TomEE/OpenEJB (OpenWebBeans) with Apache MyFaces CODI

2012-11-21 Thread Howard W. Smith, Jr. 
Is it really necessary or encouraged to use Apache MyFaces CODI with TomEE
1.5 (SNAPSHOT)? Any pros/cons, advantages/disadvantages using them both
together?

TomEE bundles MyFaces Core 2.1.9 and OpenEJB, but Apache MyFaces CODI is
'not' bundled with TomEE, for some reason or another.

I've seen blogs encourage JSF developers to 'at least' use latest MyFaces
Core version and OpenWebBeans for performance reasons, but I don't think I
saw encouragement to use Apache MyFaces CODI.


Thanks,
Howard

Re: TomEE/OpenEJB (OpenWebBeans) with Apache MyFaces CODI

2012-11-21 Thread Thomas Andraschko 
Maybe you should look at the CODi wiki and understand what CODI provides.
If you don't like it, don't use it. This isn't a required lib.

2012/11/21 Howard W. Smith, Jr. smithh032...@gmail.com

 Is it really necessary or encouraged to use Apache MyFaces CODI with TomEE
 1.5 (SNAPSHOT)? Any pros/cons, advantages/disadvantages using them both
 together?

 TomEE bundles MyFaces Core 2.1.9 and OpenEJB, but Apache MyFaces CODI is
 'not' bundled with TomEE, for some reason or another.

 I've seen blogs encourage JSF developers to 'at least' use latest MyFaces
 Core version and OpenWebBeans for performance reasons, but I don't think I
 saw encouragement to use Apache MyFaces CODI.


 Thanks,
 Howard

Re: TomEE/OpenEJB (OpenWebBeans) with Apache MyFaces CODI

2012-11-21 Thread Mark Struberg 
Hi Howard!

CODI is a portable CDI _Extension_ and not a CDI container!

CODI runs on Weld, OpenWebBeans, resin, Glassfish, TomEE, JBossAS, etc

LieGrue,
strub



- Original Message -
 From: Howard W. Smith, Jr. smithh032...@gmail.com
 To: MyFaces Discussion users@myfaces.apache.org
 Cc: 
 Sent: Wednesday, November 21, 2012 9:51 PM
 Subject: TomEE/OpenEJB (OpenWebBeans) with Apache MyFaces CODI
 
 Is it really necessary or encouraged to use Apache MyFaces CODI with TomEE
 1.5 (SNAPSHOT)? Any pros/cons, advantages/disadvantages using them both
 together?
 
 TomEE bundles MyFaces Core 2.1.9 and OpenEJB, but Apache MyFaces CODI is
 'not' bundled with TomEE, for some reason or another.
 
 I've seen blogs encourage JSF developers to 'at least' use latest 
 MyFaces
 Core version and OpenWebBeans for performance reasons, but I don't think I
 saw encouragement to use Apache MyFaces CODI.
 
 
 Thanks,
 Howard

Re: TomEE/OpenEJB (OpenWebBeans) with Apache MyFaces CODI

2012-11-21 Thread Howard W. Smith, Jr. 
Thanks Thomas and Mark. Right now, I have no CODI dependencies, so I'll
remove from my app/project, for now.


On Wed, Nov 21, 2012 at 3:51 PM, Howard W. Smith, Jr. 
smithh032...@gmail.com wrote:

 Is it really necessary or encouraged to use Apache MyFaces CODI with TomEE
 1.5 (SNAPSHOT)? Any pros/cons, advantages/disadvantages using them both
 together?

 TomEE bundles MyFaces Core 2.1.9 and OpenEJB, but Apache MyFaces CODI is
 'not' bundled with TomEE, for some reason or another.

 I've seen blogs encourage JSF developers to 'at least' use latest MyFaces
 Core version and OpenWebBeans for performance reasons, but I don't think I
 saw encouragement to use Apache MyFaces CODI.


 Thanks,
 Howard