Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie?
Hi Nick I would say grounded both ends, don't need to be connected to the antenna itself, right. JC -Original Message- From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com] On Behalf Of Nick Hall-Patch Sent: Tuesday, December 13, 2016 11:42 AM To: JC <n...@comcast.net> Cc: 'topband' <topband@contesting.com> Subject: Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie? So, is the ground wire just left "floating", JC?No electrical connection to the antenna itself? Thanks and 73, Nick VE7DXR At 11:23 13-12-16, JC wrote: >Hi Nick > >The wire will reduce loss on the transmission line given a better match >and phase. In practice you can see change on the SWR and front back. If >you have a good ground you probably won't see anything changing. > >Regards >JC > >-Original Message- >From: Nick Hall-Patch [mailto:n...@ieee.org] >Sent: Monday, December 12, 2016 10:59 PM >To: JC <n...@comcast.net> >Cc: 'topband' <topband@contesting.com> >Subject: Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie? > >What kind of improvement in performance is observed by providing a >better ground, JC? And, where would a ground wire (counterpoise?) be >connected with the DHDL antenna system? > >Thanks and 73, > >Nick >VE7DXR > > > >At 15:38 11-12-16, JC wrote: > >Hi Mike and Don > > > >The DHDL as well as few other antennas, has a hidden component. The > >bottom wire parallel to the ground is a transmission line, actually, > >any antenna parallel to the ground is a transmission line. A > >beverage antenna a is good example. > > > >The ground is the second leg of the transition line, for a K9AY loop > >it is the same, the bottom wire and the ground form a transmission > >line. The transmission line allows the Resistor and the Transformer > >to be moved to the center of the loop. The VE3DO loop is also exactly > >the >same. > > > >The same way, a DHDL antenna uses the ground to phase the two loops, > >if you elevate the DHDL high far from the ground, the patter changes. > >The DHDL is a ground dependent antenna, improving the ground with a > >ground wire bellow the antenna can fix some ground problems. > > > > > >My two cents. > > > >73's > >JC > > > >N4IS > > > >-----Original Message- > >From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com] On Behalf Of > >Don Kirk > >Sent: Sunday, December 11, 2016 10:13 AM > >To: D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> > >Cc: topband <topband@contesting.com> > >Subject: Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie? > > > >Hi Mike, > > > >Funny you should ask that. > > > >A few months ago (September) I was looking at building a smaller size > >DHDL using 4Nec2, and there were a few things I saw that I thought > >needed improvement (I saw things in the full size DHDL that I thought > >needed improvement, it was not limited to the small size DHDL I was > >trying to design). Then I started to play around with the location > >of its termination resistor as well as routing of wires, and wound up > >with what I called the Terminated Bowtie. I built one in my backyard > >but my yard is pretty small and the antenna was too close to existing > >objects (house and chain link > >fence) and I did not realize the S/N improvement that I expected, > >nevertheless based on modeling it looks like a winner (9.5 RDF and > >front to back ratio versus elevation angle very robust). > > > >I have attached the preliminary document I put together a few months > >ago for you and others to view (it might not be perfect, but should > >convey my design / thoughts). I would love someone to build one of > >these out in the open to see if the real life build provides results > >similar to the 4Nec2 modelling I did. > > > >Note: Bringing the feedline away from the antenna properly needs to > >be looked at to minimize distortion of the pattern. As I recall the > >feedline should not drop down to the ground until it's at least 5 > >feet away from the antenna, and a greater distance would be best. > >The feedline should also use choke with ground rod similar to what's > >recommend for other RX antennas we use (beverages, flags, etc.) to > >block common mode noise from making its way to the antenna feedpoint. > > > >Let me know what you think. It might not work, but sure looked good > >on paper. > > > >73, > >Don (wd8dsb) > > > >On Sun, Dec 11, 2016 at 9:41 AM, D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> wrote: > > > > >
Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie?
So, is the ground wire just left "floating", JC?No electrical connection to the antenna itself? Thanks and 73, Nick VE7DXR At 11:23 13-12-16, JC wrote: Hi Nick The wire will reduce loss on the transmission line given a better match and phase. In practice you can see change on the SWR and front back. If you have a good ground you probably won't see anything changing. Regards JC -Original Message- From: Nick Hall-Patch [mailto:n...@ieee.org] Sent: Monday, December 12, 2016 10:59 PM To: JC <n...@comcast.net> Cc: 'topband' <topband@contesting.com> Subject: Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie? What kind of improvement in performance is observed by providing a better ground, JC? And, where would a ground wire (counterpoise?) be connected with the DHDL antenna system? Thanks and 73, Nick VE7DXR At 15:38 11-12-16, JC wrote: >Hi Mike and Don > >The DHDL as well as few other antennas, has a hidden component. The >bottom wire parallel to the ground is a transmission line, actually, >any antenna parallel to the ground is a transmission line. A beverage >antenna a is good example. > >The ground is the second leg of the transition line, for a K9AY loop >it is the same, the bottom wire and the ground form a transmission >line. The transmission line allows the Resistor and the Transformer to >be moved to the center of the loop. The VE3DO loop is also exactly the same. > >The same way, a DHDL antenna uses the ground to phase the two loops, if >you elevate the DHDL high far from the ground, the patter changes. The >DHDL is a ground dependent antenna, improving the ground with a ground >wire bellow the antenna can fix some ground problems. > > >My two cents. > >73's >JC > >N4IS > >-Original Message- >From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com] On Behalf Of Don >Kirk >Sent: Sunday, December 11, 2016 10:13 AM >To: D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> >Cc: topband <topband@contesting.com> >Subject: Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie? > >Hi Mike, > >Funny you should ask that. > >A few months ago (September) I was looking at building a smaller size >DHDL using 4Nec2, and there were a few things I saw that I thought >needed improvement (I saw things in the full size DHDL that I thought >needed improvement, it was not limited to the small size DHDL I was >trying to design). Then I started to play around with the location of >its termination resistor as well as routing of wires, and wound up with >what I called the Terminated Bowtie. I built one in my backyard but my >yard is pretty small and the antenna was too close to existing objects >(house and chain link >fence) and I did not realize the S/N improvement that I expected, >nevertheless based on modeling it looks like a winner (9.5 RDF and >front to back ratio versus elevation angle very robust). > >I have attached the preliminary document I put together a few months >ago for you and others to view (it might not be perfect, but should >convey my design / thoughts). I would love someone to build one of >these out in the open to see if the real life build provides results >similar to the 4Nec2 modelling I did. > >Note: Bringing the feedline away from the antenna properly needs to be >looked at to minimize distortion of the pattern. As I recall the >feedline should not drop down to the ground until it's at least 5 feet >away from the antenna, and a greater distance would be best. The >feedline should also use choke with ground rod similar to what's >recommend for other RX antennas we use (beverages, flags, etc.) to >block common mode noise from making its way to the antenna feedpoint. > >Let me know what you think. It might not work, but sure looked good on >paper. > >73, >Don (wd8dsb) > >On Sun, Dec 11, 2016 at 9:41 AM, D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> wrote: > > > > > > > I have two flag rx ants and I was looking at the DHDL and DK6ED > > Double Loop System V2 and wondering if twisting my Flag rx ants into > > Bowties would improve the forward pattern and make them narrower > > with better front to back. > > I would just ""flip"" the termination resistor end to form a loose > > BOWTIE shape. > > I have no ant modeling software so I have no way to ponder this change. > > Maybe someone could model doing this. > > TNX es 73, Mike W3TS > > _ > > Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband > > >_ >Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband > >_ >Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband Nick Hall-Patch Victoria, BC Canada Nick Hall-Patch Victoria, BC Canada _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband
Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie?
Hi Nick The wire will reduce loss on the transmission line given a better match and phase. In practice you can see change on the SWR and front back. If you have a good ground you probably won't see anything changing. Regards JC -Original Message- From: Nick Hall-Patch [mailto:n...@ieee.org] Sent: Monday, December 12, 2016 10:59 PM To: JC <n...@comcast.net> Cc: 'topband' <topband@contesting.com> Subject: Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie? What kind of improvement in performance is observed by providing a better ground, JC? And, where would a ground wire (counterpoise?) be connected with the DHDL antenna system? Thanks and 73, Nick VE7DXR At 15:38 11-12-16, JC wrote: >Hi Mike and Don > >The DHDL as well as few other antennas, has a hidden component. The >bottom wire parallel to the ground is a transmission line, actually, >any antenna parallel to the ground is a transmission line. A beverage >antenna a is good example. > >The ground is the second leg of the transition line, for a K9AY loop >it is the same, the bottom wire and the ground form a transmission >line. The transmission line allows the Resistor and the Transformer to >be moved to the center of the loop. The VE3DO loop is also exactly the same. > >The same way, a DHDL antenna uses the ground to phase the two loops, if >you elevate the DHDL high far from the ground, the patter changes. The >DHDL is a ground dependent antenna, improving the ground with a ground >wire bellow the antenna can fix some ground problems. > > >My two cents. > >73's >JC > >N4IS > >-Original Message- >From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com] On Behalf Of Don >Kirk >Sent: Sunday, December 11, 2016 10:13 AM >To: D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> >Cc: topband <topband@contesting.com> >Subject: Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie? > >Hi Mike, > >Funny you should ask that. > >A few months ago (September) I was looking at building a smaller size >DHDL using 4Nec2, and there were a few things I saw that I thought >needed improvement (I saw things in the full size DHDL that I thought >needed improvement, it was not limited to the small size DHDL I was >trying to design). Then I started to play around with the location of >its termination resistor as well as routing of wires, and wound up with >what I called the Terminated Bowtie. I built one in my backyard but my >yard is pretty small and the antenna was too close to existing objects >(house and chain link >fence) and I did not realize the S/N improvement that I expected, >nevertheless based on modeling it looks like a winner (9.5 RDF and >front to back ratio versus elevation angle very robust). > >I have attached the preliminary document I put together a few months >ago for you and others to view (it might not be perfect, but should >convey my design / thoughts). I would love someone to build one of >these out in the open to see if the real life build provides results >similar to the 4Nec2 modelling I did. > >Note: Bringing the feedline away from the antenna properly needs to be >looked at to minimize distortion of the pattern. As I recall the >feedline should not drop down to the ground until it's at least 5 feet >away from the antenna, and a greater distance would be best. The >feedline should also use choke with ground rod similar to what's >recommend for other RX antennas we use (beverages, flags, etc.) to >block common mode noise from making its way to the antenna feedpoint. > >Let me know what you think. It might not work, but sure looked good on >paper. > >73, >Don (wd8dsb) > >On Sun, Dec 11, 2016 at 9:41 AM, D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> wrote: > > > > > > > I have two flag rx ants and I was looking at the DHDL and DK6ED > > Double Loop System V2 and wondering if twisting my Flag rx ants into > > Bowties would improve the forward pattern and make them narrower > > with better front to back. > > I would just ""flip"" the termination resistor end to form a loose > > BOWTIE shape. > > I have no ant modeling software so I have no way to ponder this change. > > Maybe someone could model doing this. > > TNX es 73, Mike W3TS > > _ > > Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband > > >_ >Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband > >_ >Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband Nick Hall-Patch Victoria, BC Canada _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband
Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie?
What kind of improvement in performance is observed by providing a better ground, JC? And, where would a ground wire (counterpoise?) be connected with the DHDL antenna system? Thanks and 73, Nick VE7DXR At 15:38 11-12-16, JC wrote: Hi Mike and Don The DHDL as well as few other antennas, has a hidden component. The bottom wire parallel to the ground is a transmission line, actually, any antenna parallel to the ground is a transmission line. A beverage antenna a is good example. The ground is the second leg of the transition line, for a K9AY loop it is the same, the bottom wire and the ground form a transmission line. The transmission line allows the Resistor and the Transformer to be moved to the center of the loop. The VE3DO loop is also exactly the same. The same way, a DHDL antenna uses the ground to phase the two loops, if you elevate the DHDL high far from the ground, the patter changes. The DHDL is a ground dependent antenna, improving the ground with a ground wire bellow the antenna can fix some ground problems. My two cents. 73's JC N4IS -Original Message- From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com] On Behalf Of Don Kirk Sent: Sunday, December 11, 2016 10:13 AM To: D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> Cc: topband <topband@contesting.com> Subject: Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie? Hi Mike, Funny you should ask that. A few months ago (September) I was looking at building a smaller size DHDL using 4Nec2, and there were a few things I saw that I thought needed improvement (I saw things in the full size DHDL that I thought needed improvement, it was not limited to the small size DHDL I was trying to design). Then I started to play around with the location of its termination resistor as well as routing of wires, and wound up with what I called the Terminated Bowtie. I built one in my backyard but my yard is pretty small and the antenna was too close to existing objects (house and chain link fence) and I did not realize the S/N improvement that I expected, nevertheless based on modeling it looks like a winner (9.5 RDF and front to back ratio versus elevation angle very robust). I have attached the preliminary document I put together a few months ago for you and others to view (it might not be perfect, but should convey my design / thoughts). I would love someone to build one of these out in the open to see if the real life build provides results similar to the 4Nec2 modelling I did. Note: Bringing the feedline away from the antenna properly needs to be looked at to minimize distortion of the pattern. As I recall the feedline should not drop down to the ground until it's at least 5 feet away from the antenna, and a greater distance would be best. The feedline should also use choke with ground rod similar to what's recommend for other RX antennas we use (beverages, flags, etc.) to block common mode noise from making its way to the antenna feedpoint. Let me know what you think. It might not work, but sure looked good on paper. 73, Don (wd8dsb) On Sun, Dec 11, 2016 at 9:41 AM, D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> wrote: > > > I have two flag rx ants and I was looking at the DHDL and DK6ED Double > Loop System V2 and wondering if twisting my Flag rx ants into Bowties > would improve the forward pattern and make them narrower with better > front to back. > I would just ""flip"" the termination resistor end to form a loose > BOWTIE shape. > I have no ant modeling software so I have no way to ponder this change. > Maybe someone could model doing this. > TNX es 73, Mike W3TS > _ > Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband > _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband Nick Hall-Patch Victoria, BC Canada _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband
Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie?
Hi Mike and Don The DHDL as well as few other antennas, has a hidden component. The bottom wire parallel to the ground is a transmission line, actually, any antenna parallel to the ground is a transmission line. A beverage antenna a is good example. The ground is the second leg of the transition line, for a K9AY loop it is the same, the bottom wire and the ground form a transmission line. The transmission line allows the Resistor and the Transformer to be moved to the center of the loop. The VE3DO loop is also exactly the same. The same way, a DHDL antenna uses the ground to phase the two loops, if you elevate the DHDL high far from the ground, the patter changes. The DHDL is a ground dependent antenna, improving the ground with a ground wire bellow the antenna can fix some ground problems. My two cents. 73's JC N4IS -Original Message- From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com] On Behalf Of Don Kirk Sent: Sunday, December 11, 2016 10:13 AM To: D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> Cc: topband <topband@contesting.com> Subject: Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie? Hi Mike, Funny you should ask that. A few months ago (September) I was looking at building a smaller size DHDL using 4Nec2, and there were a few things I saw that I thought needed improvement (I saw things in the full size DHDL that I thought needed improvement, it was not limited to the small size DHDL I was trying to design). Then I started to play around with the location of its termination resistor as well as routing of wires, and wound up with what I called the Terminated Bowtie. I built one in my backyard but my yard is pretty small and the antenna was too close to existing objects (house and chain link fence) and I did not realize the S/N improvement that I expected, nevertheless based on modeling it looks like a winner (9.5 RDF and front to back ratio versus elevation angle very robust). I have attached the preliminary document I put together a few months ago for you and others to view (it might not be perfect, but should convey my design / thoughts). I would love someone to build one of these out in the open to see if the real life build provides results similar to the 4Nec2 modelling I did. Note: Bringing the feedline away from the antenna properly needs to be looked at to minimize distortion of the pattern. As I recall the feedline should not drop down to the ground until it's at least 5 feet away from the antenna, and a greater distance would be best. The feedline should also use choke with ground rod similar to what's recommend for other RX antennas we use (beverages, flags, etc.) to block common mode noise from making its way to the antenna feedpoint. Let me know what you think. It might not work, but sure looked good on paper. 73, Don (wd8dsb) On Sun, Dec 11, 2016 at 9:41 AM, D Michael <damich...@verizon.net> wrote: > > > I have two flag rx ants and I was looking at the DHDL and DK6ED Double > Loop System V2 and wondering if twisting my Flag rx ants into Bowties > would improve the forward pattern and make them narrower with better > front to back. > I would just ""flip"" the termination resistor end to form a loose > BOWTIE shape. > I have no ant modeling software so I have no way to ponder this change. > Maybe someone could model doing this. > TNX es 73, Mike W3TS > _ > Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband > _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband
Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie?
Mike and Gang, It was this project (terminated bowtie) that got me looking into the KD9SV 994 x5 preamp a few months ago (I published some info on this preamp a few months ago). I think the KD9SV 994 x5 preamp sometimes called the KD9SV VLN preamp (very low noise preamp) would be perfect for use with this type antenna. Just FYI, Don (wd8dsb) On Sun, Dec 11, 2016 at 10:12 AM, Don Kirkwrote: > Hi Mike, > > Funny you should ask that. > > A few months ago (September) I was looking at building a smaller size DHDL > using 4Nec2, and there were a few things I saw that I thought needed > improvement (I saw things in the full size DHDL that I thought needed > improvement, it was not limited to the small size DHDL I was trying to > design). Then I started to play around with the location of its > termination resistor as well as routing of wires, and wound up with what I > called the Terminated Bowtie. I built one in my backyard but my yard is > pretty small and the antenna was too close to existing objects (house and > chain link fence) and I did not realize the S/N improvement that I > expected, nevertheless based on modeling it looks like a winner (9.5 RDF > and front to back ratio versus elevation angle very robust). > > I have attached the preliminary document I put together a few months ago > for you and others to view (it might not be perfect, but should convey my > design / thoughts). I would love someone to build one of these out in the > open to see if the real life build provides results similar to the 4Nec2 > modelling I did. > > Note: Bringing the feedline away from the antenna properly needs to be > looked at to minimize distortion of the pattern. As I recall the feedline > should not drop down to the ground until it's at least 5 feet away from the > antenna, and a greater distance would be best. The feedline should also > use choke with ground rod similar to what's recommend for other RX antennas > we use (beverages, flags, etc.) to block common mode noise from making its > way to the antenna feedpoint. > > Let me know what you think. It might not work, but sure looked good on > paper. > > 73, > Don (wd8dsb) > > On Sun, Dec 11, 2016 at 9:41 AM, D Michael wrote: > >> >> >> I have two flag rx ants and I was looking at the DHDL and DK6ED Double >> Loop System V2 and wondering if twisting my Flag rx ants into Bowties >> would improve the forward pattern and make them narrower with better front >> to back. >> I would just ""flip"" the termination resistor end to form a loose BOWTIE >> shape. >> I have no ant modeling software so I have no way to ponder this change. >> Maybe someone could model doing this. >> TNX es 73, Mike W3TS >> _ >> Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband >> > > _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband
Re: Topband: Twist a Flag into a Bowtie?
Hi Mike, Funny you should ask that. A few months ago (September) I was looking at building a smaller size DHDL using 4Nec2, and there were a few things I saw that I thought needed improvement (I saw things in the full size DHDL that I thought needed improvement, it was not limited to the small size DHDL I was trying to design). Then I started to play around with the location of its termination resistor as well as routing of wires, and wound up with what I called the Terminated Bowtie. I built one in my backyard but my yard is pretty small and the antenna was too close to existing objects (house and chain link fence) and I did not realize the S/N improvement that I expected, nevertheless based on modeling it looks like a winner (9.5 RDF and front to back ratio versus elevation angle very robust). I have attached the preliminary document I put together a few months ago for you and others to view (it might not be perfect, but should convey my design / thoughts). I would love someone to build one of these out in the open to see if the real life build provides results similar to the 4Nec2 modelling I did. Note: Bringing the feedline away from the antenna properly needs to be looked at to minimize distortion of the pattern. As I recall the feedline should not drop down to the ground until it's at least 5 feet away from the antenna, and a greater distance would be best. The feedline should also use choke with ground rod similar to what's recommend for other RX antennas we use (beverages, flags, etc.) to block common mode noise from making its way to the antenna feedpoint. Let me know what you think. It might not work, but sure looked good on paper. 73, Don (wd8dsb) On Sun, Dec 11, 2016 at 9:41 AM, D Michaelwrote: > > > I have two flag rx ants and I was looking at the DHDL and DK6ED Double > Loop System V2 and wondering if twisting my Flag rx ants into Bowties > would improve the forward pattern and make them narrower with better front > to back. > I would just ""flip"" the termination resistor end to form a loose BOWTIE > shape. > I have no ant modeling software so I have no way to ponder this change. > Maybe someone could model doing this. > TNX es 73, Mike W3TS > _ > Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband > _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband