Assistant Professor Position

2000-11-02 Thread pgreene

The following ad will appear in the December issue of the APA 
Monitor.

Assistant Professor Position--Psychology Department, Iona 
College: anticipates one opening for a tenure-track position in the 
School of Arts and Science. A Ph.D. in psychology is required by 
the time of appointment, September 2001.

We seek a candidate with expertise in two broad areas, 
quantitative/experimental methods and 
social/organizational/industrial psychology. The candidate should 
be able to demonstrate excellence in teaching and a commitment 
to students. A record of research and publications is highly 
desirable. Courses will be at the graduate and undergraduate level 
and could be offered on the main campus in New Rochelle or any of 
the off-campus locations near New York City. 

Iona College, dedicated to personal teaching in the tradition of the 
Christian Brothers and American Catholic higher education, is an 
equal opportunity employer.

Applicants should submit a statement of their teaching philosophy, 
curriculum vitae, and the names of three references by February 1, 
2001.

Paul Greene, Ph.D.
Chair, Psychology Department
Iona College
715 North Avenue
New Rochelle, NY 10801

[EMAIL PROTECTED]
New Rochelle, New York 10801



Student Questions

2000-11-02 Thread K Jung

Hello All,
During our discussion on consciousness 2 thought-provoking questions were 
asked.
1.  While dreaming, does the hearing hemisphere light up with activity due 
to the dream's content.  Or does it integrate outside stimuli?

2.  It has been contended that there is an ironite composite in the 
olfactory region of the brain/nose that allows humans and other mammals to 
detect true north.  Said student has found conflicting articles on the 
research into this phenomenon.

Thanks,
K

Kitty K. Jung, MA
Psychology Instructor
Truckee Meadows Community College
Reno, NV
775.673.7098
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
_
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.

Share information about yourself, create your own public profile at 
http://profiles.msn.com.




Psych GRE: guess

2000-11-02 Thread Stephen Black

On Thu, 2 Nov 2000, Marie Helweg-Larsen wrote:

> Hi Tipsters
> What is the general advice regarding taking the psychology GRE. If you
> don't know the answer should you guess or leave it blank?

Kalat and Matlin (2000), who were on the committee that writes
the GRE psychology test, state that 1/4 of the questions answered
incorrectly are subtracted from the score. They conclude that
this means that:

"The test does not penalize a person for guessing. A student who
can eliminate an answer or who thinks one answer is a slightly
better guess than the others should fill in an answer".

They should know, I guess.

Kalat, J., & Matlin, M. (2000).  The GRE psychology test: a
  useful but poorly understood test. Teaching of Psychology, 
  27, 24--

-Stephen


Stephen Black, Ph.D.  tel: (819) 822-9600 ext 2470
Department of Psychology  fax: (819) 822-9661
Bishop's Universitye-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Lennoxville, QC   
J1M 1Z7  
Canada Department web page at http://www.ubishops.ca/ccc/div/soc/psy
   Check out TIPS listserv for teachers of psychology at:
   http://www.frostburg.edu/dept/psyc/southerly/tips/





institutional approval of student research

2000-11-02 Thread Deborah Hume

Greetings --
Have any of you encountered a situation in which empirical research
conducted by a student under faculty supervision (or by a faculty person for
that matter) has been "censored" by the institution?
The research is still in the proposal stage, but we cannot obtain approval
to proceed without inclusion of a statement that the results of the research
cannot be presented or published without the permission of our college. The
research concerns predictors of student retention. The student, an
outstandingly promising psychology major who hopes to go on to graduate
school, is quite frustrated because if she completes the study she may not
be able to present it or publish it in any form without "permission" --
potentially preventing her from being able to demonstrate that she has
conducted and presented or published research when she wants to apply to
graduate programs.

I feel like there are issues of academic freedom and of proper scientific
methodology involved here (I was taught -- and teach -- that the scientist
has the responsibility to make the results of empirical work publicly
available), but also the educational issue of failing to facilitate the
academic development of a student.

If you have encountered such a situation, I would appreciate hearing about
how it was handled or resolved (you can reply to me back channel at
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
If you haven't encountered anything like this but have any wise advise for
proceeding, I'd appreciate that as well.

Thanks,
Deb Hume




function of myelin

2000-11-02 Thread Vivian Hamilton

I thought I'd share a student response with you that gave me a chuckle
while recently grading midterms in my Intro Psych class...

When responding to a question regarding the function of the various parts
of a neuron, one student wrote:
"The purpose of the myelin sheath is to keep the neuron from escaping."

That was a new one on me!

Cheers,
Vivian M. Hamilton
Instructor of Psychology
Portland Community College
12000 SW 49th Avenue
Portland, Oregon 97219
(503) 977-4296
FAX (503) 977-4959



RE: Personality test for counselors

2000-11-02 Thread Grieve, Frederick

Pat Cabe wrote:

Pathology, unfortunately, may be an issue. As I understand criteria
from national bodies, counselors are supposed to possess the kind of 
emotional stability that their clients presumably lack. Our
experience with masters level counseling applicants (and 
occasionally students) is that indeed there may be 
some underlying emotional and/or psychological problems present in
some of them.

We used to joke in graduate school (based purely on anectdotal observation)
that about 50% of the students were there to help others and 50% were there
because they needed help.

--Rick

Rick Grieve, Ph.D.
Department of Psychology
Austin Peay State University
Clarksville, TN 37044

I am here to chew bubblegum and take names.


Pat Cabe

> I wonder if the NEO-PI-R would work.  Several factors would seem
> relevant to counseling (Openness, Neuroticism, Extraversion).  I am not
> sure what the problem was with the MMPI-2, but the NEO-PI-R is also less
> pathologically-oriented, which may be a benefit.
> 
> -Luke Dalfiume, Ph.D.
> Eureka College
> Eureka, IL
> 
> 

**
Patrick Cabe, Ph.D.
Department of Psychology
University of North Carolina at Pembroke
One University Drive
Pembroke, NC 28372-1510

(910) 521-6630

[EMAIL PROTECTED]

"Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty."
Thomas Jefferson

"There is the danger that everyone waits
idly for others to act in his stead."
Albert Einstein

"Majorities simply follow minorities.
Gandhi



Psych GRE:omit or guess

2000-11-02 Thread Marie Helweg-Larsen

Hi Tipsters
What is the general advice regarding taking the psychology GRE. If you
don't know the answer should you guess or leave it blank?
Marie

--
Marie Helweg-Larsen, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Psychology
Transylvania University
300 North Broadway
Lexington, KY 40508-1797
Office: (859) 281-3656
Web page: http://www.transy.edu/homepages/mhelweglarsen/index2.html





measures of critical thinking

2000-11-02 Thread Deborah Briihl

Hi!
Does anyone know of a fairly good measure of critical thinking? I would 
really like one that looks at the stages or development of intellectual and 
ethical thought (Perry, Bloom's etc.) if possible. I have two and the 
references to a few others, but I'm not sure of their reliability or 
validity. Thanks in advance!
Deb

Dr. Deborah S. Briihl
Dept. of Psychology and Counseling
Valdosta State University
Valdosta, GA 31698
(229) 333-5994
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Well I know these voices must be my soul...
Rhyme and Reason - DMB




No Subject

2000-11-02 Thread QuantyM

I am interested in reviewing and doing research on the effectiveness of
e-learning in college courses.  Has anyone done research on this?  Is there
a good source for this kind of literature?  I have our library doing a
literature search, but I think there may be a lot of things that are not
published in the usual places.
Any help would be most appreciated.

Michael B. Quanty, Ph.D.
Psychology Professor
Senior Institutional Researcher
Thomas Nelson Community College
PO Box 9407
Hampton, VA 23670

Phone: 757.825.3500
Fax: 757.825.3807





RE: Facing an ethical question

2000-11-02 Thread McKinley-Pace, Marcia

>I've been trying to help a student find faces expressing basic
>emotions for an experiment. 

Stephen,
I don't have an answer to your ethical question, but I do know that
pictures of faces are often available in catalogs of educational
materials (e.g., Child's Play) or educational stores.  I bought a poster
of 16 different faces, labelled with the appropriate emotions (at least
in my view), for $2 at a local teacher's store.  I hung it in my son's
room, but your student could easily take something like this and cut the
faces out for research purposes. 

Marcia

Marcia J. McKinley-Pace, J.D., Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Psychology
Mount St. Mary's College
Emmitsburg, MD  21727
(301) 447-5394 x4282
[EMAIL PROTECTED] or [EMAIL PROTECTED]

 



Facing an ethical question

2000-11-02 Thread Stephen Black

I've been trying to help a student find faces expressing basic
emotions for an experiment. My search took me to the lab of a
famous researcher, one whose name you could probably guess. He
had a set of these faces. Anticipating what would happen, I
pleaded poverty (i.e. no grant, which is true) in making the
request.

In reply, I received an attachment with a sample of beautiful
full-colour photographs of faces expressing basic emotions, and a
request for big bucks to get them. For face pictures, it seemed a
tad excessive. However, I suppose he has the right to recoup the
costs of development. I'm not sure he has the right to make a
profit, though, considering that these materials are intended to
advance basic research.

That's debatable, I guess. But what struck me was the explicit
instruction that the cheque be made out directly to Dr. Famous
Researcher himself. Now I don't know for sure, but it wouldn't
surprise me if he developed these materials through government
grants. It that's the case, shouldn't any money earned through
the sale of these materials go back to the grant, not to enrich
him personally?

-Stephen


Stephen Black, Ph.D.  tel: (819) 822-9600 ext 2470
Department of Psychology  fax: (819) 822-9661
Bishop's Universitye-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Lennoxville, QC   
J1M 1Z7  
Canada Department web page at http://www.ubishops.ca/ccc/div/soc/psy
   Check out TIPS listserv for teachers of psychology at:
   http://www.frostburg.edu/dept/psyc/southerly/tips/





RE: Personality test for counselors

2000-11-02 Thread Rick Froman

-Original Message-
From: jim clark [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
Sent: Wednesday, November 01, 2000 8:12 PM
To: TIPS
Subject: Re: Personality test for counselors

With regards to the question that prompted this thread, it would
seem that whatever measure is chosen, one should try not to have
too sensitive an instrument or you will be rejecting lots of
potential graduate students.

Best wishes
Jim

Since Jim has referred back to the original post, let me take this
opportunity to jump in and say that such a test is not going to be used to
screen applicants to the program, or to keep those with psychological
disorders from counseling, only to try to foresee meltdowns in counseling
placements. Now that Halloween is behind us, I certainly don't want to be
responsible for scaring anyone either. I hope most people realize that this
thread took a course far removed from the intention of the original poster.
Although many of these topics may be of general interest, I did want to
clarify the purpose for which I am seeking a test. Also, remember that the
fact that we did NOT want to screen for pathology using this test was one
reason that the MMPI was not found to be useful for the prediction in
question.

Also, although it is not responsive to my original question, I seem
compelled to address the question of whether screening graduate school
students for mental pathology is discriminatory and hypocritical for a
profession which helps people overcome such problems. Are we discriminating
unfairly against people who could make great counselor's despite a
psychological disorder? That depends on if the disorder impairs therapeutic
judgment and I would say that many of them would. Some say such experiences
could improve empathy and give unique knowledge about certain conditions.
Also experience in counseling is useful for a counselor. I think it is
important to distinguish between receiving counseling and having a mental
dysfunction that could impair therapeutic judgment. Counseling can be used
for many purposes, like clarifying issues and re-thinking challenges in your
life. If a person has overcome mental disorders to succeed in their job,
that is great but it won't show up as current pathology. If someone is
suffering from current pathology, how is it serving them or their potential
clients to allow them to practice (and practicum will be involved in a
competent graduate program)? Concerns about countertransference pale in
comparison to concerns about interpreting someone else's concerns through
the lens of my own paranoia or depression or other pathology.

Rick

Dr. Richard L. Froman
Psychology Department
John Brown University
Siloam Springs, AR 72761
e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.jbu.edu/sbs/psych/froman.htm 



Re: God, Tomlin, Szasz, and schizophrenia

2000-11-02 Thread Esther Yoder Strahan

I have some other hypotheses to put forth in the Szasz/Tomlin controversy:
 1. It was a case of two people independently stating a not very 
novel idea. There are many cases in the scientific literature, as I'm sure 
you all know, of simultaneous discovery even of much more complex concepts
 2. It was a case of "cryptomnesia" (e.g. Brown & Murphy, 1989), or 
unintentional plagiarism
 3. Tomlin knew it was from Szasz, but comics are not required to 
cite references (can you imagine what comedy routines would be like if they 
did?!!  >:))!

Esther


At 09:26 AM 11/2/00 -0500, Stephen Black wrote:
> > > Jim Guinee wrote:
>
> > > > I don't have a relevant comment, but it made me think of the latest
> > > > quote in my signature block.
> > > >
> > > > "Why is it when we talk to God we're praying,
> > > >but when he talks to us we're schizophrenic?"
> > > >  -Lily Tomlin
>
>Mike Scoles commented:
> >
> > > I believe it was Szasz, not Tomlin!
>
>Jim Guinee replied
>
> > According to the "21st Century Dictionary of Quotations," edited by the
> > Princeton Language Institute, it's Tomlin.  But, I'm aware that quotes are
> > commonly attributed to the wrong person.
>
>And a voice said to me: "Take down the Oxford Dictionary of
>Modern Quotations from your shelf". I obeyed.  It said:
>
>"If you talk to God, you are praying; if God talks to you, you
>have schizophrenia. If the dead talk to you, you are a
>spiritualist; if God talks to you, you are a schizophrenic."
>
>_The Second Sin (1973), "Schizophrenia", Thomas Szasz
>
>My theory: Tomlin ripped Szasz off and made it her own. In some
>circles we call this plagiarism.
>
>-Stephen
>
>
>Stephen Black, Ph.D.  tel: (819) 822-9600 ext 2470
>Department of Psychology  fax: (819) 822-9661
>Bishop's Universitye-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>Lennoxville, QC
>J1M 1Z7
>Canada Department web page at http://www.ubishops.ca/ccc/div/soc/psy
>Check out TIPS listserv for teachers of psychology at:
>http://www.frostburg.edu/dept/psyc/southerly/tips/
>
>
>

Esther Yoder Strahan, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Psychology
Heidelberg College
310 East Market Street
Tiffin, OH  44883-2462
(419) 448-2238
fax (419) 448-2236




God, Tomlin, Szasz, schizophrenia, and Strahan

2000-11-02 Thread Stephen Black

On Thu, 2 Nov 2000, Esther Yoder Strahan wrote:

> I have some other hypotheses to put forth in the Szasz/Tomlin controversy:

>  3. Tomlin knew it was from Szasz, but comics are not required to 
> cite references (can you imagine what comedy routines would be like if they 
> did?!!  >:))!

More scholarly? 

Now why couldn't she have said: "as the
psychiatrist Thomas Szasz once said...". It works for me. 

(Of course, my post assumed that the transmission was from
Szasz->Tomlin. What if it was Szasz who ripped off Tomlin? We
need the date of the Tomlin pronouncement.)

-Stephen

Stephen Black, Ph.D.  tel: (819) 822-9600 ext 2470
Department of Psychology  fax: (819) 822-9661
Bishop's Universitye-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Lennoxville, QC   
J1M 1Z7  
Canada Department web page at http://www.ubishops.ca/ccc/div/soc/psy
   Check out TIPS listserv for teachers of psychology at:
   http://www.frostburg.edu/dept/psyc/southerly/tips/






Re: Two questions about Likert scales

2000-11-02 Thread truhons

On the issue of comparing two groups on their responses to a Likert scale, I
came across the same issue in some of my summer research. In the military
Blacks and women rate the equal opportunity climate worse than Whites and
men. Is this because it is worse for them or do the items mean different
things to them? I used item response theory to examine their survey, and
it may be helpful in answering this question.

Stephen Truhon
Dept. of Social Sciences
Winston-Salem State University
Winston-Salem, NC 27110



Re: Psycho-politics:Bush/Skinner

2000-11-02 Thread Paul Brandon

At 8:56 AM -0500 11/2/00, John W. Kulig wrote:
>Paul Brandon wrote:
>> >Btw,was Skinner a democrat,a republican or a behaviorist?
>>
>> A radical behaviorist.
>> If he was a member of any organized political party (as opposed to
>> Democrats ;-) I'm not aware of it.
>
>That sounds reasonable. Interestingly, you can find things to please the
>left and the right in his writings . In his 1986 American Psychologist
>article "What is wrong with daily life in the western world?" (page 568-574)
>he claims "Five cultural practices have eroded the contingencies of
>reinforcement under which the human species evolved by promoting the pleasing
>effects of the consequences of behavior at the expense of the strengthening
>effects. These practices are (a) alientating workers from the consequences of
>their work ..". That's leftist lingo, and socialists say the same thing
>(socialists - contrary to stereotype, do not claim all workers should earn he
>same, rather that what they earn should be _more_ closely tied work).
>Further, his dabbling in utopian vision (Walden II, for instance) is a
>leftist idea. The left claims mankind is perfectable, and government can play
>a role perfecting people. The kibbutz and the kolholtz (russian collective)
>were all founded around this key idea.

But see Skinner's philosphy of science (William Baum, 1994 is a good source).
He was a Machian pragmatist who believed that there is no absolute truth
(as opposed to a Platonic realist).
That people are capable of improvement, and that government (or anyone else
in a position to manage contingencies) an effect that improvement, yes.
Perfection -- no.
Walden II was written as a draft for discussion -- the start of a process.

>On the other hand, in his 1986 article, the second cultural practice he
>criticizes is "(b) helping those who could help themselves .." Welfare,
>obviously, is like giving a rat a food pellet  for doing nothing.
>I like to think he was a leftist (perhaps a borderline Marxist) who
>avoided kee-jerk ideology in favor of discovering those practices that
>actually work to improve the collective.

A leftist in some senses maybe; a Marxist not.
While he would (I suspect -- I never asked him) that there is something
inherently behavioral about the labor theory of value, the basic socialist
creed
"From each according to their ability, to each according to their need"
is a direct contradiction of the principle of reinforcement.  People don't
work that way.  I once pointed this out to Paul Meehl when he accused
Skinner of Communism.

* PAUL K. BRANDON   [EMAIL PROTECTED]  *
* Psychology Dept   Minnesota State University, Mankato *
* 23 Armstrong Hall, Mankato, MN 56001  ph 507-389-6217 *
*http://www.mankato.msus.edu/dept/psych/welcome.html*





Looking for summer teaching gig

2000-11-02 Thread Robin Pearce


TIPSters--

Apologies if this is a misuse of the list, but since I see people post job
openings I figure advertising my availability isn't too out of line.

I'm a graduate student, ABD (though I haven't filled out paperwork for a
Master's) and am looking to teach a psychology course this summer in the
greater Boston area. I've been a teaching fellow for Social,
Developmental, Personality and Stats, and have taught Personality on my
own. I've gotten excellent ratings from students and the professors I've
worked with.

I'm hitting that final stretch of grad school and am really needing a shot
of what I love--teaching--to remind myself of why I'm doing this!

I'd prefer a night course, since I do have a day job, but I can be
flexible. I'd be open to teach any of the above courses, or Intro. 

My CV is available on request, and so am I, for interviews. Please, if
you have an opening or know of one, drop me a line. 

Thanks!

Robin

***
Robin Pearce  "The wit of a graduate student is like champagne.   
Boston University   Canadian champagne." 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]  --Robertson Davies
***





God, Tomlin, Szasz, and schizophrenia

2000-11-02 Thread Stephen Black

> > Jim Guinee wrote:

> > > I don't have a relevant comment, but it made me think of the latest
> > > quote in my signature block.
> > >
> > > "Why is it when we talk to God we're praying,
> > >but when he talks to us we're schizophrenic?"
> > >  -Lily Tomlin

Mike Scoles commented:
> 
> > I believe it was Szasz, not Tomlin!

Jim Guinee replied
 
> According to the "21st Century Dictionary of Quotations," edited by the 
> Princeton Language Institute, it's Tomlin.  But, I'm aware that quotes are 
> commonly attributed to the wrong person.  

And a voice said to me: "Take down the Oxford Dictionary of
Modern Quotations from your shelf". I obeyed.  It said:

"If you talk to God, you are praying; if God talks to you, you
have schizophrenia. If the dead talk to you, you are a
spiritualist; if God talks to you, you are a schizophrenic."

_The Second Sin (1973), "Schizophrenia", Thomas Szasz

My theory: Tomlin ripped Szasz off and made it her own. In some
circles we call this plagiarism.

-Stephen


Stephen Black, Ph.D.  tel: (819) 822-9600 ext 2470
Department of Psychology  fax: (819) 822-9661
Bishop's Universitye-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Lennoxville, QC   
J1M 1Z7  
Canada Department web page at http://www.ubishops.ca/ccc/div/soc/psy
   Check out TIPS listserv for teachers of psychology at:
   http://www.frostburg.edu/dept/psyc/southerly/tips/







Re: Psycho-politics:Bush/Skinner

2000-11-02 Thread John W. Kulig



Paul Brandon wrote:

>
> >Btw,was Skinner a democrat,a republican or a behaviorist?
>
> A radical behaviorist.
> If he was a member of any organized political party (as opposed to
> Democrats ;-) I'm not aware of it.

That sounds reasonable. Interestingly, you can find things to please the
left and the right in his writings . In his 1986 American Psychologist
article "What is wrong with daily life in the western world?" (page 568-574)
he claims "Five cultural practices have eroded the contingencies of
reinforcement under which the human species evolved by promoting the pleasing
effects of the consequences of behavior at the expense of the strengthening
effects. These practices are (a) alientating workers from the consequences of
their work ..". That's leftist lingo, and socialists say the same thing
(socialists - contrary to stereotype, do not claim all workers should earn he
same, rather that what they earn should be _more_ closely tied work).
Further, his dabbling in utopian vision (Walden II, for instance) is a
leftist idea. The left claims mankind is perfectable, and government can play
a role perfecting people. The kibbutz and the kolholtz (russian collective)
were all founded around this key idea.
On the other hand, in his 1986 article, the second cultural practice he
criticizes is "(b) helping those who could help themselves .." Welfare,
obviously, is like giving a rat a food pellet  for doing nothing.
I like to think he was a leftist (perhaps a borderline Marxist) who
avoided kee-jerk ideology in favor of discovering those practices that
actually work to improve the collective.

--
---
John W. Kulig[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Department of Psychology http://oz.plymouth.edu/~kulig
Plymouth State College   tel: (603) 535-2468
Plymouth NH USA 03264fax: (603) 535-2412
---
"What a man often sees he does not wonder at, although he knows
not why it happens; if something occurs which he has not seen before,
he thinks it is a marvel" - Cicero.





RE: how to handle a student situation

2000-11-02 Thread HART_CHRISTIAN

"Some expressed surprise that as a clinical person I was unsure
about how to respond and was interested in the advice of others."   

This comment from Rod's post made me think it might be useful to
educate/demystify the process for non-clinical colleagues.  I suspect that
Rod was either being a bit too modest and didn't want to appear
self-serving.  But for the record...

Although the licensing process for psychologists is at least partially
designed to make sure we can practice independently, that is not necessarily
the best option. As many of you can attest, one strategy that is drilled
into psychologists (at least in California if not every state) is "consult,
consult, consult."  Certainly, the "more heads are better than one"
philosophy is logically flawed and offers no guarantee of objectivity, in
practice it almost always provide a fresh perspective or at least a
confirmation that one has chosen a prudent course of action.

But beyond the specifics in a given situation, the process of seeking
consultation offers additional advantages.  First, no matter how skilled one
is as a clinician, one's emotional process can effectively create a blank
wall against which options do not arise.  We're all human and each of us can
probably think of moments when anxiety seized us, if only briefly.  ("Uh,
yes, let me introduce to you my best friend of over 20 years...his name
is...um...") Sometimes just knowing that one can "vent" a bit to colleagues
is enought to obviate the need

I was grateful that Rod shared the process with us. It serves to remind me
that I am not all-powerful, that if he can do it, then I can do it yet
again.  It may sound strange, but there is still a pervasive tendency to
reinforce that all-powerful healer persona. It's ego gratifying but costs a
lot in the long run.  Each time another clinician is "real" and doesn't
pretend omniscience, it frees every other clinician to do the same.  And
this must be repeated over and over.  At least that's my experience. Perhaps
clinicians with decades more experience have finally become ultimately
secure, but I would question that.

Indeed, I am most concerned about the clnicians who never ask for feedback,
who seem too eager to wrap themselves up in that cloak of invincibility
(last worn by that naked emporer with the creative tailor). Finally, Rod's
willingness to share the process is sound clinical judgment even though, as
he added, he almost immediately thought of some viable alternatives.  If
only it were true that the process of becoming a clinical psychologist
magically wiped away all the foibles that make us human, imperfect and
insecure. My favorite quote, given the number of "wounded healers" (oy!) in
psychology  Rod actually demonstrated behavior that I and others have been
taught to greatly respect for the courage it requires and the commitment to
a client's welfare it indicates.

For those interested, a book I recommend is Irv Yalom's "Love's
Executioner."  He presents the reality of clinical work through case studies
showing all of his warts and wrinkles as well as the bright, beautiful
parts.  The book serves to simultaneously demystify the clinical process by
humanizing clinicians, but in so doing, somehow manages to convey that much
more, how powerful the process can be. Beyond all that, the book is
smashingly readable.  Whether colleague or student, psychodynamic or
cognitively oriented, I only ever received rave reviews about it. Enjoy.

Cheers!
Christian

Christian Hart, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Psychology
Department of Behavioral Studies
Santa Monica College
-Original Message-
From: Roderick D. Hetzel
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: 11/1/00 1:54 PM
Subject: RE: how to handle a student situation

Hi everyone:
 
Thanks for your advice and suggestions on how to handle the student
situation.  
Because many of you have asked me to pass along any responses to my
post, let
me provide a brief summary.  

The majority of the non-clinical psychologists who responded stated that
they
usually take these situations to their clinical colleagues and get their

advice.  Some expressed surprise that as a clinical person I was unsure
about
how to respond and was interested in the advice of others.  Although I
felt a
bit incompetent after reading some of the comments, I was heartened by
the 
clinical psychologists who responded.
 
Most of the clinical psychologists who responded stated that handling
these 
kinds of situation with students is difficult for them and produces a
lot of 
anxiety, despite all of their training and experience in mental health 
treatment.  One comment in particular was a good summary of the
responses
from clinical psychologists:  "I think one of the hardest adjustments I
had to 
teaching was having to use my clinical knowledge with student problems,
and 
trying to figure out how to approach them without being inappropriate or

engaging in a dual relationship."  That comment certainly summed up my 
experience in dealing