Re: [OSM-talk] Who interprets semicolon in tag values?
On Mon, Sep 30, 2013 at 9:08 PM, NopMap wrote: > The original example wasn't mine, but I think it is very common that a pub > has much later opening hours than a restaurant. Having both as part of the > same enterprise is a british speciality if I remember my visits correctly. > > And mapping them as separate POIs is the only practical and human readable > way we currently have available, that's the point. :-) > > I have to agree with this. The most common clashes I run into mapping towns in Australia; bakery/cafes (technically you could do amenity=cafe, shop=bakery) general store/cafe general store/fuel general store/post office pub/hotel (I tend to create two nodes, in roughly the right places) pub/restaurant (in the country, I take the restaurant as assumed - every pub serves meals at least some days of the week) cafe/bar A general solution that would solve these and other problems would be a relation to group parts of the same business. That way, you could have the expressiveness of precise tagging (eg, "is there a bakery near here? yes. is there a cafe near here? yes") but easy rendering: show one icon, and the renderer can decide whether it's a cafe or bakery icon. Steve ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
Re: [OSM-talk] Who interprets semicolon in tag values?
2013/9/30 NopMap > The original example wasn't mine, but I think it is very common that a pub > has much later opening hours than a restaurant. Having both as part of the > same enterprise is a british speciality if I remember my visits correctly. > > And mapping them as separate POIs is the only practical and human readable > way we currently have available, that's the point. :-) > +1, I also see it like this. If you want, group them into a site relation afterwards. The argument: one osm object for one real life thing doesn't work anyway. What is "one real life thing"? Why should the pub and the hotel (restaurant / telephone / letter box / ...) be the same thing? If one business has several shops, is that one or several "things"? cheers, Martin ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
Re: [OSM-talk] Who interprets semicolon in tag values?
Colin Smale wrote > Take a look at the lanes tagging business Thats just another very specialized single-purpose tagging scheme that cannot be generalized to connecting multiple institutions in one POI. At least not if you still want casual mappers to be able to decipher such a thing. The idea of a semicolon-delimited 2D-matrix distributed over multiple tags for general tagging makes my hair stand on edge. :-) Colin Smale wrote > One has to wonder whether your examples really reference the same POI. > Maybe within the same building, but if the opening hours, phone number > etc are different, it is starting to feel like two independent > enterprises in a common building. The original example wasn't mine, but I think it is very common that a pub has much later opening hours than a restaurant. Having both as part of the same enterprise is a british speciality if I remember my visits correctly. And mapping them as separate POIs is the only practical and human readable way we currently have available, that's the point. :-) bye, Nop -- View this message in context: http://gis.19327.n5.nabble.com/Who-interprets-semicolon-in-tag-values-tp5763540p5779443.html Sent from the General Discussion mailing list archive at Nabble.com. ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
