Re: Results of facet differs with change in facet.limit.
OK, this is strange on the face of it. Is there any chance you could create a test case that fails? Even if it only fails a small percentage of the time... Best, Erick On Wed, May 4, 2016 at 3:02 AM, Modassar Ather wrote: > The "val1" is same for both the test with limit 100 and 200 so the > following is true. > > limit=100 > 1225 > 1082 > 1076 > > limit=200 > 1366 > 1321 > 1315 > > This I have noticed irrespective of facet.limit too. Please refer to my > previous mail for the example. > > Thanks, > Modassar > > On Wed, May 4, 2016 at 3:01 PM, Toke Eskildsen > wrote: > >> On Mon, 2016-05-02 at 15:53 +0530, Modassar Ather wrote: >> > E.g. >> > Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=100 >> > Result : >> > 1225 >> > 1082 >> > 1076 >> > >> > Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=200 >> > 1366 >> > 1321 >> > 1315 >> >> Is the "val1" in your limit=100 test the same term as your "val1" in >> your limit=200-test? >> >> >> Or to phrase it another way: Do you have >> >> limit=100 >> 1225 >> 1082 >> 1076 >> >> limit=200 >> 1366 >> 1321 >> 1315 >> >> >> or >> >> limit=100 >> 1225 >> 1082 >> 1076 >> >> limit=200 >> 1366 >> 1321 >> 1315 >> >> >> - Toke Eskildsen, State and University Library, Denmark >> >>
Re: Results of facet differs with change in facet.limit.
The "val1" is same for both the test with limit 100 and 200 so the following is true. limit=100 1225 1082 1076 limit=200 1366 1321 1315 This I have noticed irrespective of facet.limit too. Please refer to my previous mail for the example. Thanks, Modassar On Wed, May 4, 2016 at 3:01 PM, Toke Eskildsen wrote: > On Mon, 2016-05-02 at 15:53 +0530, Modassar Ather wrote: > > E.g. > > Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=100 > > Result : > > 1225 > > 1082 > > 1076 > > > > Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=200 > > 1366 > > 1321 > > 1315 > > Is the "val1" in your limit=100 test the same term as your "val1" in > your limit=200-test? > > > Or to phrase it another way: Do you have > > limit=100 > 1225 > 1082 > 1076 > > limit=200 > 1366 > 1321 > 1315 > > > or > > limit=100 > 1225 > 1082 > 1076 > > limit=200 > 1366 > 1321 > 1315 > > > - Toke Eskildsen, State and University Library, Denmark > >
Re: Results of facet differs with change in facet.limit.
On Mon, 2016-05-02 at 15:53 +0530, Modassar Ather wrote: > E.g. > Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=100 > Result : > 1225 > 1082 > 1076 > > Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=200 > 1366 > 1321 > 1315 Is the "val1" in your limit=100 test the same term as your "val1" in your limit=200-test? Or to phrase it another way: Do you have limit=100 1225 1082 1076 limit=200 1366 1321 1315 or limit=100 1225 1082 1076 limit=200 1366 1321 1315 - Toke Eskildsen, State and University Library, Denmark
Re: Results of facet differs with change in facet.limit.
Thanks Erick for your response. I checked with distrib=false. I tried with a smaller result set. *Search* E.g. text_field:term AND f:val1 Number of matches : 49 *Facet:* (distrib=true) text_field:term AND f:val1 *Result* Shard1 : 47 *Facet: *(distrib=false) text_field:term AND f:val1&distrib=false *Result* Shard1 : 44 Shard3 : 2 Shard8 : 3 All other shards out of 12 shows 0 count against val1. It seems that the result of shard3 is not being added to the main result. Kindly comment. Best, Modassar On Wed, May 4, 2016 at 5:33 AM, Erick Erickson wrote: > Hmm, I'd be interested what you get if you restrict your > queries to individual shards using &distrib=false. This > will go to the individual shard you address and no others. > > Does the facet count change in those circumstances? > > Best, > Erick > > On Tue, May 3, 2016 at 4:48 AM, Modassar Ather > wrote: > > I tried to reproduce the same issue with a field of following type but > > could not. > > > stored="false" omitNorms="true"/> > > > > Please share your inputs. > > > > Best, > > Modassar > > > > On Tue, May 3, 2016 at 10:32 AM, Modassar Ather > > wrote: > > > >> Hi, > >> > >> Kindly share your inputs on this issue. > >> > >> Thanks, > >> Modassar > >> > >> On Mon, May 2, 2016 at 3:53 PM, Modassar Ather > >> wrote: > >> > >>> Hi, > >>> > >>> I have a field f which is defined as follows on solr 5.x. It is 12 > shard > >>> cluster with no replica. > >>> > >>> sortMissingLast="true" > >>> stored="false" indexed="false" docValues="true"/> > >>> > >>> When I facet on this field with different facet.limit I get different > >>> facet count. > >>> > >>> E.g. > >>> Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=100 > >>> Result : > >>> 1225 > >>> 1082 > >>> 1076 > >>> > >>> Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=200 > >>> 1366 > >>> 1321 > >>> 1315 > >>> > >>> I am noticing lesser document in facets whereas the numFound during > >>> search is more. Please refer to following query for details. > >>> > >>> Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f > >>> Result : > >>> 1225 > >>> 1082 > >>> 1076 > >>> > >>> Query : text_field:term AND f:val1 > >>> Result: numFound=1366 > >>> > >>> Kindly help me understand this behavior or let me know if it is an > issue. > >>> > >>> Thanks, > >>> Modassar > >>> > >> > >> >
Re: Results of facet differs with change in facet.limit.
Hmm, I'd be interested what you get if you restrict your queries to individual shards using &distrib=false. This will go to the individual shard you address and no others. Does the facet count change in those circumstances? Best, Erick On Tue, May 3, 2016 at 4:48 AM, Modassar Ather wrote: > I tried to reproduce the same issue with a field of following type but > could not. > stored="false" omitNorms="true"/> > > Please share your inputs. > > Best, > Modassar > > On Tue, May 3, 2016 at 10:32 AM, Modassar Ather > wrote: > >> Hi, >> >> Kindly share your inputs on this issue. >> >> Thanks, >> Modassar >> >> On Mon, May 2, 2016 at 3:53 PM, Modassar Ather >> wrote: >> >>> Hi, >>> >>> I have a field f which is defined as follows on solr 5.x. It is 12 shard >>> cluster with no replica. >>> >>> >> stored="false" indexed="false" docValues="true"/> >>> >>> When I facet on this field with different facet.limit I get different >>> facet count. >>> >>> E.g. >>> Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=100 >>> Result : >>> 1225 >>> 1082 >>> 1076 >>> >>> Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=200 >>> 1366 >>> 1321 >>> 1315 >>> >>> I am noticing lesser document in facets whereas the numFound during >>> search is more. Please refer to following query for details. >>> >>> Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f >>> Result : >>> 1225 >>> 1082 >>> 1076 >>> >>> Query : text_field:term AND f:val1 >>> Result: numFound=1366 >>> >>> Kindly help me understand this behavior or let me know if it is an issue. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> Modassar >>> >> >>
Re: Results of facet differs with change in facet.limit.
I tried to reproduce the same issue with a field of following type but could not. Please share your inputs. Best, Modassar On Tue, May 3, 2016 at 10:32 AM, Modassar Ather wrote: > Hi, > > Kindly share your inputs on this issue. > > Thanks, > Modassar > > On Mon, May 2, 2016 at 3:53 PM, Modassar Ather > wrote: > >> Hi, >> >> I have a field f which is defined as follows on solr 5.x. It is 12 shard >> cluster with no replica. >> >> > stored="false" indexed="false" docValues="true"/> >> >> When I facet on this field with different facet.limit I get different >> facet count. >> >> E.g. >> Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=100 >> Result : >> 1225 >> 1082 >> 1076 >> >> Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=200 >> 1366 >> 1321 >> 1315 >> >> I am noticing lesser document in facets whereas the numFound during >> search is more. Please refer to following query for details. >> >> Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f >> Result : >> 1225 >> 1082 >> 1076 >> >> Query : text_field:term AND f:val1 >> Result: numFound=1366 >> >> Kindly help me understand this behavior or let me know if it is an issue. >> >> Thanks, >> Modassar >> > >
Re: Results of facet differs with change in facet.limit.
Hi, Kindly share your inputs on this issue. Thanks, Modassar On Mon, May 2, 2016 at 3:53 PM, Modassar Ather wrote: > Hi, > > I have a field f which is defined as follows on solr 5.x. It is 12 shard > cluster with no replica. > > stored="false" indexed="false" docValues="true"/> > > When I facet on this field with different facet.limit I get different > facet count. > > E.g. > Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=100 > Result : > 1225 > 1082 > 1076 > > Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=200 > 1366 > 1321 > 1315 > > I am noticing lesser document in facets whereas the numFound during search > is more. Please refer to following query for details. > > Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f > Result : > 1225 > 1082 > 1076 > > Query : text_field:term AND f:val1 > Result: numFound=1366 > > Kindly help me understand this behavior or let me know if it is an issue. > > Thanks, > Modassar >
Results of facet differs with change in facet.limit.
Hi, I have a field f which is defined as follows on solr 5.x. It is 12 shard cluster with no replica. When I facet on this field with different facet.limit I get different facet count. E.g. Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=100 Result : 1225 1082 1076 Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f&facet.limit=200 1366 1321 1315 I am noticing lesser document in facets whereas the numFound during search is more. Please refer to following query for details. Query : text_field:term&facet.field=f Result : 1225 1082 1076 Query : text_field:term AND f:val1 Result: numFound=1366 Kindly help me understand this behavior or let me know if it is an issue. Thanks, Modassar
