Re: [OpenSIPS-Users] sst min-se problem
Hi Jeff, not need to report it, as I just fix it. Thanks and regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hi Bogdan, If the current code is operating contrary to the RFC, how might one such as me request it be updated? - Jeff On 4/6/09 1:10 PM, Bogdan-Andrei Iancu bog...@voice-system.ro wrote: Looking in the code, the 422 is sent only if the proxy min-se (1800) is smaller than the min(received-min_se(90), received-se(300)) - 1800 90 - false, no 422. But reading the RFC 4028, I would say the condition is the other way around - if the local min-se is higher than min(received-min_se(90), received-se(300)) , the 422 should be sent out. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hi Bogdan, Makes sense, but the why didn't the proxy reject the request with a 422 since the Session-Expires from the request is less than the proxy's Min-SE of 1800? - Jeff On 4/6/09 12:56 PM, Bogdan-Andrei Iancu bog...@voice-system.ro wrote: Hi Jeff, What you configure is the min-se of the proxy. (1800) In DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 are the values from received from request. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hello, I have the sst module configured as follows: loadmodule sst.so modparam(sst|dialog, timeout_avp, $avp(s:sst_timeout)) modparam(sst, sst_flag, 6) modparam(sst, enable_stats, 1) modparam(sst, min_se, 1800) modparam(sst, reject_to_small, 1) Opensips 1.5 receives an invite containing the following header: Session-Expires: 300 sstCheckMin(1) at debug=6 shows this: DBG:sst:sst_check_min: No MIN-SE header found. DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Done returning false (-1) Since the invite from my gateway didn't contain a MIN-SE, why doesn't it use the 1800 provided at the modparam? Thanks, Jeff ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Re: [OpenSIPS-Users] sst min-se problem
Thanks. :) On 4/13/09 7:56 AM, Bogdan-Andrei Iancu bog...@voice-system.ro wrote: Hi Jeff, not need to report it, as I just fix it. Thanks and regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hi Bogdan, If the current code is operating contrary to the RFC, how might one such as me request it be updated? - Jeff On 4/6/09 1:10 PM, Bogdan-Andrei Iancu bog...@voice-system.ro wrote: Looking in the code, the 422 is sent only if the proxy min-se (1800) is smaller than the min(received-min_se(90), received-se(300)) - 1800 90 - false, no 422. But reading the RFC 4028, I would say the condition is the other way around - if the local min-se is higher than min(received-min_se(90), received-se(300)) , the 422 should be sent out. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hi Bogdan, Makes sense, but the why didn't the proxy reject the request with a 422 since the Session-Expires from the request is less than the proxy's Min-SE of 1800? - Jeff On 4/6/09 12:56 PM, Bogdan-Andrei Iancu bog...@voice-system.ro wrote: Hi Jeff, What you configure is the min-se of the proxy. (1800) In DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 are the values from received from request. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hello, I have the sst module configured as follows: loadmodule sst.so modparam(sst|dialog, timeout_avp, $avp(s:sst_timeout)) modparam(sst, sst_flag, 6) modparam(sst, enable_stats, 1) modparam(sst, min_se, 1800) modparam(sst, reject_to_small, 1) Opensips 1.5 receives an invite containing the following header: Session-Expires: 300 sstCheckMin(1) at debug=6 shows this: DBG:sst:sst_check_min: No MIN-SE header found. DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Done returning false (-1) Since the invite from my gateway didn't contain a MIN-SE, why doesn't it use the 1800 provided at the modparam? Thanks, Jeff ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Re: [OpenSIPS-Users] sst min-se problem
Hi Bogdan, If the current code is operating contrary to the RFC, how might one such as me request it be updated? - Jeff On 4/6/09 1:10 PM, Bogdan-Andrei Iancu bog...@voice-system.ro wrote: Looking in the code, the 422 is sent only if the proxy min-se (1800) is smaller than the min(received-min_se(90), received-se(300)) - 1800 90 - false, no 422. But reading the RFC 4028, I would say the condition is the other way around - if the local min-se is higher than min(received-min_se(90), received-se(300)) , the 422 should be sent out. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hi Bogdan, Makes sense, but the why didn't the proxy reject the request with a 422 since the Session-Expires from the request is less than the proxy's Min-SE of 1800? - Jeff On 4/6/09 12:56 PM, Bogdan-Andrei Iancu bog...@voice-system.ro wrote: Hi Jeff, What you configure is the min-se of the proxy. (1800) In DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 are the values from received from request. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hello, I have the sst module configured as follows: loadmodule sst.so modparam(sst|dialog, timeout_avp, $avp(s:sst_timeout)) modparam(sst, sst_flag, 6) modparam(sst, enable_stats, 1) modparam(sst, min_se, 1800) modparam(sst, reject_to_small, 1) Opensips 1.5 receives an invite containing the following header: Session-Expires: 300 sstCheckMin(1) at debug=6 shows this: DBG:sst:sst_check_min: No MIN-SE header found. DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Done returning false (-1) Since the invite from my gateway didn't contain a MIN-SE, why doesn't it use the 1800 provided at the modparam? Thanks, Jeff ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Re: [OpenSIPS-Users] sst min-se problem
Hi Jeff, What you configure is the min-se of the proxy. (1800) In DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 are the values from received from request. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hello, I have the sst module configured as follows: loadmodule sst.so modparam(sst|dialog, timeout_avp, $avp(s:sst_timeout)) modparam(sst, sst_flag, 6) modparam(sst, enable_stats, 1) modparam(sst, min_se, 1800) modparam(sst, reject_to_small, 1) Opensips 1.5 receives an invite containing the following header: Session-Expires: 300 sstCheckMin(1) at debug=6 shows this: DBG:sst:sst_check_min: No MIN-SE header found. DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Done returning false (-1) Since the invite from my gateway didn't contain a MIN-SE, why doesn't it use the 1800 provided at the modparam? Thanks, Jeff ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Re: [OpenSIPS-Users] sst min-se problem
Hi Bogdan, Makes sense, but the why didn't the proxy reject the request with a 422 since the Session-Expires from the request is less than the proxy's Min-SE of 1800? - Jeff On 4/6/09 12:56 PM, Bogdan-Andrei Iancu bog...@voice-system.ro wrote: Hi Jeff, What you configure is the min-se of the proxy. (1800) In DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 are the values from received from request. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hello, I have the sst module configured as follows: loadmodule sst.so modparam(sst|dialog, timeout_avp, $avp(s:sst_timeout)) modparam(sst, sst_flag, 6) modparam(sst, enable_stats, 1) modparam(sst, min_se, 1800) modparam(sst, reject_to_small, 1) Opensips 1.5 receives an invite containing the following header: Session-Expires: 300 sstCheckMin(1) at debug=6 shows this: DBG:sst:sst_check_min: No MIN-SE header found. DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Done returning false (-1) Since the invite from my gateway didn't contain a MIN-SE, why doesn't it use the 1800 provided at the modparam? Thanks, Jeff ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Re: [OpenSIPS-Users] sst min-se problem
Looking in the code, the 422 is sent only if the proxy min-se (1800) is smaller than the min(received-min_se(90), received-se(300)) - 1800 90 - false, no 422. But reading the RFC 4028, I would say the condition is the other way around - if the local min-se is higher than min(received-min_se(90), received-se(300)) , the 422 should be sent out. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hi Bogdan, Makes sense, but the why didn't the proxy reject the request with a 422 since the Session-Expires from the request is less than the proxy's Min-SE of 1800? - Jeff On 4/6/09 12:56 PM, Bogdan-Andrei Iancu bog...@voice-system.ro wrote: Hi Jeff, What you configure is the min-se of the proxy. (1800) In DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 are the values from received from request. Regards, Bogdan Jeff Pyle wrote: Hello, I have the sst module configured as follows: loadmodule sst.so modparam(sst|dialog, timeout_avp, $avp(s:sst_timeout)) modparam(sst, sst_flag, 6) modparam(sst, enable_stats, 1) modparam(sst, min_se, 1800) modparam(sst, reject_to_small, 1) Opensips 1.5 receives an invite containing the following header: Session-Expires: 300 sstCheckMin(1) at debug=6 shows this: DBG:sst:sst_check_min: No MIN-SE header found. DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Done returning false (-1) Since the invite from my gateway didn't contain a MIN-SE, why doesn't it use the 1800 provided at the modparam? Thanks, Jeff ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
[OpenSIPS-Users] sst min-se problem
Hello, I have the sst module configured as follows: loadmodule sst.so modparam(sst|dialog, timeout_avp, $avp(s:sst_timeout)) modparam(sst, sst_flag, 6) modparam(sst, enable_stats, 1) modparam(sst, min_se, 1800) modparam(sst, reject_to_small, 1) Opensips 1.5 receives an invite containing the following header: Session-Expires: 300 sstCheckMin(1) at debug=6 shows this: DBG:sst:sst_check_min: No MIN-SE header found. DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Session-Expires: 300; MIN-SE: 90 DBG:sst:sst_check_min: Done returning false (-1) Since the invite from my gateway didn't contain a MIN-SE, why doesn't it use the 1800 provided at the modparam? Thanks, Jeff ___ Users mailing list Users@lists.opensips.org http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
