Randy,
Would it kill you to just be excited about a nice
performance rather than parsing a side issue down to the
last molecule standing?
- Original Message Follows -
>
> In the modern era of elite athletes competing on the elite
> circuit much longer than they used to, and athletes moving
> into Masters (seniors) competition directly from the elite
> circuit or after only a short 'retirement', it is obvious
> that the age grade tables for the upper 30's to about 45
> are totally worthless.
>
> They were probably built based on observed experience with
> athletes going into training and competion at age 42, not
> having done anything serious since high school competition
> , or never having competed in track at all to that point.
>
> It also brings into question the motives for using
> adjustment tables like this to begin with. Apparently the
> thinking is that to make an uneducated (as far as seniors
> competition) public appreciate just how great some of the
> performances are, it must be adjusted for direct
> comparison to elite athletes that the public might
> recognize (probably a wrong assumption to begin with in
> the U.S.). If that is a wrong assumption, then it would be
> just as good to reverse the tables and and for every new
> WR (REAL WR) say "that's a fantastic performance for the
> 21-year-old, which would be worth a 14.31 at age 55, which
> would be an age 55 world record!".
>
> Or if the U.S. public doesn't even recognize most
> elite-level track performance values today, adjust them to
> a sport they are more likely to recognize- "That's a
> fantastic world record clearance for Stacy Dragila!, which
> is equivalant to a 35 rebound performance in your average
> NBA Game- yeh , GO Stacy- you're now better than Wilt the
> Stilt"
>
> Best just to drop the comparisons completely and let
> performances at all age levels stand on their own merit,
> along with the results of head-to-head competition.
>
> RT
>
>
Keith Whitman
Special projects assistant
Muskingum College, New Concord, Ohio 43762
(330) 677-4631-Home