tree gives leaves all contents of which could not be,saved and deleted?

2006-06-29 Thread hanasaki


Hans Reiser wrote:
 Vladimir V. Saveliev wrote:
 
 Hello

 On Thu, 2006-06-29 at 14:51 -0500, hanasaki wrote:
  

 Recently had to do a reboot and had not errors, just replayed
 transactions at reboot.  Just to be safe, I rebooted into Knoppix 5.0x
 and did a reiserfsck which reported there were errors that needed to be
 fixed with --rebuild-tree  The failed output of this is below.  This has
 happened quite often and I have done a full reinstall several times.
 This is much more of an issue than ever was experienced with ext3 or
 even ext2.

 ///

 216224 directory entries were hashed with r5 hash.
r5 hash is selected
 Flushing..finished
Read blocks (but not data blocks) 1049994
Leaves among those 44826
- corrected leaves 1
- leaves all contents of which could not be
 saved and deleted 3


 This is only information. reiserfsck was not able to recover content of
 a node.

Objectids found 215800

 uname -a  = a custom kernel from kernel.org download and build
 Linux deskstation 2.6.17.1hanaden #1 SMP PREEMPT Wed Jun 28 18:34:21 CDT
 2006 i686 GNU/Linux

 Has been occurring with lower kernel numbers and those that come with
 both Debian and Ubuntu

   

 Fix the message to be more clear then.

Running rebuild-tree gives the same error even if run three times in a
row.  Is this OK?  Is it just information or is there something on the
disk potentially corrupt in the data (not the file system integrity)
based on this msg?

What do you mean fix the message?



Re: --rebuild-tree always finds errors --check is ok

2005-01-07 Thread hanasaki
Could you outline exactly what takes place on a rebuild-tree?
I was under the incorrect assumption that if a rebuild-tree is 100% 
successful then the FS is ok and a subsequent rebuild-tree will have 
nothing to fix/report.  .

Vitaly Fertman wrote:
On Tuesday 04 January 2005 20:25, hanasaki wrote:
Version of reiserfsk
==
== From debian sarge
/sbin/reiserfsck -V
reiserfsck 3.6.19 (2003 www.namesys.com)
== also used the version in knoppix 3.7 with similar results
the output of two consecutive runs of --rebuild-tree on the same
unmounted partition are attached.  Below is the diff

rebuild-tree finds some blocks that looks like reiserfs formatted 
blocks for the first sight whereas they are not and just belongs to 
some file bodies. The consistency check reveals no valid metadata 
in them, so they are considered as not valid reiserfs formatted blocks
and left not modified on disk. This is why the second run of rebuild-tree
finds them again and tries to do all the stuff again.



Re: --rebuild-tree always finds errors --check is ok

2005-01-06 Thread hanasaki
Version of reiserfsk
==
== From debian sarge
/sbin/reiserfsck -V
reiserfsck 3.6.19 (2003 www.namesys.com)
== also used the version in knoppix 3.7 with similar results
the output of two consecutive runs of --rebuild-tree on the same 
unmounted partition are attached.  Below is the diff

diff data00-run1 data00-run0
14c14
 172168 directory entries were hashed with r5 hash.
---
 172167 directory entries were hashed with r5 hash.
Vladimir Saveliev wrote:
Hello
On Sun, 2005-01-02 at 00:55, hanasaki wrote:
Running reiser3 on kernel 2.6.10 and 2.6.9 with Debian sarge and unstable.
the --rebuild-tree always finds errors and corrects them.  even when run
more than once consecutively without mounting the partition in between.
Please provide reiserfsck --rebuild-tree output.
What is version of your reiserfsck? (reiserfsck -V)

--check says all is good.




### Pass 0 ###
block 254411: The number of items (21) is incorrect, should be (1) - corrected
block 254411: The free space (1) is incorrect, should be (2256) - corrected
pass0: vpf-10110: block 254411, item (0): Unknown item type found [0 251658496 
0x1001800 ??? (15)] - deleted
block 1574493: The number of items (18) is incorrect, should be (0) - corrected
block 1574493: The free space (1184) is incorrect, should be (4072) - corrected
block 2206239: The number of items (1) is incorrect, should be (0) - corrected
block 2206239: The free space (0) is incorrect, should be (4072) - corrected
block 2844875: The number of items (2) is incorrect, should be (1) - corrected
block 2844875: The free space (0) is incorrect, should be (4048) - corrected
pass0: vpf-10110: block 2844875, item (0): Unknown item type found [16777472 
16780544 0x200 ??? (15)] - deleted
block 3326501: The number of items (1) is incorrect, should be (0) - corrected
block 3326501: The free space (0) is incorrect, should be (4072) - corrected
172167 directory entries were hashed with r5 hash.
### Pass 1 ###
### Pass 2 ###
### Pass 3 #
### Pass 3a (lost+found pass) #
### Pass 0 ###
block 254411: The number of items (21) is incorrect, should be (1) - corrected
block 254411: The free space (1) is incorrect, should be (2256) - corrected
pass0: vpf-10110: block 254411, item (0): Unknown item type found [0 251658496 
0x1001800 ??? (15)] - deleted
block 1574493: The number of items (18) is incorrect, should be (0) - corrected
block 1574493: The free space (1184) is incorrect, should be (4072) - corrected
block 2206239: The number of items (1) is incorrect, should be (0) - corrected
block 2206239: The free space (0) is incorrect, should be (4072) - corrected
block 2844875: The number of items (2) is incorrect, should be (1) - corrected
block 2844875: The free space (0) is incorrect, should be (4048) - corrected
pass0: vpf-10110: block 2844875, item (0): Unknown item type found [16777472 
16780544 0x200 ??? (15)] - deleted
block 3326501: The number of items (1) is incorrect, should be (0) - corrected
block 3326501: The free space (0) is incorrect, should be (4072) - corrected
172168 directory entries were hashed with r5 hash.
### Pass 1 ###
### Pass 2 ###
### Pass 3 #
### Pass 3a (lost+found pass) #


--rebuild-tree always finds errors --check is ok

2005-01-01 Thread hanasaki
Running reiser3 on kernel 2.6.10 and 2.6.9 with Debian sarge and unstable.
the --rebuild-tree always finds errors and corrects them.  even when run
more than once consecutively without mounting the partition in between.
--check says all is good.



--rebuild-tree always finds errors --check is ok

2004-12-30 Thread hanasaki
Running reiser3 on kernel 2.6.10 and 2.6.9 with Debian sarge and unstable.
the --rebuild-tree always finds errors and corrects them.  even when run 
more than once consecutively without mounting the partition in between.

--check says all is good.