Re: [Acme] Fwd: New Version Notification for draft-suchan-acme-onion-00.txt

2022-05-11 Thread Richard Barnes
Yep, this is the right way to suggest a new draft! Thanks for writing this up. One high-level comment on a quick skim: I don't think you need the new identifier type. Since .onion is a "legit" TLD [RFC7686], onion names are part of the DNS namespace. It's OK for CAs to have different policies f

Re: [Acme] Fwd: New Version Notification for draft-suchan-acme-onion-00.txt

2022-05-11 Thread Seo Suchan
I don't think we can change challange name while being competiable with CABF reqs: they already point to RFC8555 section 8.3 and RFC8723 for allowed challanges. any other name will not be comply with that. we can invent new http based challange based 4.3.3.2.18, but it will have to use differe