Re: [Biofuel] Farmworkers Sue U.S. EPA

2006-03-30 Thread Chip Mefford
D. Mindock wrote:
 There's no doubt that conditions for farmworkers have not improved under the 
 Bush regime. Notice that
 the organophosphate pesticides, developed by the Nazis as a weapon of war, 
 are being used everywhere.


Organophosphates have been around since the middle 1800s.
Glaucoma was being treated with an organophospate physostigmine
before to turn of the century, and many organophosphate cholinesterase
inhibitors have been around well before the Nazis.

I call shenanigans.

The problems with organophosphates are HUGE. This is all a real
mess. Yes, the Nazi's did use these for weapons. However, they
were developed well before the nazi movement, for very different
reasons.

For reasons like the aforementioned physostigmine, which was helpful
in treating glaucoma then, like it is now, a century and a half later.
It also, like many other organophosphates, is able to cross the
blood/brain barrier, which is what makes these chemicals such a problem,
and also, makes them pretty damned handy for a lot of things.
And yes, it also makes it ideal for nerve agent weapons.


 Note: some common organophosphates (OPs) = (diazinon, chlorpyrifos, 
 dichlorvos, malathion, and azamethiphos)  
 (Phosmet is the one form used in England which set off the original cases of 
 Mad Cow Disease.)

In short, Yeah, I personally feel that short of an outright ban, access
to OP pesticides needs to come under some pretty strict controls.

[Arguments concerning the relative merits of pesticides aside.]

However, whenever you pick up a really broad brush, and paint NAZI
across something, please be certain the label is appropriate.

Language that demonizes people like a lot of the agricultural scientists
that I've known and worked with my short stay in this life, might serve
only to narrow your impact well inside what might have been a broader
intended audience.

  Peace, D. Mindock

___
Biofuel mailing list
Biofuel@sustainablelists.org
http://sustainablelists.org/mailman/listinfo/biofuel_sustainablelists.org

Biofuel at Journey to Forever:
http://journeytoforever.org/biofuel.html

Search the combined Biofuel and Biofuels-biz list archives (50,000 messages):
http://www.mail-archive.com/biofuel@sustainablelists.org/



[Biofuel] Farmworkers Sue U.S. EPA

2006-03-29 Thread D. Mindock



There's nodoubt that conditions for farmworkers have 
notimproved under the Bush regime. Notice that
the organophosphate 
pesticides, developed by the Nazis as a weapon of war, are being used 
everywhere.
Note:some common 
organophosphates (OPs)=(diazinon, chlorpyrifos, dichlorvos, 
malathion, and azamethiphos)
(Phosmet is the one formused in England which set 
off the original cases of Mad Cow Disease.)
Peace, D. 
Mindock===



  
  


  Pesticide Action Network 
  Updates Service (PANUPS)See PANUPS 
  updates service, for complete information. 
  Farmworkers Sue U.S. EPA for Allowing 
  Dangerous PesticidesJanuary 26, 2004
  On January 13, 2004, farmworker groups filed a 
  lawsuit in Seattle, Washington, charging the U.S. Environmental Protection 
  Agency with ignoring important health data in 2001 when it re-approved use 
  of two pesticides extremely hazardous to farmworkers. The two pesticides, 
  azinphos-methyl (AZM) and phosmet, are highly toxic organophosphate 
  pesticides, derived from nerve agents developed during World War II and 
  among the most powerful neurotoxins routinely used in the U.S. Acute 
  exposure to organophosphates (OPs) can cause dizziness, vomiting, 
  seizures, paralysis, loss of mental function, and death.
  AZM and phosmet are used extensively in orchard crops 
  such as apples, peaches and pears, and are registered for use on 32 food 
  crops. Annually about 60 million pounds of OPs are applied to crops in the 
  U.S. The National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS) Agricultural 
  Chemical Database reports 1.5 million pounds of AZM and phosmet were 
  applied agriculturally in 2001. Although the two pesticides are used 
  across the nation, Washington, Oregon and California growers are 
  responsible for approximately half of all AZM and phosmet agricultural use 
  in the U.S.
  In addition to occupational exposures to OPs, migrant 
  and seasonal farmworkers and their families often live where pesticides 
  drift and settle, and are also exposed through "take-home" exposures on 
  clothing, cars, and skin. Tests of dust in farmworker homes in Washington 
  reported in Environmental Health Perspectives found 85% contained AZM 
  residue, and a study published in Environmental Research found four to 
  five times more chemicals in the bodies of farmworker children and people 
  living within one quarter-mile of agricultural fields in Washington state 
  than in the general population.
  The lawsuit charges U.S. EPA has continued to allow 
  uses of these pesticides without considering the risks posed to workers, 
  their children, and communities. "It is outrageous that U.S. EPA 
  authorized the use of these pesticides, putting thousands of workers at 
  risk of serious illness every year," said Erik Nicholson of the United 
  Farmworkers of America (UFW). "These two pesticides can poison so many 
  farmworkers that EPA found the risks unacceptable, but the agency still 
  allowed them to be used."
  U.S. EPA, while acknowledging that agricultural 
  pesticide poisonings are severely underreported, has estimated that 
  between 10,000 and 20,000 agricultural workers are sickened each year by 
  pesticides. No national system exists to track pesticide poisoning 
  incidents, and attorneys report that officials in California, Oregon and 
  Washington have all expressed concern for the adequacy of their state 
  reporting systems.
  A 2003 survey of farmworkers by the Washington 
  Department of Health found 75% of workers surveyed reported a job-related 
  pesticide exposure. That survey also noted that workers often do not seek 
  care for symptoms out of fear of employer reprisals, and a belief that 
  doctors downplay symptoms due to state and employer pressures. The 
  pesticide AZM is the fourth most frequent pesticide associated with 
  poisoning complaints in the state of Washington. According to UFW, about 
  30,000 workers in Washington's apple industry are potentially at risk from 
  exposure to AZM and phosmet, with thousands more working in pear and 
  cherry crops also at risk.
  The lawsuit argues that U.S. EPA analyzed the 
  estimated economic value of using these two pesticides to farmers but 
  failed to quantify the risks to people and the environment, discounted the 
  use of safe and proven alternatives to these dangerous substances, and 
  used industry-generated data without subjecting it to public comment, even 
  though a federal law allows public input.
  AZM and phosmet also pose risks to wildlife, can 
  poison fish, beneficial insects, and contaminate water supplies. USGS data 
  indicate AZM is one of the pesticides most