Re: SI- points in the same place on the same model? I have doubts but...

2013-01-09 Thread Gideon Klindt
OK, well either way, I was getting some flack blown at me about co-points
and SDS modeling and how it's a horrible practice. I've been creating
forced hard edges in other packages (and Si) this way for some time on low
density models with no issues other then it being harder to select points
when a model is not sub-divided.

See- the slice tool and several other tools auto merge points in a funky
way in modo if you have some points living in the same place. They say I'm
a horrible modeler (which I have no defense against ;) ) and I say no- this
tool has a bug- so fix it or list it as a known limitation!

Luckily, the developer (lux) seems to agree it's an issue.

Anyway, thanks for the clarification on the co-points!

-g

On Wed, Jan 9, 2013 at 12:27 PM, Leonard Koch wrote:

> Of course they can. Whenever you select a face on a geometry and hit
> ctrl+d you have at least 3 points that each have an identical twin. SI is
> totally fine with it.
>
>
> On Wed, Jan 9, 2013 at 9:08 PM, Gideon Klindt wrote:
>
>> Hi-
>>
>> Just modeling in another package (modo) and came into a bit of an
>> argument over a tool that was incorrectly merging points on a mesh when
>> sliced.
>>
>> I was told the issue was that I had points, on the same layer/mesh that
>> were in the same place (was trying to make a forced SDS hard edge).
>>
>> Now, AFAIK, in SI, points, at least on the same geo, can't technically
>> exist in the same spot- correct? Or am I wrong and misinformed?
>>
>> Just checking a slight technicality...
>>
>> Thanks,
>> -g
>>
>> --
>> Gideon D. Klindt
>> gideonklindt.com
>
>
>


-- 
Gideon D. Klindt
gideonklindt.com


Re: SI- points in the same place on the same model? I have doubts but...

2013-01-09 Thread Leonard Koch
Of course they can. Whenever you select a face on a geometry and hit ctrl+d
you have at least 3 points that each have an identical twin. SI is totally
fine with it.


On Wed, Jan 9, 2013 at 9:08 PM, Gideon Klindt wrote:

> Hi-
>
> Just modeling in another package (modo) and came into a bit of an argument
> over a tool that was incorrectly merging points on a mesh when sliced.
>
> I was told the issue was that I had points, on the same layer/mesh that
> were in the same place (was trying to make a forced SDS hard edge).
>
> Now, AFAIK, in SI, points, at least on the same geo, can't technically
> exist in the same spot- correct? Or am I wrong and misinformed?
>
> Just checking a slight technicality...
>
> Thanks,
> -g
>
> --
> Gideon D. Klindt
> gideonklindt.com


SI- points in the same place on the same model? I have doubts but...

2013-01-09 Thread Gideon Klindt
Hi-

Just modeling in another package (modo) and came into a bit of an argument
over a tool that was incorrectly merging points on a mesh when sliced.

I was told the issue was that I had points, on the same layer/mesh that
were in the same place (was trying to make a forced SDS hard edge).

Now, AFAIK, in SI, points, at least on the same geo, can't technically
exist in the same spot- correct? Or am I wrong and misinformed?

Just checking a slight technicality...

Thanks,
-g

-- 
Gideon D. Klindt
gideonklindt.com