Re: Creation of new threads after closing response writer in Servlet in Little-G Jetty 2.0.1
I did some debugging and followed the code until:
SelectChannelConnector$ConnectorEndPoint(SelectChannelEndPoint).run() line: 422
when this line is called the Treads will be created.
I guess this is Jetty code because I could not found it
in the Geronimo sources.
Which Jetty version is used is Geronimo 2.0.1?
When I look in the sources pom.xml it is 6.1.5, is this the used Version?
Thanks,
Mario
Mario Ruebsam wrote:
Hello,
after migrating successful from Little-G Jetty 1.1 to Little-G Jetty 2.0.1
I detected some strange behavior when closing the Servlets response writer.
Every time the writer is closed Geronimo or Jetty creates 10 new Threads
in the DefaultThreadPool. The code snippet is below.
In G 1.1 the same code has no impact on threads.
Does anybody has the same experience? Is this a Jetty or a Geronimo
problem?
public void doGet(HttpServletRequest pRequest, HttpServletResponse
pResponse) throws IOException, ServletException {
... do some stuff ...
PrintWriter tOut = pResponse.getWriter();
tOut.write(tData);
tOut.close();
}
Thanks,
Mario
Re: Creation of new threads after closing response writer in Servlet in Little-G Jetty 2.0.1
I did some debugging and followed the code until:
SelectChannelConnector$ConnectorEndPoint(SelectChannelEndPoint).run() line: 422
when this line is called the Treads will be created.
I guess this is Jetty code because I could not found it
in the Geronimo sources.
Which Jetty version is used is Geronimo 2.0.1?
When I look in the sources pom.xml it is 6.1.5, is this the used Version?
Thanks,
Mario
Mario Ruebsam wrote:
Hello,
after migrating successful from Little-G Jetty 1.1 to Little-G Jetty 2.0.1
I detected some strange behavior when closing the Servlets response writer.
Every time the writer is closed Geronimo or Jetty creates 10 new Threads
in the DefaultThreadPool. The code snippet is below.
In G 1.1 the same code has no impact on threads.
Does anybody has the same experience? Is this a Jetty or a Geronimo
problem?
public void doGet(HttpServletRequest pRequest, HttpServletResponse
pResponse) throws IOException, ServletException {
... do some stuff ...
PrintWriter tOut = pResponse.getWriter();
tOut.write(tData);
tOut.close();
}
Thanks,
Mario
Re: Creation of new threads after closing response writer in Servlet in Little-G Jetty 2.0.1
On Sep 14, 2007, at 11:34 AM, Mario Ruebsam wrote: I did some debugging and followed the code until: SelectChannelConnector$ConnectorEndPoint(SelectChannelEndPoint).run () line: 422 when this line is called the Treads will be created. Nice. Thanks for digging into this Mario! I guess this is Jetty code because I could not found it in the Geronimo sources. Correct. Which Jetty version is used is Geronimo 2.0.1? When I look in the sources pom.xml it is 6.1.5, is this the used Version? Yes, we use 6.1.5. See geronimo-jetty6-jee5-2.0.1/repository/org/ mortbay/jetty/jetty/6.1.5/jetty-6.1.5.jar in your installation... Perhaps Jan or Greg can comment on the behavior you're seeing... --kevan
Re: Creation of new threads after closing response writer in Servlet in Little-G Jetty 2.0.1
Mario, thanks for doing the extra debugging to narrow down where the
problem is at. Yes the jetty version is 6.1.5. You can also find
the version number of a component in the admin console's System
modules portlet or by the directory name in Geronimo's repository,
in this case $G/repository/org/mortbay/jetty/jetty/6.1.5
Best wishes,
Paul
On Sep 14, 2007, at 11:34 AM, Mario Ruebsam wrote:
I did some debugging and followed the code until:
SelectChannelConnector$ConnectorEndPoint(SelectChannelEndPoint).run
() line: 422
when this line is called the Treads will be created.
I guess this is Jetty code because I could not found it
in the Geronimo sources.
Which Jetty version is used is Geronimo 2.0.1?
When I look in the sources pom.xml it is 6.1.5, is this the used
Version?
Thanks,
Mario
Mario Ruebsam wrote:
Hello,
after migrating successful from Little-G Jetty 1.1 to Little-G
Jetty 2.0.1
I detected some strange behavior when closing the Servlets
response writer.
Every time the writer is closed Geronimo or Jetty creates 10 new
Threads
in the DefaultThreadPool. The code snippet is below.
In G 1.1 the same code has no impact on threads.
Does anybody has the same experience? Is this a Jetty or a
Geronimo problem?
public void doGet(HttpServletRequest pRequest, HttpServletResponse
pResponse) throws IOException, ServletException {
... do some stuff ...
PrintWriter tOut = pResponse.getWriter();
tOut.write(tData);
tOut.close();
}
Thanks,
Mario
Re: Creation of new threads after closing response writer in Servlet in Little-G Jetty 2.0.1
Ok, I will download or checkout the Jetty 6.1.5 sources to do some further
investigation on it.
Thanks,
Mario
Paul McMahan wrote:
Mario, thanks for doing the extra debugging to narrow down where the
problem is at. Yes the jetty version is 6.1.5. You can also find the
version number of a component in the admin console's System modules
portlet or by the directory name in Geronimo's repository, in this case
$G/repository/org/mortbay/jetty/jetty/6.1.5
Best wishes,
Paul
On Sep 14, 2007, at 11:34 AM, Mario Ruebsam wrote:
I did some debugging and followed the code until:
SelectChannelConnector$ConnectorEndPoint(SelectChannelEndPoint).run()
line: 422
when this line is called the Treads will be created.
I guess this is Jetty code because I could not found it
in the Geronimo sources.
Which Jetty version is used is Geronimo 2.0.1?
When I look in the sources pom.xml it is 6.1.5, is this the used Version?
Thanks,
Mario
Mario Ruebsam wrote:
Hello,
after migrating successful from Little-G Jetty 1.1 to Little-G Jetty
2.0.1
I detected some strange behavior when closing the Servlets response
writer.
Every time the writer is closed Geronimo or Jetty creates 10 new Threads
in the DefaultThreadPool. The code snippet is below.
In G 1.1 the same code has no impact on threads.
Does anybody has the same experience? Is this a Jetty or a Geronimo
problem?
public void doGet(HttpServletRequest pRequest, HttpServletResponse
pResponse) throws IOException, ServletException {
... do some stuff ...
PrintWriter tOut = pResponse.getWriter();
tOut.write(tData);
tOut.close();
}
Thanks,
Mario
Re: Creation of new threads after closing response writer in Servlet in Little-G Jetty 2.0.1
The new Treads are created by more than one Servlet requests
when loading a page. The page itself and also serving some
static files.
The new Threads appear all at the same time because of a
synchronized block in SelectChannelEndPoint.undispatch();
Which is called at the line number mentioned in my last mail.
All that looks like normal behaviour. The problem I see is
that all newly created Threads stay alive and none of theses
Threads is reused after that.
I guess there is some problem reusing the Threads in the pool and
every request creates new Threads. The number of 10 new threads
mentioned before relates magically to exact 10 servlet requests
in my test case. On other pages there are lesser or more.
So the number means nothing.
I have no idea about the Thread pool management and don't know
where to start so I give the ball back to you guys on the list.
Thanks,
Mario
Mario Ruebsam wrote:
Ok, I will download or checkout the Jetty 6.1.5 sources to do some further
investigation on it.
Thanks,
Mario
Paul McMahan wrote:
Mario, thanks for doing the extra debugging to narrow down where the
problem is at. Yes the jetty version is 6.1.5. You can also find
the version number of a component in the admin console's System
modules portlet or by the directory name in Geronimo's repository, in
this case $G/repository/org/mortbay/jetty/jetty/6.1.5
Best wishes,
Paul
On Sep 14, 2007, at 11:34 AM, Mario Ruebsam wrote:
I did some debugging and followed the code until:
SelectChannelConnector$ConnectorEndPoint(SelectChannelEndPoint).run()
line: 422
when this line is called the Treads will be created.
I guess this is Jetty code because I could not found it
in the Geronimo sources.
Which Jetty version is used is Geronimo 2.0.1?
When I look in the sources pom.xml it is 6.1.5, is this the used
Version?
Thanks,
Mario
Mario Ruebsam wrote:
Hello,
after migrating successful from Little-G Jetty 1.1 to Little-G Jetty
2.0.1
I detected some strange behavior when closing the Servlets response
writer.
Every time the writer is closed Geronimo or Jetty creates 10 new
Threads
in the DefaultThreadPool. The code snippet is below.
In G 1.1 the same code has no impact on threads.
Does anybody has the same experience? Is this a Jetty or a Geronimo
problem?
public void doGet(HttpServletRequest pRequest, HttpServletResponse
pResponse) throws IOException, ServletException {
... do some stuff ...
PrintWriter tOut = pResponse.getWriter();
tOut.write(tData);
tOut.close();
}
Thanks,
Mario
