Re: Should we consider Spark3 support for Hive on Spark

2022-08-24 Thread Jan Fili
Yes exactly.

This is what is recommended, cause hive on Spark has little interest.
However there is nothing enforcing not todo it.

Important to me cause i sit here and work on grassroots marrieng hive on
kafka-streams.

Owen O'Malley  schrieb am Mi., 24. Aug. 2022, 18:51:

> Hive on Spark is not recommended. The recommended path is to use either
> Tez or LLAP. If you already are using Spark 3, it would be far easier to
> use Spark SQL.
>
> .. Owen
>
> On Wed, Aug 24, 2022 at 3:46 AM Fred Bai 
> wrote:
>
>> Hi everyone:
>>
>> Do we have any support for Hive on Spark? I need Hive on Spark, but my
>> Spark version is 3.X.
>>
>> I found Hive incompatible with Spark3, I modify a lot of code to be
>> compatible.
>>
>> Hive on Spark has deprecated?
>>
>> And. Hive on Spark is very slow when the job executes.
>>
>


Re: Should we consider Spark3 support for Hive on Spark

2022-08-24 Thread Owen O'Malley
Hive on Spark is not recommended. The recommended path is to use either Tez
or LLAP. If you already are using Spark 3, it would be far easier to use
Spark SQL.

.. Owen

On Wed, Aug 24, 2022 at 3:46 AM Fred Bai  wrote:

> Hi everyone:
>
> Do we have any support for Hive on Spark? I need Hive on Spark, but my
> Spark version is 3.X.
>
> I found Hive incompatible with Spark3, I modify a lot of code to be
> compatible.
>
> Hive on Spark has deprecated?
>
> And. Hive on Spark is very slow when the job executes.
>


Re: Should we consider Spark3 support for Hive on Spark

2022-08-24 Thread hernan saab via user
Do you honestly believe that a non apache community dev can just fork hive, 
modify the code and make it work with any version of spark? Is that what you 
are suggesting? Please, let us know if this is the case.


Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPad


On Wednesday, August 24, 2022, 6:13 AM, Jan Fili  wrote:

Can always fork to get things going ;)

*sorry for spam*

Am Mi., 24. Aug. 2022 um 06:34 Uhr schrieb hernan saab via user
:
>
>
> Hey Fred,
>
> Contrary to what you may perceive from the hive docs, what you are trying to 
> do is not plug and play.
> Only apache committers can do what you are trying to do.
> Use canned solutions such as confluence or AWS EMR and save yourself weeks of 
> wasted effort.
>
> Hernán
> On Tuesday, August 23, 2022 at 08:46:30 PM PDT, Fred Bai 
>  wrote:
>
>
> Hi everyone:
>
> Do we have any support for Hive on Spark? I need Hive on Spark, but my Spark 
> version is 3.X.
>
> I found Hive incompatible with Spark3, I modify a lot of code to be 
> compatible.
>
> Hive on Spark has deprecated?
>
> And. Hive on Spark is very slow when the job executes.





Re: Should we consider Spark3 support for Hive on Spark

2022-08-24 Thread Jan Fili
Can always fork to get things going ;)

*sorry for spam*

Am Mi., 24. Aug. 2022 um 06:34 Uhr schrieb hernan saab via user
:
>
>
> Hey Fred,
>
> Contrary to what you may perceive from the hive docs, what you are trying to 
> do is not plug and play.
> Only apache committers can do what you are trying to do.
> Use canned solutions such as confluence or AWS EMR and save yourself weeks of 
> wasted effort.
>
> Hernán
> On Tuesday, August 23, 2022 at 08:46:30 PM PDT, Fred Bai 
>  wrote:
>
>
> Hi everyone:
>
> Do we have any support for Hive on Spark? I need Hive on Spark, but my Spark 
> version is 3.X.
>
> I found Hive incompatible with Spark3, I modify a lot of code to be 
> compatible.
>
> Hive on Spark has deprecated?
>
> And. Hive on Spark is very slow when the job executes.


Re: Should we consider Spark3 support for Hive on Spark

2022-08-23 Thread hernan saab via user
 
Hey Fred,
Contrary to what you may perceive from the hive docs, what you are trying to do 
is not plug and play.Only apache committers can do what you are trying to 
do.Use canned solutions such as confluence or AWS EMR and save yourself weeks 
of wasted effort.
HernánOn Tuesday, August 23, 2022 at 08:46:30 PM PDT, Fred Bai 
 wrote:  
 
 Hi everyone:
Do we have any support for Hive on Spark? I need Hive on Spark, but my Spark 
version is 3.X.
I found Hive incompatible with Spark3, I modify a lot of code to be compatible.
Hive on Spark has deprecated? 
And. Hive on Spark is very slow when the job executes.  

Should we consider Spark3 support for Hive on Spark

2022-08-23 Thread Fred Bai
Hi everyone:

Do we have any support for Hive on Spark? I need Hive on Spark, but my
Spark version is 3.X.

I found Hive incompatible with Spark3, I modify a lot of code to be
compatible.

Hive on Spark has deprecated?

And. Hive on Spark is very slow when the job executes.