On 5/1/10 10:38 AM, Artur Hefczyc wrote:
> Hi,
>
> I am almost finishing implementation of this XEP.
> Either I am wrong or there is a mistake in following XEP's examples:
> 7, 8 and 9 which show the server response to the user/client.
>
> Let me take the example 7 as an example ;-)
>
> Example 7. Alert Response
>
> to='berna...@hamlet.lit/elsinore'
>id='chatty2'>
> status='alert'
> from='franci...@hamlet.lit'
> to='berna...@hamlet.lit/elsinore'>
>
>
>
>
> The incorrect part in my opinion is 'to' and 'from' attributes
> in the message or/and in the amp element.
> The alert is sent back to the original message sender
> ('berna...@hamlet.lit/elsinore')
> in the above example, therefore this JID should be placed in 'from' attribute
> in
> amp element. Or I am wrong and misunderstood the XEP?
Artur, you are right, because XEP-0079 says:
###
The 'from' attribute specifies the original sender of the containing
stanza. This attribute MUST be specified for any
stanza sent from a supporting server, regardless of the recipient. It
SHOULD NOT be specified otherwise. The value of the 'from' attribute
MUST be the full JID (n...@domain/resource) of the sender for the
original stanza.
The 'to' attribute specifies the original (intended) recipient of the
containing stanza. This attribute MUST be specified for any
stanza sent from a supporting server, regardless of the
recipient. It SHOULD NOT be specified otherwise. The value of the 'to'
attribute MUST be the full JID (n...@domain/resource) of the intended
recipient for the original stanza.
###
I've corrected those examples.
/psa
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
