Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
Here is the solution this looks perfect for me. thanks for all your help http://www.confluent.io/blog/bottled-water-real-time-integration-of-postgresql-and-kafka/ On 28 July 2015 at 23:27, Jörn Franke jornfra...@gmail.com wrote: Can you put some transparent cache in front of the database? Or some jdbc proxy? Le mar. 28 juil. 2015 à 19:34, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com a écrit : can the source write to Kafka/Flume/Hbase in addition to Postgres? no it can't write ,this is due to the fact that there are many applications those are producing this postGreSql data.I can't really asked all the teams to start writing to some other source. velocity of the application is too high. On 28 July 2015 at 21:50, santosh...@gmail.com wrote: Sqoop’s incremental data fetch will reduce the data size you need to pull from source, but then by the time that incremental data fetch is complete, is it not current again, if velocity of the data is high? May be you can put a trigger in Postgres to send data to the big data cluster as soon as changes are made. Or as I was saying in another email, can the source write to Kafka/Flume/Hbase in addition to Postgres? Sent from Windows Mail *From:* Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com *Sent:* Tuesday, July 28, 2015 5:43 AM *To:* santosh...@gmail.com *Cc:* ayan guha guha.a...@gmail.com, felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org I trying do that, but there will always data mismatch, since by the time scoop is fetching main database will get so many updates. There is something called incremental data fetch using scoop but that hits a database rather than reading the WAL edit. On 28 July 2015 at 02:52, santosh...@gmail.com wrote: Why cant you bulk pre-fetch the data to HDFS (like using Sqoop) instead of hitting Postgres multiple times? Sent from Windows Mail *From:* ayan guha guha.a...@gmail.com *Sent:* Monday, July 27, 2015 4:41 PM *To:* Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com *Cc:* felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org You can call dB connect once per partition. Please have a look at design patterns of for each construct in document. How big is your data in dB? How soon that data changes? You would be better off if data is in spark already On 28 Jul 2015 04:48, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for your reply. Parallel i will be hitting around 6000 call to postgreSQl which is not good my database will die. these calls to database will keeps on increasing. Handling millions on request is not an issue with Hbase/NOSQL any other alternative? On 27 July 2015 at 23:18, felixcheun...@hotmail.com wrote: You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
Hi Ayan Thanks for reply. Its around 5 GB having 10 tables...this data changes very frequently every minutes few updates its difficult to have this data in spark, if any updates happen on main tables, how can I refresh spark data? On 28 July 2015 at 02:11, ayan guha guha.a...@gmail.com wrote: You can call dB connect once per partition. Please have a look at design patterns of for each construct in document. How big is your data in dB? How soon that data changes? You would be better off if data is in spark already On 28 Jul 2015 04:48, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for your reply. Parallel i will be hitting around 6000 call to postgreSQl which is not good my database will die. these calls to database will keeps on increasing. Handling millions on request is not an issue with Hbase/NOSQL any other alternative? On 27 July 2015 at 23:18, felixcheun...@hotmail.com wrote: You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
I trying do that, but there will always data mismatch, since by the time scoop is fetching main database will get so many updates. There is something called incremental data fetch using scoop but that hits a database rather than reading the WAL edit. On 28 July 2015 at 02:52, santosh...@gmail.com wrote: Why cant you bulk pre-fetch the data to HDFS (like using Sqoop) instead of hitting Postgres multiple times? Sent from Windows Mail *From:* ayan guha guha.a...@gmail.com *Sent:* Monday, July 27, 2015 4:41 PM *To:* Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com *Cc:* felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org You can call dB connect once per partition. Please have a look at design patterns of for each construct in document. How big is your data in dB? How soon that data changes? You would be better off if data is in spark already On 28 Jul 2015 04:48, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for your reply. Parallel i will be hitting around 6000 call to postgreSQl which is not good my database will die. these calls to database will keeps on increasing. Handling millions on request is not an issue with Hbase/NOSQL any other alternative? On 27 July 2015 at 23:18, felixcheun...@hotmail.com wrote: You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
Sqoop’s incremental data fetch will reduce the data size you need to pull from source, but then by the time that incremental data fetch is complete, is it not current again, if velocity of the data is high? May be you can put a trigger in Postgres to send data to the big data cluster as soon as changes are made. Or as I was saying in another email, can the source write to Kafka/Flume/Hbase in addition to Postgres? Sent from Windows Mail From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Tuesday, July 28, 2015 5:43 AM To: santosh...@gmail.com Cc: ayan guha, felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org I trying do that, but there will always data mismatch, since by the time scoop is fetching main database will get so many updates. There is something called incremental data fetch using scoop but that hits a database rather than reading the WAL edit. On 28 July 2015 at 02:52, santosh...@gmail.com wrote: Why cant you bulk pre-fetch the data to HDFS (like using Sqoop) instead of hitting Postgres multiple times? Sent from Windows Mail From: ayan guha Sent: Monday, July 27, 2015 4:41 PM To: Jeetendra Gangele Cc: felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org You can call dB connect once per partition. Please have a look at design patterns of for each construct in document. How big is your data in dB? How soon that data changes? You would be better off if data is in spark already On 28 Jul 2015 04:48, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for your reply. Parallel i will be hitting around 6000 call to postgreSQl which is not good my database will die. these calls to database will keeps on increasing. Handling millions on request is not an issue with Hbase/NOSQL any other alternative? On 27 July 2015 at 23:18, felixcheun...@hotmail.com wrote: You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
can the source write to Kafka/Flume/Hbase in addition to Postgres? no it can't write ,this is due to the fact that there are many applications those are producing this postGreSql data.I can't really asked all the teams to start writing to some other source. velocity of the application is too high. On 28 July 2015 at 21:50, santosh...@gmail.com wrote: Sqoop’s incremental data fetch will reduce the data size you need to pull from source, but then by the time that incremental data fetch is complete, is it not current again, if velocity of the data is high? May be you can put a trigger in Postgres to send data to the big data cluster as soon as changes are made. Or as I was saying in another email, can the source write to Kafka/Flume/Hbase in addition to Postgres? Sent from Windows Mail *From:* Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com *Sent:* Tuesday, July 28, 2015 5:43 AM *To:* santosh...@gmail.com *Cc:* ayan guha guha.a...@gmail.com, felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org I trying do that, but there will always data mismatch, since by the time scoop is fetching main database will get so many updates. There is something called incremental data fetch using scoop but that hits a database rather than reading the WAL edit. On 28 July 2015 at 02:52, santosh...@gmail.com wrote: Why cant you bulk pre-fetch the data to HDFS (like using Sqoop) instead of hitting Postgres multiple times? Sent from Windows Mail *From:* ayan guha guha.a...@gmail.com *Sent:* Monday, July 27, 2015 4:41 PM *To:* Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com *Cc:* felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org You can call dB connect once per partition. Please have a look at design patterns of for each construct in document. How big is your data in dB? How soon that data changes? You would be better off if data is in spark already On 28 Jul 2015 04:48, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for your reply. Parallel i will be hitting around 6000 call to postgreSQl which is not good my database will die. these calls to database will keeps on increasing. Handling millions on request is not an issue with Hbase/NOSQL any other alternative? On 27 July 2015 at 23:18, felixcheun...@hotmail.com wrote: You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
Can you put some transparent cache in front of the database? Or some jdbc proxy? Le mar. 28 juil. 2015 à 19:34, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com a écrit : can the source write to Kafka/Flume/Hbase in addition to Postgres? no it can't write ,this is due to the fact that there are many applications those are producing this postGreSql data.I can't really asked all the teams to start writing to some other source. velocity of the application is too high. On 28 July 2015 at 21:50, santosh...@gmail.com wrote: Sqoop’s incremental data fetch will reduce the data size you need to pull from source, but then by the time that incremental data fetch is complete, is it not current again, if velocity of the data is high? May be you can put a trigger in Postgres to send data to the big data cluster as soon as changes are made. Or as I was saying in another email, can the source write to Kafka/Flume/Hbase in addition to Postgres? Sent from Windows Mail *From:* Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com *Sent:* Tuesday, July 28, 2015 5:43 AM *To:* santosh...@gmail.com *Cc:* ayan guha guha.a...@gmail.com, felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org I trying do that, but there will always data mismatch, since by the time scoop is fetching main database will get so many updates. There is something called incremental data fetch using scoop but that hits a database rather than reading the WAL edit. On 28 July 2015 at 02:52, santosh...@gmail.com wrote: Why cant you bulk pre-fetch the data to HDFS (like using Sqoop) instead of hitting Postgres multiple times? Sent from Windows Mail *From:* ayan guha guha.a...@gmail.com *Sent:* Monday, July 27, 2015 4:41 PM *To:* Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com *Cc:* felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org You can call dB connect once per partition. Please have a look at design patterns of for each construct in document. How big is your data in dB? How soon that data changes? You would be better off if data is in spark already On 28 Jul 2015 04:48, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for your reply. Parallel i will be hitting around 6000 call to postgreSQl which is not good my database will die. these calls to database will keeps on increasing. Handling millions on request is not an issue with Hbase/NOSQL any other alternative? On 27 July 2015 at 23:18, felixcheun...@hotmail.com wrote: You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
Thanks for your reply. Parallel i will be hitting around 6000 call to postgreSQl which is not good my database will die. these calls to database will keeps on increasing. Handling millions on request is not an issue with Hbase/NOSQL any other alternative? On 27 July 2015 at 23:18, felixcheun...@hotmail.com wrote: You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
You can call dB connect once per partition. Please have a look at design patterns of for each construct in document. How big is your data in dB? How soon that data changes? You would be better off if data is in spark already On 28 Jul 2015 04:48, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for your reply. Parallel i will be hitting around 6000 call to postgreSQl which is not good my database will die. these calls to database will keeps on increasing. Handling millions on request is not an issue with Hbase/NOSQL any other alternative? On 27 July 2015 at 23:18, felixcheun...@hotmail.com wrote: You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
Re: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark
I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Is velocity an issue in Postgres that your data would become stale as soon as it reaches Big data cluster? If your concern is that Datastore (hbase etc) is not current in Big Data cluster, can the source write to other stores (like Kafka/Hbase etc/Flume) as well when it writes to Postgres? Sent from Windows Mail From: santosh...@gmail.com Sent: Monday, July 27, 2015 5:22 PM To: ayan guha, Jeetendra Gangele Cc: felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org Why cant you bulk pre-fetch the data to HDFS (like using Sqoop) instead of hitting Postgres multiple times? Sent from Windows Mail From: ayan guha Sent: Monday, July 27, 2015 4:41 PM To: Jeetendra Gangele Cc: felixcheun...@hotmail.com, user@spark.apache.org You can call dB connect once per partition. Please have a look at design patterns of for each construct in document. How big is your data in dB? How soon that data changes? You would be better off if data is in spark already On 28 Jul 2015 04:48, Jeetendra Gangele gangele...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for your reply. Parallel i will be hitting around 6000 call to postgreSQl which is not good my database will die. these calls to database will keeps on increasing. Handling millions on request is not an issue with Hbase/NOSQL any other alternative? On 27 July 2015 at 23:18, felixcheun...@hotmail.com wrote: You can have Spark reading from PostgreSQL through the data access API. Do you have any concern with that approach since you mention copying that data into HBase. From: Jeetendra Gangele Sent: Monday, July 27, 6:00 AM Subject: Data from PostgreSQL to Spark To: user Hi All I have a use case where where I am consuming the Events from RabbitMQ using spark streaming.This event has some fields on which I want to query the PostgreSQL and bring the data and then do the join between event data and PostgreSQl data and put the aggregated data into HDFS, so that I run run analytics query over this data using SparkSQL. my question is PostgreSQL data in production data so i don't want to hit so many times. at any given 1 seconds time I may have 3000 events,that means I need to fire 3000 parallel query to my PostGreSQl and this data keeps on growing, so my database will go down. I can't migrate this PostgreSQL data since lots of system using it,but I can take this data to some NOSQL like base and query the Hbase, but here issue is How can I make sure that Hbase has upto date data? Any anyone suggest me best approach/ method to handle this case? Regards Jeetendra
