Re: [Vo]:Re: I was impressed by Levi in the video interview

2011-08-24 Thread Jed Rothwell
Mattia Rizzi mattia.ri...@gmail.com wrote:

  2. Apart from the initial heat burst, the temperature was steady, as
 shown
 in the laptop photos they took. So the flow must have been steady.

 You have a terrible confusion in your head.
 The “laptop photos” doesn’t exists at all for the february test (liquid
 water calorimetry)


They told me they recorded the whole thing with a camera, since they could
not be there for the whole 18 hours. I do not know if it is a laptop camera
or some other kind.

Anyway, while they were there, they watched the temperature display and it
did not fluctuate much. I doubt it fluctuated when they turned their backs
or went home to sleep but you never know.

- Jed


Re: [Vo]:Re: I was impressed by Levi in the video interview

2011-08-24 Thread Jed Rothwell

Mattia Rizzi wrote:

Again, you wrote that “the temperature was steady, as shown in the 
laptop photos they took”.
These photos are not pubblicated. So there isn’t “as show”, it’s again 
a “RossiLevi said”.


It would be easy to make fake photos or a fake video. So even if they 
published photos, it would prove nothing.


If you do not trust what Rossi and Levi said, then you will not believe 
any of this. You might as well not participate in the discussion, 
because Rossi and Levi may be lying is an argument that cannot be 
refuted or falsified, and it can be used to explain away every aspect of 
every claim.


They told me they took photos. I believe them. You don't. There is 
nothing more to be said, and no point to debating the issue.


- Jed