Re: Solr cloud in 4.0 with NRT performance

2012-09-15 Thread Erick Erickson
SolrCloud should be indistinguishable from Solr w/ replication in
terms of functionality, so this should work just fine.

SolrCloud should actually (and I'm kind of guessing here) give _better_
consistency than Solr w/ replication. Consider 4 slaves all with a polling
interval of 10 minutes that just happened to start up every 2.5 minutes,
and a master that committed every minute. The slaves would always
be out-of-step with each other by up to 10 minutes.

There's a lot of work in SolrCloud to make sure that all the replicas are all
caught up before they start serving requests. An update to SolrCloud
gets passed to all the replicas before being searchable.

So just go for it G...

Best
Erick

On Fri, Sep 14, 2012 at 5:11 AM, samarth s samarth.s.seksa...@gmail.com wrote:
 Hi,

 I am currently using features like facet and group/collapse on solr 3.6.
 The frequency of writing is user driven, and hence is expected to be
 visible real time or at least near real time. These updates should be
 consistent in facet and group results as well. Also to handle the query
 load, I may have to use replication/sharding w/ or w/o solr cloud.

 I am planning to migrate to solr 4.0, and use its powerful features of NRT
 ( soft commit ) and Solr Cloud ( using Zookeeper ) to achieve the above
 requirements.

 Is a Solr Cloud with a replication level greater than 1, capable of giving
 NRT results ?
 If yes, do these NRT results work with all kinds of querying, like,
 faceting and grouping ?

 It would be great if some one could share their insights and numbers on
 these questions.

 --
 Regards,
 Samarth


Solr cloud in 4.0 with NRT performance

2012-09-14 Thread samarth s
Hi,

I am currently using features like facet and group/collapse on solr 3.6.
The frequency of writing is user driven, and hence is expected to be
visible real time or at least near real time. These updates should be
consistent in facet and group results as well. Also to handle the query
load, I may have to use replication/sharding w/ or w/o solr cloud.

I am planning to migrate to solr 4.0, and use its powerful features of NRT
( soft commit ) and Solr Cloud ( using Zookeeper ) to achieve the above
requirements.

Is a Solr Cloud with a replication level greater than 1, capable of giving
NRT results ?
If yes, do these NRT results work with all kinds of querying, like,
faceting and grouping ?

It would be great if some one could share their insights and numbers on
these questions.

-- 
Regards,
Samarth