Re: [agi] Chomsky's apparently erroneous critique of LLMs isn't in error

2023-06-27 Thread James Bowery
On Mon, Jun 26, 2023 at 6:35 PM Mike Archbold wrote: > The problem with AIT is you need a PhD to understand it, ... > The problem with AIT is you need a PhD to _not_ understand it and PhD's not only wield authority over the rest of the field but have an incentive to obscure Ockham's Razor. It i

Re: [agi] Chomsky's apparently erroneous critique of LLMs isn't in error

2023-06-26 Thread Mike Archbold
The problem with AIT is you need a PhD to understand it, the On Mon, Jun 26, 2023 at 11:10 AM James Bowery wrote: > https://youtu.be/wPonuHqbNds?t=1199 > > Chomsky's apparently erroneous critique of Transformer-based LLMs is > actually correct in the larger sense. His apparent error? > > Ask Cha

[agi] Chomsky's apparently erroneous critique of LLMs isn't in error

2023-06-26 Thread James Bowery
https://youtu.be/wPonuHqbNds?t=1199 Chomsky's apparently erroneous critique of Transformer-based LLMs is actually correct in the larger sense. His apparent error? Ask ChatGPT the following: "What is the grammar diagram for the sentence: The friends of my brothers are in England." Contrary to wh