Re: [vchkpw] running sa-learn from valias
On Nov 7, 2006, at 4:51 AM, andrej wrote: are you sure its not working (adding the mail to spam/ham)? My guess is that the mail is still in the queue and cannot be delivered because after running your script its stuck because it has no more instructions on what to do with it. That should be easy to test by adding a valid mailbox (of fiddling with the script return code, but thats behind my qmail knowledge ;). Let me know if it works. It might be because your script to add it to the spam/ham database doesn't use an exit code that qmail-local understands. From `man qmail-command`: command’s exit codes are interpreted as follows: 0 means that the delivery was successful; 99 means that the delivery was successful, but that qmail-local should ignore all further delivery instructions; 100 means that the delivery failed permanently (hard error); 111 means that the delivery failed but should be tried again in a little while (soft error). What do you see in the qmail-send log when a message goes through the process? -- Tom Collins - [EMAIL PROTECTED] Vpopmail - virtual domains for qmail: http://vpopmail.sf.net/ QmailAdmin - web interface for Vpopmail: http://qmailadmin.sf.net/
Re: [vchkpw] running sa-learn from valias
> So I assume I setup the aliases wrong? I tried setting the ownership of the > scripts to vpopmail, playing with permissions. > > I see the messages I send to [EMAIL PROTECTED] in the queue. (So, a related > qmail question: how do I tell what reason a message is in the queue?) > I guess this question is not really a vpopmail question so you might consider moving it to the qmail mailinglist.anyway my 2 cents ;) are you sure its not working (adding the mail to spam/ham)? My guess is that the mail is still in the queue and cannot be delivered because after running your script its stuck because it has no more instructions on what to do with it. That should be easy to test by adding a valid mailbox (of fiddling with the script return code, but thats behind my qmail knowledge ;). Let me know if it works. |/root/bin/learnham ./Maildir/ cheers andrej
Re: [vchkpw] running sa-learn from valias
Quinn Comendant wrote: I'm trying to create an alias that pipes a message to sa-learn. I've created the alias: [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$valias -s strangecode.com | grep spam [EMAIL PROTECTED] -> |sa-learn --ham --no-sync [EMAIL PROTECTED] -> |sa-learn --spam --no-sync That didn't work, so I tried this: [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$valias -s strangecode.com | grep spam [EMAIL PROTECTED] -> |/root/bin/learnham [EMAIL PROTECTED] -> |/root/bin/learnspam And those scripts are something like: [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$cat /root/bin/learnham #!/bin/sh sa-learn --spam --no-sync -D &> /tmp/learnspam.log And they work fine is fed spam directly... [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$bin/learnspam < ...spam here... EOF [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$head /tmp/learnspam.log [8532] dbg: logger: adding facilities: all ... Learned tokens from 1 message(s) (1 message(s) examined) So I assume I setup the aliases wrong? I tried setting the ownership of the scripts to vpopmail, playing with permissions. I see the messages I send to [EMAIL PROTECTED] in the queue. (So, a related qmail question: how do I tell what reason a message is in the queue?) Thanks! Quinn You would probably find this easier to do with maildrop and mailfilter.
[vchkpw] running sa-learn from valias
I'm trying to create an alias that pipes a message to sa-learn. I've created the alias: [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$valias -s strangecode.com | grep spam [EMAIL PROTECTED] -> |sa-learn --ham --no-sync [EMAIL PROTECTED] -> |sa-learn --spam --no-sync That didn't work, so I tried this: [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$valias -s strangecode.com | grep spam [EMAIL PROTECTED] -> |/root/bin/learnham [EMAIL PROTECTED] -> |/root/bin/learnspam And those scripts are something like: [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$cat /root/bin/learnham #!/bin/sh sa-learn --spam --no-sync -D &> /tmp/learnspam.log And they work fine is fed spam directly... [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$bin/learnspam < ...spam here... EOF [EMAIL PROTECTED]/1 ~]$head /tmp/learnspam.log [8532] dbg: logger: adding facilities: all ... Learned tokens from 1 message(s) (1 message(s) examined) So I assume I setup the aliases wrong? I tried setting the ownership of the scripts to vpopmail, playing with permissions. I see the messages I send to [EMAIL PROTECTED] in the queue. (So, a related qmail question: how do I tell what reason a message is in the queue?) Thanks! Quinn
