Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit
Arron, Thanks for responding. Things seem to be clearer now. I have a question to ask though. We all know Bananas have seeds. (So a BananaBean can have a collection of seeds.) Now I have a situation where I have to set the property of the seed bean via the JSP on submit. Lets have a seed bean public class SeedBean { public String getColor() { return color; } public void setColor(String str) { color= str; } private String color; } Now in the MonkeyBean (Which is the formbean ) can I say the following? public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class)), BananaBean.class); } I tried doing the same but it didnt work :( Thanks for your time hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2002 10:19 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit Hemant, Sorry about the issues you're having, but at face value it seems that you're almost trying too hard. Without seeing the rest of your code, it's hard to see what your generateWrappedCollection() method is trying to acheive, so I'll try to answer with code... With the collection wrapping, it's a simple one liner in the bean. For example, in all my monkey examples, they all return the collection as the indexed property type (because it's a valid indexed getter and the iterate tags can use the collection to get their thing going). All you need to do is wrap that collection directly. For example, two complete beans... public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), BananaBean.class); } public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav; } public void setFlavour(String str) { flav = str; } private String flav; } The MonkeyBean is the parent class that hold the collection. It has immediately wrapped the ArrayList in the LazyCollection, and passed it the class of the BananaBean object. You may want to keep a reference to the wrapped ArrayList, generally I don't have the need to. These classes are all but ready to rock. In the action class, query the database or whatever and populate the MonkeyBean with the BananaBean data. Serve the result to the JSP. JSP write out a list of text boxes using iterate tags. Submit this, and after the monkeybean is built, the lazy collection will grow the banana list with banana beans as the indexed requests come in. When it gets back to your action class, you'll have your collection of banana beans. Hope this helps, you know where we are if it doesn't. Arron. On Mon, 2002-07-22 at 22:59, hemant wrote: Comrades, Objective: To autopopulate forms on submit. The formbean has a collection of collections of ValueObjects. Each valueObject contains a pair of other Value Objects. Before people beat me up, The following possibilities have been dealt with: 1 No, this is not a case of reset() I have the collections initialized and things are fine. 2 It is not a case of bean being in request scope. By default the bean is in session scope (Unless we explicitly mention the action attribute that it is request scope.) [ ...cut...] I am about to give up on form auto populate as I am out of time. I will be populating them by hand but anyway... one last attempt. We dont like to lose... do we? Thanks In Advance hemant -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit
The seed beans would be child beans to the banana beans. You'd ask the monkey bean for the collection of bananas, and once you have a banana, you'd ask the banana for the list of it's seeds. So, the list becomes a member of the banana. Looking a little like this... public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav; } public void setFlavour(String str) { flav = str; } public List getSeeds() { return seedList; } private List seedList = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class); private String flav; } Nested beans are all about composition. Each nesting level will be composed of that beneath it. Monkey's don't manage seeds, they manage bananas. Seed management is up to the Banana. If there's another level, then the seed bean will take care of that. The Monkey examples of my site are an example of all this. What may be confusing is that they build objects and at times their children for sake of convenience. But the member collections themselves are always attached to the object they're concerned with. So when the request comes in, it will make the monkey object for the form. It'll then ask for the banana at the index. When the banana's made it will make the lazy wrapped list of seeds. so when an update for a seed comes in, then it will make the seed object for the banana. Once you have one level going, the rest are just as easy. From one to a hundred list levels, it's all the same. Other things come to light too... you don't have to always have the model start with monkey. Say another form which is banana specific, you can use the same banana object in another model, and it'll work just as well. Gotta love OOP :) Arron. On Wed, 2002-07-24 at 23:43, hemant wrote: Arron, Thanks for responding. Things seem to be clearer now. I have a question to ask though. We all know Bananas have seeds. (So a BananaBean can have a collection of seeds.) Now I have a situation where I have to set the property of the seed bean via the JSP on submit. Lets have a seed bean public class SeedBean { public String getColor() { return color; } public void setColor(String str) { color= str; } private String color; } Now in the MonkeyBean (Which is the formbean ) can I say the following? public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class)), BananaBean.class); } I tried doing the same but it didnt work :( Thanks for your time hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2002 10:19 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit Hemant, Sorry about the issues you're having, but at face value it seems that you're almost trying too hard. Without seeing the rest of your code, it's hard to see what your generateWrappedCollection() method is trying to acheive, so I'll try to answer with code... With the collection wrapping, it's a simple one liner in the bean. For example, in all my monkey examples, they all return the collection as the indexed property type (because it's a valid indexed getter and the iterate tags can use the collection to get their thing going). All you need to do is wrap that collection directly. For example, two complete beans... public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), BananaBean.class); } public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav; } public void setFlavour(String str) { flav = str; } private String flav; } The MonkeyBean is the parent class that hold the collection. It has immediately wrapped the ArrayList in the LazyCollection, and passed it the class of the BananaBean object. You may want to keep a reference to the wrapped ArrayList, generally I don't have the need to. These classes are all but ready to rock. In the action class, query the database or whatever and populate the MonkeyBean with the BananaBean data. Serve the result to the JSP. JSP write out a list of text boxes using iterate tags. Submit this, and after the monkeybean is built, the lazy collection will grow the banana list with banana beans as the indexed requests come in. When it gets back to your action class, you'll have your collection of banana beans. Hope this helps, you know where we are if it doesn't. Arron. On Mon, 2002-07-22 at 22:59, hemant wrote: Comrades, Objective: To autopopulate forms on submit. The formbean has a collection of collections of ValueObjects. Each valueObject contains a pair of
Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit
Arron Great answer! Will experiment with my code based on your suggestions and let you know Thanks for your time Regards hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2002 10:46 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit The seed beans would be child beans to the banana beans. You'd ask the monkey bean for the collection of bananas, and once you have a banana, you'd ask the banana for the list of it's seeds. So, the list becomes a member of the banana. Looking a little like this... public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav; } public void setFlavour(String str) { flav = str; } public List getSeeds() { return seedList; } private List seedList = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class); private String flav; } Nested beans are all about composition. Each nesting level will be composed of that beneath it. Monkey's don't manage seeds, they manage bananas. Seed management is up to the Banana. If there's another level, then the seed bean will take care of that. The Monkey examples of my site are an example of all this. What may be confusing is that they build objects and at times their children for sake of convenience. But the member collections themselves are always attached to the object they're concerned with. So when the request comes in, it will make the monkey object for the form. It'll then ask for the banana at the index. When the banana's made it will make the lazy wrapped list of seeds. so when an update for a seed comes in, then it will make the seed object for the banana. Once you have one level going, the rest are just as easy. From one to a hundred list levels, it's all the same. Other things come to light too... you don't have to always have the model start with monkey. Say another form which is banana specific, you can use the same banana object in another model, and it'll work just as well. Gotta love OOP :) Arron. On Wed, 2002-07-24 at 23:43, hemant wrote: Arron, Thanks for responding. Things seem to be clearer now. I have a question to ask though. We all know Bananas have seeds. (So a BananaBean can have a collection of seeds.) Now I have a situation where I have to set the property of the seed bean via the JSP on submit. Lets have a seed bean public class SeedBean { public String getColor() { return color; } public void setColor(String str) { color= str; } private String color; } Now in the MonkeyBean (Which is the formbean ) can I say the following? public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class)), BananaBean.class); } I tried doing the same but it didnt work :( Thanks for your time hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2002 10:19 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit Hemant, Sorry about the issues you're having, but at face value it seems that you're almost trying too hard. Without seeing the rest of your code, it's hard to see what your generateWrappedCollection() method is trying to acheive, so I'll try to answer with code... With the collection wrapping, it's a simple one liner in the bean. For example, in all my monkey examples, they all return the collection as the indexed property type (because it's a valid indexed getter and the iterate tags can use the collection to get their thing going). All you need to do is wrap that collection directly. For example, two complete beans... public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), BananaBean.class); } public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav; } public void setFlavour(String str) { flav = str; } private String flav; } The MonkeyBean is the parent class that hold the collection. It has immediately wrapped the ArrayList in the LazyCollection, and passed it the class of the BananaBean object. You may want to keep a reference to the wrapped ArrayList, generally I don't have the need to. These classes are all but ready to rock. In the action class, query the database or whatever and populate the MonkeyBean with the BananaBean data. Serve the result to the JSP. JSP write out a list of text boxes using iterate tags. Submit this, and after the monkeybean is built, the lazy
Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit
Two questions: 1 - In our situation we will be getting a *result* object with an internal list from the backend that is similar to the MonkeyBean. I would NOT be able to change it's implementation (ie:adding LazyCollections) . How could I achieve the same thing? Would I need to create to temporary list wrappers that would be used to manually insert the newly created lists ? 2 - Are the LazyCollections public now. The last I heard they were on there way to Commons. I have been checking Arrons site and have seen to mention of them. I also understand that some of the tutorials will be updated with the lazy collections instead of putting the list in session. Is this the case? Thanks hemant [EMAIL PROTECTED] on 07/24/2002 10:02:05 AM Please respond to Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] To:Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] cc: Subject:Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit Arron Great answer! Will experiment with my code based on your suggestions and let you know Thanks for your time Regards hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2002 10:46 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit The seed beans would be child beans to the banana beans. You'd ask the monkey bean for the collection of bananas, and once you have a banana, you'd ask the banana for the list of it's seeds. So, the list becomes a member of the banana. Looking a little like this... public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav; } public void setFlavour(String str) { flav = str; } public List getSeeds() { return seedList; } private List seedList = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class); private String flav; } Nested beans are all about composition. Each nesting level will be composed of that beneath it. Monkey's don't manage seeds, they manage bananas. Seed management is up to the Banana. If there's another level, then the seed bean will take care of that. The Monkey examples of my site are an example of all this. What may be confusing is that they build objects and at times their children for sake of convenience. But the member collections themselves are always attached to the object they're concerned with. So when the request comes in, it will make the monkey object for the form. It'll then ask for the banana at the index. When the banana's made it will make the lazy wrapped list of seeds. so when an update for a seed comes in, then it will make the seed object for the banana. Once you have one level going, the rest are just as easy. From one to a hundred list levels, it's all the same. Other things come to light too... you don't have to always have the model start with monkey. Say another form which is banana specific, you can use the same banana object in another model, and it'll work just as well. Gotta love OOP :) Arron. On Wed, 2002-07-24 at 23:43, hemant wrote: Arron, Thanks for responding. Things seem to be clearer now. I have a question to ask though. We all know Bananas have seeds. (So a BananaBean can have a collection of seeds.) Now I have a situation where I have to set the property of the seed bean via the JSP on submit. Lets have a seed bean public class SeedBean { public String getColor() { return color; } public void setColor(String str) { color= str; } private String color; } Now in the MonkeyBean (Which is the formbean ) can I say the following? public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class)), BananaBean.class); } I tried doing the same but it didnt work :( Thanks for your time hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2002 10:19 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit Hemant, Sorry about the issues you're having, but at face value it seems that you're almost trying too hard. Without seeing the rest of your code, it's hard to see what your generateWrappedCollection() method is trying to acheive, so I'll try to answer with code... With the collection wrapping, it's a simple one liner in the bean. For example, in all my monkey examples, they all return the collection as the indexed property type (because it's a valid indexed getter and the iterate tags can use the collection to get their thing going). All you need to do is wrap that collection directly. For example, two complete beans... public
Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit
To answer your second question, the LazyCollections aren't yet public (unless I am in some kinda coma) , they can be found in commons nightly builds.This is OO Software Craftsmanship at its best!! The code is very well documented and should be enough to get you going. regards hemant - Original Message - From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2002 11:22 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit Two questions: 1 - In our situation we will be getting a *result* object with an internal list from the backend that is similar to the MonkeyBean. I would NOT be able to change it's implementation (ie:adding LazyCollections) . How could I achieve the same thing? Would I need to create to temporary list wrappers that would be used to manually insert the newly created lists ? 2 - Are the LazyCollections public now. The last I heard they were on there way to Commons. I have been checking Arrons site and have seen to mention of them. I also understand that some of the tutorials will be updated with the lazy collections instead of putting the list in session. Is this the case? Thanks hemant [EMAIL PROTECTED] on 07/24/2002 10:02:05 AM Please respond to Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] To:Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] cc: Subject:Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit Arron Great answer! Will experiment with my code based on your suggestions and let you know Thanks for your time Regards hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2002 10:46 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit The seed beans would be child beans to the banana beans. You'd ask the monkey bean for the collection of bananas, and once you have a banana, you'd ask the banana for the list of it's seeds. So, the list becomes a member of the banana. Looking a little like this... public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav; } public void setFlavour(String str) { flav = str; } public List getSeeds() { return seedList; } private List seedList = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class); private String flav; } Nested beans are all about composition. Each nesting level will be composed of that beneath it. Monkey's don't manage seeds, they manage bananas. Seed management is up to the Banana. If there's another level, then the seed bean will take care of that. The Monkey examples of my site are an example of all this. What may be confusing is that they build objects and at times their children for sake of convenience. But the member collections themselves are always attached to the object they're concerned with. So when the request comes in, it will make the monkey object for the form. It'll then ask for the banana at the index. When the banana's made it will make the lazy wrapped list of seeds. so when an update for a seed comes in, then it will make the seed object for the banana. Once you have one level going, the rest are just as easy. From one to a hundred list levels, it's all the same. Other things come to light too... you don't have to always have the model start with monkey. Say another form which is banana specific, you can use the same banana object in another model, and it'll work just as well. Gotta love OOP :) Arron. On Wed, 2002-07-24 at 23:43, hemant wrote: Arron, Thanks for responding. Things seem to be clearer now. I have a question to ask though. We all know Bananas have seeds. (So a BananaBean can have a collection of seeds.) Now I have a situation where I have to set the property of the seed bean via the JSP on submit. Lets have a seed bean public class SeedBean { public String getColor() { return color; } public void setColor(String str) { color= str; } private String color; } Now in the MonkeyBean (Which is the formbean ) can I say the following? public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class)), BananaBean.class); } I tried doing the same but it didnt work :( Thanks for your time hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2002 10:19 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit Hemant, Sorry about the issues you're
Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit
Arron, Upon reading your reply, i modified my MonkeyBean and BananaBean to have a wrapped BananaBean List and wrapped SeedBean List respectively. I fire up the page and submit, and check for the changes in the BananaBean List in MonkeyBean but the change in seed information does not seem to be updated in the banana list upon submit. Any bonehead thing that I might have done? So when the request comes in, it will make the monkey object for the form. It'll then ask for the banana at the index. When the banana's made it will make the lazy wrapped list of seeds. so when an update for a seed comes in, then it will make the seed object for the banana. So is it possible that the new Banana and new Seed are not being created at all? and as a result the seed/banana data is not being set? Regards hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2002 10:46 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit The seed beans would be child beans to the banana beans. You'd ask the monkey bean for the collection of bananas, and once you have a banana, you'd ask the banana for the list of it's seeds. So, the list becomes a member of the banana. Looking a little like this... public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav; } public void setFlavour(String str) { flav = str; } public List getSeeds() { return seedList; } private List seedList = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class); private String flav; } Nested beans are all about composition. Each nesting level will be composed of that beneath it. Monkey's don't manage seeds, they manage bananas. Seed management is up to the Banana. If there's another level, then the seed bean will take care of that. The Monkey examples of my site are an example of all this. What may be confusing is that they build objects and at times their children for sake of convenience. But the member collections themselves are always attached to the object they're concerned with. So when the request comes in, it will make the monkey object for the form. It'll then ask for the banana at the index. When the banana's made it will make the lazy wrapped list of seeds. so when an update for a seed comes in, then it will make the seed object for the banana. Once you have one level going, the rest are just as easy. From one to a hundred list levels, it's all the same. Other things come to light too... you don't have to always have the model start with monkey. Say another form which is banana specific, you can use the same banana object in another model, and it'll work just as well. Gotta love OOP :) Arron. On Wed, 2002-07-24 at 23:43, hemant wrote: Arron, Thanks for responding. Things seem to be clearer now. I have a question to ask though. We all know Bananas have seeds. (So a BananaBean can have a collection of seeds.) Now I have a situation where I have to set the property of the seed bean via the JSP on submit. Lets have a seed bean public class SeedBean { public String getColor() { return color; } public void setColor(String str) { color= str; } private String color; } Now in the MonkeyBean (Which is the formbean ) can I say the following? public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), SeedBean.class)), BananaBean.class); } I tried doing the same but it didnt work :( Thanks for your time hemant - Original Message - From: Arron Bates [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Users Mailing List [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2002 10:19 AM Subject: Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit Hemant, Sorry about the issues you're having, but at face value it seems that you're almost trying too hard. Without seeing the rest of your code, it's hard to see what your generateWrappedCollection() method is trying to acheive, so I'll try to answer with code... With the collection wrapping, it's a simple one liner in the bean. For example, in all my monkey examples, they all return the collection as the indexed property type (because it's a valid indexed getter and the iterate tags can use the collection to get their thing going). All you need to do is wrap that collection directly. For example, two complete beans... public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), BananaBean.class); } public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav;
Re: Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit
Hemant, Sorry about the issues you're having, but at face value it seems that you're almost trying too hard. Without seeing the rest of your code, it's hard to see what your generateWrappedCollection() method is trying to acheive, so I'll try to answer with code... With the collection wrapping, it's a simple one liner in the bean. For example, in all my monkey examples, they all return the collection as the indexed property type (because it's a valid indexed getter and the iterate tags can use the collection to get their thing going). All you need to do is wrap that collection directly. For example, two complete beans... public class MonkeyBean { public List getBananas() { return bananas; } private List bananas = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(), BananaBean.class); } public class BananaBean { public String getFlavour() { return flav; } public void setFlavour(String str) { flav = str; } private String flav; } The MonkeyBean is the parent class that hold the collection. It has immediately wrapped the ArrayList in the LazyCollection, and passed it the class of the BananaBean object. You may want to keep a reference to the wrapped ArrayList, generally I don't have the need to. These classes are all but ready to rock. In the action class, query the database or whatever and populate the MonkeyBean with the BananaBean data. Serve the result to the JSP. JSP write out a list of text boxes using iterate tags. Submit this, and after the monkeybean is built, the lazy collection will grow the banana list with banana beans as the indexed requests come in. When it gets back to your action class, you'll have your collection of banana beans. Hope this helps, you know where we are if it doesn't. Arron. On Mon, 2002-07-22 at 22:59, hemant wrote: Comrades, Objective: To autopopulate forms on submit. The formbean has a collection of collections of ValueObjects. Each valueObject contains a pair of other Value Objects. Before people beat me up, The following possibilities have been dealt with: 1 No, this is not a case of reset() I have the collections initialized and things are fine. 2 It is not a case of bean being in request scope. By default the bean is in session scope (Unless we explicitly mention the action attribute that it is request scope.) [ ...cut...] I am about to give up on form auto populate as I am out of time. I will be populating them by hand but anyway... one last attempt. We dont like to lose... do we? Thanks In Advance hemant -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Wrapping Collections in LazyList to auto-populate form on Submit
Comrades, Objective: To autopopulate forms on submit. The formbean has a collection of collections of ValueObjects. Each valueObject contains a pair of other Value Objects. Before people beat me up, The following possibilities have been dealt with: 1 No, this is not a case of reset() I have the collections initialized and things are fine. 2 It is not a case of bean being in request scope. By default the bean is in session scope (Unless we explicitly mention the action attribute that it is request scope.) When asked about why the nested beans were not dynamically populated even though the getter() methods are beling called, Nesting and Recursion Guru Arron Bates said the following: quote FYI This isn't a nested tags issue at all, but a nested bean-in-a-list issue which Struts had a long time before I wrote the nested tags. They're only guilty of making something quite complex very easy to do. :) Wrap your collections in org.apache.commons.collections.LazyList, provide a class definition of your child bean and it'll be sweet and ready to do without any other effort, even in the reset() method. /quote So without wasting anytime, I downloaded the nightly build and incorporated it into my IDE. I still seem to be missing something. I wrote a simple method to test the wrapping. I get the following... trace java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Null property value for 'wrappedCollections[0]' java.lang.Throwable(java.lang.String) java.lang.Exception(java.lang.String) java.lang.RuntimeException(java.lang.String) java.lang.IllegalArgumentException(java.lang.String) java.lang.Object org.apache.commons.beanutils.PropertyUtils.getNestedProperty(java.lang.Object, java.lang.String) java.lang.Object org.apache.commons.beanutils.PropertyUtils.getProperty(java.lang.Object, java.lang.String) java.lang.Object org.apache.struts.util.RequestUtils.lookup(javax.servlet.jsp.PageContext, java.lang.String, java.lang.String, java.lang.String) int org.apache.struts.taglib.logic.IterateTag.doStartTag() /trace jspSnippet nested:iterate id=voPairCollectionHolder property=wrappedCollections name=rangesform type=com.xxx.operations.mplanning.mpi.util.VoPairCollectionHolder nested:iterate id=vopair name=voPairCollectionHolder property=voPairs type=com.xxx.operations.mplanning.mpi.util.ValueObjectPair . . nested:write name=vopair property=twVo.objectType/ - nested:write name=vopair property=twVo.description/ /jspSnippet public java.util.Collection generateWrappedCollection() { if (null != this.collectionOfCollectionsOfVoPairs) { ArrayList list = new ArrayList(); //This is the entire collection. Iterator iterator = this.collectionOfCollectionsOfVoPairs.iterator(); //A LazyList List lazyList = null; ValueObjectPair voPair = new ValueObjectPair(); //A container for ValueObjectPair collection. VoPairCollectionHolder holder = null; while (iterator.hasNext()) { //Gets each collection of ValueObject Pairs. Collection voPairCollection = (Collection) iterator.next(); //Wrap collection containing ValueObjectPairs into a LazyList. lazyList = LazyCollections.lazyList(new ArrayList(voPairCollection), voPair.getClass()); //Place each ValueObjectPair collection into a VoPairCollecitonHolder. holder = new VoPairCollectionHolder(lazyList); //The list now is a collection of VoPairCollection holders. list.add(holder); //list.add(lazyList); } //Now Wrap the collection of collections of valueobject pairs in another lazylist this.wrappedCollections = LazyCollections.lazyList(list, holder.getClass()); } return this.wrappedCollections; } I am about to give up on form auto populate as I am out of time. I will be populating them by hand but anyway... one last attempt. We dont like to lose... do we? Thanks In Advance hemant