Re: [abcusers] Re : suggestions for [A4A2] notation

2002-08-11 Thread Laurie (ukonline)
Is it legal abc to have a rest in a chord? For instance: X:0 T:Example L:1/8 M:4/2 K:G [zG8 B8 d8]gfe dcBA G8 Failing that we really do need the number on the end like X:1 T:Example L:1/8 M:4/2 K:G [G8 B8 d8]1gfe dcBA G8 Note that one might need single note "chords" with a length. This leads

[abcusers] Re : suggestions for [A4A2] notation

2002-08-11 Thread Bryancreer
Starling wrote - > ... I had one question. What is a "melody note"? I have always > known melodies as defined by context, and subject to much > interpretation, rather than being defined by a specific type of > notation. Two different people can call a section of music melody or > accompanimen

Re: [abcusers] Re : suggestions for [A4A2] notation

2002-08-11 Thread Don Whitener
At 05:06 AM 8/11/02, Phil Taylor wrote: >I wonder though if we aren't beginning to split some unnecessary hairs >here. Are there really any circumstances where the overall length >of the chord is different from the length of the melody note? I'm not sure if this is what you are addressing, but

Re: [abcusers] Re : suggestions for [A4A2] notation

2002-08-11 Thread John Chambers
Starling wrote - | ... I had one question. What is a "melody note"? I have always | known melodies as defined by context, and subject to much | interpretation, rather than being defined by a specific type of | notation. Two different people can call a section of music melody or | accompaniment

Re: [abcusers] Re : suggestions for [A4A2] notation

2002-08-11 Thread Richard Robinson
On Sun, 11 Aug 2002, Phil Taylor wrote: > Starling wrote: > > >Almost. I had one question. What is a "melody note"? I have always > >known melodies as defined by context, and subject to much > >interpretation, rather than being defined by a specific type of > >notation. Two different people c

Re: [abcusers] Re : suggestions for [A4A2] notation

2002-08-11 Thread Phil Taylor
Laurie wrote: >Well Muse has a serious problem in using multiple voices for a piano part. >(I would guess Bryan's Noteworthy to ABC converter would have the same >problem). The problem is "how do you decide what counts as a voice?" This >is from near the end of "His Yoke is easy and his Burthen

Re: [abcusers] Re : suggestions for [A4A2] notation

2002-08-11 Thread Laurie (ukonline)
Laurie: I've been transcribing choruses of The Messiah. Phil: If you're doing something that complicated you have to be using multiple voices anyway...to represent the two hands unambiguously. Well Muse has a serious problem in using multiple voices for a piano part. (I would guess Bryan's Notewo

Re: [abcusers] Re : suggestions for [A4A2] notation

2002-08-11 Thread Phil Taylor
Starling wrote: >Almost. I had one question. What is a "melody note"? I have always >known melodies as defined by context, and subject to much >interpretation, rather than being defined by a specific type of >notation. Two different people can call a section of music melody or >accompaniment,

Re: [abcusers] Re : suggestions for [A4A2] notation

2002-08-11 Thread Phil Taylor
Laurie wrote: >I've been transcribing choruses of The Messiah. The voices are of course >monophonic, but piano accompaniments have all sorts of nasties. I have >found that shortest note determines when next note starts works well. You >can always add a rest or two if that's not what you wanted