Re: Indexing and Query time boosting together
Hey Jack, Thank you so much for your reply. This is very useful. Thanks again, Dhaivat Dave On Fri, Aug 2, 2013 at 8:04 PM, Jack Krupansky wrote: > "product promotions" = "query elevation" > > See: > http://wiki.apache.org/solr/**QueryElevationComponent<http://wiki.apache.org/solr/QueryElevationComponent> > https://cwiki.apache.org/**confluence/display/solr/The+** > Query+Elevation+Component<https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/solr/The+Query+Elevation+Component> > > Or, boost the query using a function query referencing an external file > field that gets updated for promotions. > > -- Jack Krupansky > > -Original Message- From: dhaivat dave > Sent: Friday, August 02, 2013 9:17 AM > To: solr-user@lucene.apache.org > Subject: Re: Indexing and Query time boosting together > > > Hi Erick > > Many Thanks for your reply. I got your point. one question on this: is it > possible to give more priority to those docs which has higher indexing time > boosting against query time boosting. I am trying to achieve product > promotions using this implementation. can you please guide how should i > implement this feature ? > > Many Thanks, > Dhaivat Dave > > On Fri, Aug 2, 2013 at 5:34 PM, Erick Erickson ** > wrote: > > Add &debug=all to your query, that'll show you exactly how the scores >> are calculated. But the most obvious thing is that you're boosting >> on the titleName field in your query, which for doc 123 does NOT >> contain "phone" so I suspect the fact that "phone" is in the titleName >> field for 122 is overriding the index-time boost, especially since "phone" >> appears in both title and description for 122. >> >> Best >> Erick >> >> >> On Fri, Aug 2, 2013 at 7:53 AM, dhaivat dave wrote: >> >> > Hello All, >> > >> > I want to boost certain products on particular keywords. for this i am >> > using solr's indexing time boosting feature. i have given index time >> > boosting with "1.0" value to all documents in my solr indices. now what >> > i >> > am doing is when user want to boost certain product i just increase > >> index >> > time boosting value to 10.0 of that particular product only. now the >> > problem is: i have also used query time boosting (for boosting documents >> > when searched term found directly in title field) and so even i have >> > increase the indexing time boosting value of the particular product it >> > appears after query time boosted product. >> > >> > consider following example: >> > >> > - I have indexed couple document related to mobile phone (nokia,samsung >> and >> > so on) >> > - All the documents contains the title field which contains following >> value >> >*Doc1:* >> >*==* >> > >> >122 >> >Nokia Phone 2610 >> >Suprb phone >> > .. >> > >> > >> > >> >*Doc2: * >> > * ==* >> > >> > 123 >> > Samsung smwer233 >> > Samsung phone >> > .. >> > >> > >> > >> > - now if some one searches for "Phone" it will display first "Nokia >> Phone" >> > second "Samsung Phone" (by searching in and >> > field) >> > - to display "Samsung" before "Nokia" i have boost the index time value >> , >> > some thing like below >> > >> > >> > 123 >> > Samsung smwer233 >> > Samsung phone >> > .. >> > >> > >> > >> > - i am also using boosting at query time to boost the document which has >> > found terms in field >> > *"titleName:phone^4"* >> > >> > now even though i have higher boosting in samsung mobile it displays >> nokia >> > mobile first and then samsung mobile. >> > >> > can any one please guide how can i boost particular document using index >> > time boosting(it should appear first even though i am applying query > >> time >> > boosting). >> > >> > Many Thanks, >> > Dhaivat Dave >> > >> >> > > > -- > > > > > > > > Regards > Dhaivat > -- Regards Dhaivat
Re: Indexing and Query time boosting together
"product promotions" = "query elevation" See: http://wiki.apache.org/solr/QueryElevationComponent https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/solr/The+Query+Elevation+Component Or, boost the query using a function query referencing an external file field that gets updated for promotions. -- Jack Krupansky -Original Message- From: dhaivat dave Sent: Friday, August 02, 2013 9:17 AM To: solr-user@lucene.apache.org Subject: Re: Indexing and Query time boosting together Hi Erick Many Thanks for your reply. I got your point. one question on this: is it possible to give more priority to those docs which has higher indexing time boosting against query time boosting. I am trying to achieve product promotions using this implementation. can you please guide how should i implement this feature ? Many Thanks, Dhaivat Dave On Fri, Aug 2, 2013 at 5:34 PM, Erick Erickson wrote: Add &debug=all to your query, that'll show you exactly how the scores are calculated. But the most obvious thing is that you're boosting on the titleName field in your query, which for doc 123 does NOT contain "phone" so I suspect the fact that "phone" is in the titleName field for 122 is overriding the index-time boost, especially since "phone" appears in both title and description for 122. Best Erick On Fri, Aug 2, 2013 at 7:53 AM, dhaivat dave wrote: > Hello All, > > I want to boost certain products on particular keywords. for this i am > using solr's indexing time boosting feature. i have given index time > boosting with "1.0" value to all documents in my solr indices. now what > i > am doing is when user want to boost certain product i just increase > index > time boosting value to 10.0 of that particular product only. now the > problem is: i have also used query time boosting (for boosting documents > when searched term found directly in title field) and so even i have > increase the indexing time boosting value of the particular product it > appears after query time boosted product. > > consider following example: > > - I have indexed couple document related to mobile phone (nokia,samsung and > so on) > - All the documents contains the title field which contains following value >*Doc1:* >*==* > >122 >Nokia Phone 2610 >Suprb phone > .. > > > >*Doc2: * > * ==* > > 123 > Samsung smwer233 > Samsung phone > .. > > > > - now if some one searches for "Phone" it will display first "Nokia Phone" > second "Samsung Phone" (by searching in and > field) > - to display "Samsung" before "Nokia" i have boost the index time value , > some thing like below > > > 123 > Samsung smwer233 > Samsung phone > .. > > > > - i am also using boosting at query time to boost the document which has > found terms in field > *"titleName:phone^4"* > > now even though i have higher boosting in samsung mobile it displays nokia > mobile first and then samsung mobile. > > can any one please guide how can i boost particular document using index > time boosting(it should appear first even though i am applying query > time > boosting). > > Many Thanks, > Dhaivat Dave > -- Regards Dhaivat
Re: Indexing and Query time boosting together
Hi Erick Many Thanks for your reply. I got your point. one question on this: is it possible to give more priority to those docs which has higher indexing time boosting against query time boosting. I am trying to achieve product promotions using this implementation. can you please guide how should i implement this feature ? Many Thanks, Dhaivat Dave On Fri, Aug 2, 2013 at 5:34 PM, Erick Erickson wrote: > Add &debug=all to your query, that'll show you exactly how the scores > are calculated. But the most obvious thing is that you're boosting > on the titleName field in your query, which for doc 123 does NOT > contain "phone" so I suspect the fact that "phone" is in the titleName > field for 122 is overriding the index-time boost, especially since "phone" > appears in both title and description for 122. > > Best > Erick > > > On Fri, Aug 2, 2013 at 7:53 AM, dhaivat dave wrote: > > > Hello All, > > > > I want to boost certain products on particular keywords. for this i am > > using solr's indexing time boosting feature. i have given index time > > boosting with "1.0" value to all documents in my solr indices. now what i > > am doing is when user want to boost certain product i just increase index > > time boosting value to 10.0 of that particular product only. now the > > problem is: i have also used query time boosting (for boosting documents > > when searched term found directly in title field) and so even i have > > increase the indexing time boosting value of the particular product it > > appears after query time boosted product. > > > > consider following example: > > > > - I have indexed couple document related to mobile phone (nokia,samsung > and > > so on) > > - All the documents contains the title field which contains following > value > >*Doc1:* > >*==* > > > >122 > >Nokia Phone 2610 > >Suprb phone > > .. > > > > > > > >*Doc2: * > > * ==* > > > > 123 > > Samsung smwer233 > > Samsung phone > > .. > > > > > > > > - now if some one searches for "Phone" it will display first "Nokia > Phone" > > second "Samsung Phone" (by searching in and > > field) > > - to display "Samsung" before "Nokia" i have boost the index time value > , > > some thing like below > > > > > > 123 > > Samsung smwer233 > > Samsung phone > > .. > > > > > > > > - i am also using boosting at query time to boost the document which has > > found terms in field > > *"titleName:phone^4"* > > > > now even though i have higher boosting in samsung mobile it displays > nokia > > mobile first and then samsung mobile. > > > > can any one please guide how can i boost particular document using index > > time boosting(it should appear first even though i am applying query time > > boosting). > > > > Many Thanks, > > Dhaivat Dave > > > -- Regards Dhaivat
Re: Indexing and Query time boosting together
Add &debug=all to your query, that'll show you exactly how the scores are calculated. But the most obvious thing is that you're boosting on the titleName field in your query, which for doc 123 does NOT contain "phone" so I suspect the fact that "phone" is in the titleName field for 122 is overriding the index-time boost, especially since "phone" appears in both title and description for 122. Best Erick On Fri, Aug 2, 2013 at 7:53 AM, dhaivat dave wrote: > Hello All, > > I want to boost certain products on particular keywords. for this i am > using solr's indexing time boosting feature. i have given index time > boosting with "1.0" value to all documents in my solr indices. now what i > am doing is when user want to boost certain product i just increase index > time boosting value to 10.0 of that particular product only. now the > problem is: i have also used query time boosting (for boosting documents > when searched term found directly in title field) and so even i have > increase the indexing time boosting value of the particular product it > appears after query time boosted product. > > consider following example: > > - I have indexed couple document related to mobile phone (nokia,samsung and > so on) > - All the documents contains the title field which contains following value >*Doc1:* >*==* > >122 >Nokia Phone 2610 >Suprb phone > .. > > > >*Doc2: * > * ==* > > 123 > Samsung smwer233 > Samsung phone > .. > > > > - now if some one searches for "Phone" it will display first "Nokia Phone" > second "Samsung Phone" (by searching in and > field) > - to display "Samsung" before "Nokia" i have boost the index time value , > some thing like below > > > 123 > Samsung smwer233 > Samsung phone > .. > > > > - i am also using boosting at query time to boost the document which has > found terms in field > *"titleName:phone^4"* > > now even though i have higher boosting in samsung mobile it displays nokia > mobile first and then samsung mobile. > > can any one please guide how can i boost particular document using index > time boosting(it should appear first even though i am applying query time > boosting). > > Many Thanks, > Dhaivat Dave >
Indexing and Query time boosting together
Hello All, I want to boost certain products on particular keywords. for this i am using solr's indexing time boosting feature. i have given index time boosting with "1.0" value to all documents in my solr indices. now what i am doing is when user want to boost certain product i just increase index time boosting value to 10.0 of that particular product only. now the problem is: i have also used query time boosting (for boosting documents when searched term found directly in title field) and so even i have increase the indexing time boosting value of the particular product it appears after query time boosted product. consider following example: - I have indexed couple document related to mobile phone (nokia,samsung and so on) - All the documents contains the title field which contains following value *Doc1:* *==* 122 Nokia Phone 2610 Suprb phone .. *Doc2: * * ==* 123 Samsung smwer233 Samsung phone .. - now if some one searches for "Phone" it will display first "Nokia Phone" second "Samsung Phone" (by searching in and field) - to display "Samsung" before "Nokia" i have boost the index time value , some thing like below 123 Samsung smwer233 Samsung phone .. - i am also using boosting at query time to boost the document which has found terms in field *"titleName:phone^4"* now even though i have higher boosting in samsung mobile it displays nokia mobile first and then samsung mobile. can any one please guide how can i boost particular document using index time boosting(it should appear first even though i am applying query time boosting). Many Thanks, Dhaivat Dave
