Node-Kafka Client Review and Question

2013-04-24 Thread Christopher Alexander
Hi Everyone,

I just wanted to follow-up on a previous thread concerning our investigation of 
identifying a stable Node-Kafka client. To date we have tested the following:

1. Franz-Kafka (https://github.com/dannycoates/franz-kafka)
2. Node-Kafka (v2.1, https://github.com/radekg/node-kafka)
3. Node-Kafka (v2.3, https://github.com/marcuswestin/node-kafka)
4. Prozess (v0.3.5, https://github.com/cainus/Prozess)

Results:

1. Could not get Franz-Kafka and Prozess to work. Requires funky dependencies.
2. Node-Kafka, v2.1 was successfully setup but performed less stable than #3.
3. Node-Kafka, v2.3 was successfully setup, exhibited the best performance 
profile but the consumer is highly inconsistent - specifically, consumer object 
remained in-memory regardless what we did (i.e. var consumer = undefined after 
receiving message). Nothing appears to mitigate this and ALL consumed messaged 
get replayed on reception of a new message.

With this said, is there a Node-Kafka client people are actually using in 
production that doesn't exhibit the profiles we have seen? We have back-tracked 
using Node-Kafka (v2.3) to only produce messages and rely on Redis PubSub 
channels for asynchronous acking of these messages. We would be willing to 
roll-up our sleeves with the community to develop a much more stable Node-Kafka 
client.

Kind regards,

Chris Alexander
Chief Technical Architect and Engineer
Gravy, Inc.


Re: Node-Kafka Client Review and Question

2013-04-24 Thread Christian Carollo
Hi Everyone,

I have been experimenting with the libraries listed below and experienced the 
same problems. 
I have not found any another other node clients.  I am interested in finding a 
node solution as well.  
Happy to contribute on a common solution.

Christian Carollo

On Apr 24, 2013, at 10:19 AM, Christopher Alexander calexan...@gravycard.com 
wrote:

 Hi Everyone,
 
 I just wanted to follow-up on a previous thread concerning our investigation 
 of identifying a stable Node-Kafka client. To date we have tested the 
 following:
 
 1. Franz-Kafka (https://github.com/dannycoates/franz-kafka)
 2. Node-Kafka (v2.1, https://github.com/radekg/node-kafka)
 3. Node-Kafka (v2.3, https://github.com/marcuswestin/node-kafka)
 4. Prozess (v0.3.5, https://github.com/cainus/Prozess)
 
 Results:
 
 1. Could not get Franz-Kafka and Prozess to work. Requires funky dependencies.
 2. Node-Kafka, v2.1 was successfully setup but performed less stable than #3.
 3. Node-Kafka, v2.3 was successfully setup, exhibited the best performance 
 profile but the consumer is highly inconsistent - specifically, consumer 
 object remained in-memory regardless what we did (i.e. var consumer = 
 undefined after receiving message). Nothing appears to mitigate this and ALL 
 consumed messaged get replayed on reception of a new message.
 
 With this said, is there a Node-Kafka client people are actually using in 
 production that doesn't exhibit the profiles we have seen? We have 
 back-tracked using Node-Kafka (v2.3) to only produce messages and rely on 
 Redis PubSub channels for asynchronous acking of these messages. We would be 
 willing to roll-up our sleeves with the community to develop a much more 
 stable Node-Kafka client.
 
 Kind regards,
 
 Chris Alexander
 Chief Technical Architect and Engineer
 Gravy, Inc.