Re: file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Tom Spear (Dustin Booker, Dustin Navea)

Mike McCormack wrote:


Tom Spear (Dustin Booker, Dustin Navea) wrote:

Hmm.. I'm thinking that the test isn't doing it right then...  Cause 
windows will let you delete a readonly file, but it prompts you first


Deleting using the UI isn't the same as a program using DeleteFile().

Mike

Crap, you are right.. doing del in the command prompt returns access 
denied ok the test is right





Re: file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Mike McCormack


Tom Spear (Dustin Booker, Dustin Navea) wrote:

Hmm.. I'm thinking that the test isn't doing it right then...  Cause 
windows will let you delete a readonly file, but it prompts you first


Deleting using the UI isn't the same as a program using DeleteFile().

Mike




Re: file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Tom Spear (Dustin Booker, Dustin Navea)

Huw D M Davies wrote:

On Thu, Mar 23, 2006 at 01:24:53PM -0500, Matt Finnicum wrote:
  

I'm at a windows XP machine right now.

I have no trouble deleting read-only files - I get the dialog informing me
it's read-only, but then it allows me to delete it.

Is it the same on 95/98?



How are you trying to delete them?  The question is whether the
DeleteFile() function works as tested - the way to find this is to run
that test on Windows XP.

Huw.

  
I usually do Shift+Delete (skip the recycle bin), but delete will work 
to move a readonly file to the recycle bin as well...


Tom




Re: file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Tom Spear (Dustin Booker, Dustin Navea)

Huw D M Davies wrote:

On Thu, Mar 23, 2006 at 06:04:21AM -0600, Tom Spear (Dustin Booker, Dustin 
Navea) wrote:
  
Umm.. I'm not totally sure this is 100% in conformance with windows.  
When I try to delete a readonly file, I get a dialog telling me that it 
is readonly, and asking me if I really want to delete it.  If we are 
completely disallowing removal of a readonly file (by windows standard, 
not linux' standard), then it is incorrect and should be fixed...





Well the test passes on Win 2000.

C:\>kernel32_crosstest.exe file
file: 494243 test executed, 0 marked as todo, 0 failures.

Huw.
  
Hmm.. I'm thinking that the test isn't doing it right then...  Cause 
windows will let you delete a readonly file, but it prompts you first


Tom




Re: file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Huw D M Davies
On Thu, Mar 23, 2006 at 01:59:12PM -0500, Bryan Mayland wrote:
> Huw D M Davies wrote:
> >How are you trying to delete them?  The question is whether the
> >DeleteFile() function works as tested - the way to find this is to run
> >that test on Windows XP.
> >  
>DeleteFile on an read-only file under XP returns false.  
> GetLastError returns 5 (Access denied)

Right, which is what we're testing for (well ok we don't test
GetLastError).

Huw.




Re: file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Bryan Mayland

Huw D M Davies wrote:

How are you trying to delete them?  The question is whether the
DeleteFile() function works as tested - the way to find this is to run
that test on Windows XP.
  
   DeleteFile on an read-only file under XP returns false.  
GetLastError returns 5 (Access denied)





Re: file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Huw D M Davies
On Thu, Mar 23, 2006 at 01:24:53PM -0500, Matt Finnicum wrote:
> I'm at a windows XP machine right now.
> 
> I have no trouble deleting read-only files - I get the dialog informing me
> it's read-only, but then it allows me to delete it.
> 
> Is it the same on 95/98?

How are you trying to delete them?  The question is whether the
DeleteFile() function works as tested - the way to find this is to run
that test on Windows XP.

Huw.




Re: file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Matt Finnicum
I'm at a windows XP machine right now.

I have no trouble deleting read-only files - I get the dialog informing me it's read-only, but then it allows me to delete it.Is it the same on 95/98?--MurphOn 3/23/06, 
Huw D M Davies <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
On Thu, Mar 23, 2006 at 06:04:21AM -0600, Tom Spear (Dustin Booker, Dustin Navea) wrote:> Umm.. I'm not totally sure this is 100% in conformance with windows.> When I try to delete a readonly file, I get a dialog telling me that it
> is readonly, and asking me if I really want to delete it.  If we are> completely disallowing removal of a readonly file (by windows standard,> not linux' standard), then it is incorrect and should be fixed...
>Well the test passes on Win 2000.C:\>kernel32_crosstest.exe filefile: 494243 test executed, 0 marked as todo, 0 failures.Huw.--Huw Davies
[EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Huw D M Davies
On Thu, Mar 23, 2006 at 06:04:21AM -0600, Tom Spear (Dustin Booker, Dustin 
Navea) wrote:
> Umm.. I'm not totally sure this is 100% in conformance with windows.  
> When I try to delete a readonly file, I get a dialog telling me that it 
> is readonly, and asking me if I really want to delete it.  If we are 
> completely disallowing removal of a readonly file (by windows standard, 
> not linux' standard), then it is incorrect and should be fixed...
> 

Well the test passes on Win 2000.

C:\>kernel32_crosstest.exe file
file: 494243 test executed, 0 marked as todo, 0 failures.

Huw.
-- 
Huw Davies
[EMAIL PROTECTED]




file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file

2006-03-23 Thread Tom Spear (Dustin Booker, Dustin Navea)
Umm.. I'm not totally sure this is 100% in conformance with windows.  
When I try to delete a readonly file, I get a dialog telling me that it 
is readonly, and asking me if I really want to delete it.  If we are 
completely disallowing removal of a readonly file (by windows standard, 
not linux' standard), then it is incorrect and should be fixed...


Tom

Igor Sysoev wrote:


file.c:246: Test failed: shouldn't be able to delete a readonly file