[RESULT] [VOTE] Moving the Sling Management Console to Apache Felix

2008-05-13 Thread Felix Meschberger 
(Crossposting to Sling Dev List for information)

Hi all,

Time to tally this vote (binding votes marked with *):

   +1 Marcel Offermans*
   +1 Alex Karasulu*
   +1 Alin Dreghiciu
   +1 Stuart McCulloch*
   +1 Richard Hall*
   +1 Carsten Ziegeler*
   +1 Rob Walker*
   +1 Felix Meschberger*

So this vote passes with 8 +1, no 0 and no -1 votes. I will not follow
up with the Incubator PMC to make sure we can make this move.
 
Thanks to all who voted.

Regards
Felix


Am Mittwoch, den 07.05.2008, 21:52 +0200 schrieb Felix Meschberger:
 Hi all,
 
 After an initial round of discussion and letting it almost be forgotten,
 we should finally start to get this moving again.
 
 As noted in [1] the incubating Apache Sling project has a module - a
 single bundle - which provides a Web Based Management Console. The base
 bundle allows mainly for OSGi management such as bundle lifecycle
 management, configuration, etc. But the console is in fact extensible
 and more functionality may easily be plugged into it.
 
 Members of the Felix and Sling community met at ApacheCon in Amsterdam
 and and came to the conclusion, that the Apache Felix project would be
 the natural location for such a management console. Mainly because
 people looking for OSGi stuff would turn to Felix and not primarily to
 Sling.
 
 There is no release yet of the Sling Management Console and there are a
 number of open issues [2], which should be fixed/implemented before a
 first release of the console. Nevertheless the console is already usable
 in its current state and therefore, I think we may just move it as is
 and finish it in Apache Felix.
 
 So here is the vote. As always, it will be open for 72 hours and only
 votes of Felix PMC members are binding (though anybody is cordially
 invited to vote):
 
   [+1] Yes, move the Management Console to Apache Felix
   [0]  Don't care
   [-1] No, leave it where it is
 
 Regards
 Felix
 
 [1] http://markmail.org/message/j3vafwwzyli4zrmz
 [2] http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SLING/component/12312091

[RESULT] [VOTE] Moving the Sling Management Console to Apache Felix

2008-05-13 Thread Felix Meschberger 
Hi,

(Resending with the correct subject. This really does not seem to me my
email day )

(Crossposting to Felix Dev List for information)

Hi all,


Time to tally this vote (binding votes marked with *):


+1 Padraic Hannon*
+1 Juan José Vásquez Delgado*
+1 Carsten Ziegeler*
+1 Jukka Zitting*
+1 Bertrand Delacretaz*
+1 Felix Meschberger*

So this vote passes with 6 +1, no 0 and no -1 votes. I will not follow
up with the Incubator PMC to make sure we can make this move.

Thanks to all who voted.

Regards
Felix

 
 Am Mittwoch, den 07.05.2008, 22:04 +0200 schrieb Felix Meschberger:
  Hi all,
  
  After an initial round of discussion and letting it almost be forgotten,
  we should finally start to get this moving again.
  
  As noted in [1] the incubating Apache Sling project has a module - a
  single bundle - which provides a Web Based Management Console. The base
  bundle allows mainly for OSGi management such as bundle lifecycle
  management, configuration, etc. But the console is in fact extensible
  and more functionality may easily be plugged into it.
  
  Members of the Felix and Sling community met at ApacheCon in Amsterdam
  and and came to the conclusion, that the Apache Felix project would be
  the natural location for such a management console. Mainly because
  people looking for OSGi stuff would turn to Felix and not primarily to
  Sling.
  
  There is no release yet of the Sling Management Console and there are a
  number of open issues [2], which should be fixed/implemented before a
  first release of the console. Nevertheless the console is already usable
  in its current state and therefore, I think we may just move it as is
  and finish it in Apache Felix.
  
  So here is the vote. As always, it will be open for 72 hours and only
  votes of Sling PPMC members are binding (though anybody is cordially
  invited to vote):
  
[+1] Yes, move the Management Console to Apache Felix
[0]  Don't care
[-1] No, keep it in Sling
  
  Regards
  Felix
  
  PS: A paralell vote has been started on the Felix Dev list [3] to ask
  whether Felix would be willing to take over the console.
  
  [1] http://markmail.org/message/tizwcfggwcrnngei
  [2] http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SLING/component/12312091
  [3] http://markmail.org/message/ex6wjqowp7psomv4