Re: [Samba] Contradiction in samba documentation

2004-05-20 Thread Clint Sharp
Sahibzada Junaid Noor wrote:
Hi,
 I have found some contradictions in the samba
documentation. i am writing them down here so if you
can please verify them.
 in heading 4.3.3 of the documentation it says
  When samba is operating in security  = domain mode
, the samba server has a domain security trust account
( a machine account) and causes all authentication
requests to be passed through to the domain
controllers.
ok this means the windows domain controller is going
to do the authentication, authorizing stuff.
now look here
under heading 7.3 there is a note which says
 when samba is configured to use an LDAP , or other
indentity management and or directory service , it is
samba that continues to perform user and machine
authentication. it should be noted that the LDAP
server does not perform authentication handling in
place of what samba is designed to do
now what does this means?
according to 4.3.3 samba sends all authentication
requests to the windows AD. in 7.3 it says that it
doesnt send requests at all. then why will it use an
LDAP backend?
plz comment on this.
=
 Sahibzada Junaid Noor  
 Ph   #  (+92) (051) 5950 940
 Cell #   (+92) (0333) 5223586
 Qazi plaza,Third Floor,Commerical Market,Chaklala Scheme 3,
 Rawalpindi
 Islamic Republic of Pakistan 

 

I didn't lookup the documentation you're referring to, but to answer 
your question, LDAP authentication would not be performed in security = 
domain.  Security = domain is designed to allow your Samba server to 
authenticate against a Windows NT4 controlled domain (for Active 
Directory see security = ads, and for all options, please see the 
smb.conf manpage).

Clint
--
To unsubscribe from this list go to the following URL and read the
instructions:  http://lists.samba.org/mailman/listinfo/samba


[Samba] Contradiction in samba documentation

2004-05-18 Thread Sahibzada Junaid Noor
Hi,

  I have found some contradictions in the samba
documentation. i am writing them down here so if you
can please verify them.

  in heading 4.3.3 of the documentation it says

   When samba is operating in security  = domain mode
, the samba server has a domain security trust account
( a machine account) and causes all authentication
requests to be passed through to the domain
controllers.

ok this means the windows domain controller is going
to do the authentication, authorizing stuff.

 now look here

 under heading 7.3 there is a note which says

 when samba is configured to use an LDAP , or other
indentity management and or directory service , it is
samba that continues to perform user and machine
authentication. it should be noted that the LDAP
server does not perform authentication handling in
place of what samba is designed to do

now what does this means?

according to 4.3.3 samba sends all authentication
requests to the windows AD. in 7.3 it says that it
doesnt send requests at all. then why will it use an
LDAP backend?

plz comment on this.

=

  Sahibzada Junaid Noor  
  Ph   #  (+92) (051) 5950 940
  Cell #   (+92) (0333) 5223586
  Qazi plaza,Third Floor,Commerical Market,Chaklala Scheme 3,
  Rawalpindi
  Islamic Republic of Pakistan 









__
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! - Internet access at a great low price.
http://promo.yahoo.com/sbc/
-- 
To unsubscribe from this list go to the following URL and read the
instructions:  http://lists.samba.org/mailman/listinfo/samba