Re: [Vo]:So Rossi has a real Ph.D. obtained in 1975

2011-11-21 Thread Berke Durak
I'm being told that Dottore Magistrale in Filosofia is the
equivalent to a master's degree,
and not to a Ph.D.

Are there any Italian-speaking persons familiar with Italian research
 education here
that could comment on this?
-- 
Berke Durak



[Vo]:So Rossi has a real Ph.D. obtained in 1975

2011-11-20 Thread Berke Durak
At http://ecat.com/inventor-andrea-rossi there is a scanned statement
from the University of Milan:

 UNIVERSITÀ DEGLI STUDI DI MILANO

 Registrato al numero 582

 Matricola 89930

 Si attesta risultare dagli atti di questa Segreteria che il Sig.
 ROSSI ANDREA nato a Milano il 03/06/1950, ha superato presso questo
 Università, in data 10/12/1975, l'esame di laurea in Filosofia con
 voti CENTODIECI su CENTODIECI conseguendo la qualifica accademica di
 Dottore Magistrale in Filosofia.

 Il presento certificato si rilascia in carta libera, a richiesta
 dell'interessato, per gli usi consentiti dalla legge.

 Milano, 14 febbraio 2011

 IL COMPILATORE

 IL CAPO UFFICIO SEGRETERIA FACOLTA UMANISTICHE Dott. ssa. Filomena
 CICORA

Google translate produces this:

 UNIVERSITY OF  MILAN

 Registered number 582

 Serial number 89930

 This is to certify that the documents before the Secretary that Mr.
 Rossi Andrea was born in Milan on 03/06/1950, has been awarded by
 the University, on 10/12/1975, examination degree in Philosophy with
 a hundred and ten votes of one hundred and ten achieving the
 academic qualification of Doctor of Science in Philosophy.

 This certificate is issued on plain paper at the request of, for the
 purposes authorized by law.

 Milan, February 14, 2011

 THE COMPILER

 THE HEAD OFFICE SECRETARY
 Faculty of Humanities
 Dr. ssa. Filomena CHICORY

According to e-cat.com, he conducted his thesis on relativity.

This corroborates the information on Wikipedia:

 In 1973, Rossi graduated cum laude in Philosophy of Science and
 Engineering at the University of Milan with a thesis on Albert
 Einstein’s Theory of Relativity and its interrelationship with
 Edmund Husserl’s Phenomenology. His advisor was Professor Ludovico
 Geymonat.

So where does all this disinformation about Rossi being a chalatan
with a fake PhD from a diploma mill coming from?
-- 
Berke Durak



Re: [Vo]:So Rossi has a real Ph.D. obtained in 1975

2011-11-20 Thread Mary Yugo
On Sun, Nov 20, 2011 at 8:56 AM, Berke Durak berke.du...@gmail.com wrote:


 So where does all this disinformation about Rossi being a chalatan
 with a fake PhD from a diploma mill coming from?


I'd have to look it up and it's not terribly important but Rossi's real PhD
is in philosophy.  He claimed at one time that he also had a physics PhD
but it turned out to be from some diploma mill (phony school) in the US.
That's well documented in several places.


Re: [Vo]:So Rossi has a real Ph.D. obtained in 1975

2011-11-20 Thread Daniel Rocha
It always seemed to me an honorary diploma from an university that later
turned out to lose its accreditation, not that was phony.

2011/11/20 Mary Yugo maryyu...@gmail.com



 On Sun, Nov 20, 2011 at 8:56 AM, Berke Durak berke.du...@gmail.comwrote:


 So where does all this disinformation about Rossi being a chalatan
 with a fake PhD from a diploma mill coming from?


 I'd have to look it up and it's not terribly important but Rossi's real
 PhD is in philosophy.  He claimed at one time that he also had a physics
 PhD but it turned out to be from some diploma mill (phony school) in the
 US.  That's well documented in several places.



Re: [Vo]:So Rossi has a real Ph.D. obtained in 1975

2011-11-20 Thread Jed Rothwell
Daniel Rocha danieldi...@gmail.com wrote:

It always seemed to me an honorary diploma from an university that later
 turned out to lose its accreditation, not that was phony.


He told me it was purely honorary. He said some people gave it to him as a
reward for some work he did . . . I do not recall the details.

I think he knows nothing about the university. I told him it is a diploma
mill. He said so what? He does not care. Rossi never sweats the details.

- Jed