Re: 7u40 Review Request for 8017173: XMLCipher with RSA_OAEP Key Transport algorithm can't be instantiated

2013-07-09 Thread Vincent Ryan
Your fix looks good.


On 8 Jul 2013, at 21:48, Sean Mullan wrote:

 Hi Xuelei,
 
 Can you please review my fix for JDK-8017173? This is a regression introduced 
 in 7u25. It does not affect JDK 8, because the recent fix for JDK-8011547 to 
 integrate the Apache Santuario release 1.5.4 also fixed this issue. However, 
 I am not backporting the JDK 8 code, which is more complicated and higher 
 risk (see the comments in the bug for more information). For 7u40, this is a 
 one line fix which reverts to the code in 7u21 to minimize the risk.
 
 webrev: http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~mullan/webrevs/8017173/webrev.00/
 
 Thanks,
 Sean



7u40 Review Request for 8017173: XMLCipher with RSA_OAEP Key Transport algorithm can't be instantiated

2013-07-08 Thread Sean Mullan

Hi Xuelei,

Can you please review my fix for JDK-8017173? This is a regression 
introduced in 7u25. It does not affect JDK 8, because the recent fix for 
JDK-8011547 to integrate the Apache Santuario release 1.5.4 also fixed 
this issue. However, I am not backporting the JDK 8 code, which is more 
complicated and higher risk (see the comments in the bug for more 
information). For 7u40, this is a one line fix which reverts to the code 
in 7u21 to minimize the risk.


webrev: http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~mullan/webrevs/8017173/webrev.00/

Thanks,
Sean


Re: 7u40 Review Request for 8017173: XMLCipher with RSA_OAEP Key Transport algorithm can't be instantiated

2013-07-08 Thread Xuelei Fan
Looks fine to me.

Xuelei

On 7/9/2013 4:48 AM, Sean Mullan wrote:
 Hi Xuelei,
 
 Can you please review my fix for JDK-8017173? This is a regression
 introduced in 7u25. It does not affect JDK 8, because the recent fix for
 JDK-8011547 to integrate the Apache Santuario release 1.5.4 also fixed
 this issue. However, I am not backporting the JDK 8 code, which is more
 complicated and higher risk (see the comments in the bug for more
 information). For 7u40, this is a one line fix which reverts to the code
 in 7u21 to minimize the risk.
 
 webrev: http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~mullan/webrevs/8017173/webrev.00/
 
 Thanks,
 Sean