DIS: Re: BUS: Re: OFF: Distribution of Proposals 4930-4940

2007-04-25 Thread Ed Murphy
Maud wrote: 4932 AGAINST -- (I've missed some discussion. Aren't these 4933 AGAINST -- attempting to do basically the same thing?) The difference is whether an Excess CFJ that gets assigned may still be refused. 4935 FOR (Why ``contentiousness''? I mean, I know why, but why?)

Re: DIS: Re: BUS: proposal: slim the map

2007-04-25 Thread Zefram
Benjamin Schultz wrote: I'm voting against this, because I don't see Zefram adding emself to the map in this proposal. Eep. I thought I'd attract votes against if I *did* add anything. -zefram

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Promotor] Proposal pool report

2007-04-25 Thread Ian Kelly
On 4/25/07, Zefram [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Benjamin Schultz wrote: Or, of course, you could volunteer to take over as Promotor, eh? I'm up for that. My manifesto: if elected I'll distribute proposals promptly, in semi-weekly batches, to keep the game moving. Proposals will generally wait

DIS: Re: OFF: Distribution of Proposals 4930-4940

2007-04-25 Thread quazie
4930 | Simple VC win | Goethe| 1* | 02Apr07 | D FOR 4931 | Herald to advertise | Zefram| 1 | 04Apr07 | O FOR 4932 | Clarifying Excess CFJs | Levi | 1 | 05Apr07 | O AGAINST 4933 | constrained refusal of e... | Zefram| 1 | 05Apr07 | O FOR

DIS: Decisor

2007-04-25 Thread Kerim Aydin
Murphy wrote: Create a rule titled The International Associate Director of Personnel with this text: Create a rule titled The Assessor with this text: Certainly, at the very least, we can combine these two into a single new office? Proto: The Decisor is an Office with the responsibility

DIS: BUS: Votes

2007-04-25 Thread Kerim Aydin
Sherlock wrote: 4943 | Reward and Punishment | Goethe| 3 | 20Apr07 | D AGAINST -- punishing recusal is fine, punishing being overturned is not. No worries, but punishment for being overturned is already in the rule, not added by me, so you should prefer the new version by your

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: Distribution of Proposals 4930-4940

2007-04-25 Thread Ed Murphy
quazie wrote: 4930 | Simple VC win | Goethe| 1* | 02Apr07 | D FOR Not to the PF.

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Promotor] Proposal pool report

2007-04-25 Thread Zefram
Ian Kelly wrote: Would you be willing to take over the proposal archive as well? I'd love to. Proposals are actually the next thing I want to archive systematically, after rules. I'll make the record as complete as possible. currently exists as a postgres database, a suite of poorly organized

Re: DIS: Re: BUS: proposal: slim the map

2007-04-25 Thread Taral
On 4/25/07, Zefram [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Benjamin Schultz wrote: I'm voting against this, because I don't see Zefram adding emself to the map in this proposal. Eep. I thought I'd attract votes against if I *did* add anything. Yes! -- Taral [EMAIL PROTECTED] You can't prove anything.

Re: DIS: Decisor

2007-04-25 Thread Benjamin Schultz
On Apr 25, 2007, at 11:43 AM, Kerim Aydin wrote: Murphy wrote: Create a rule titled The International Associate Director of Personnel with this text: Create a rule titled The Assessor with this text: Certainly, at the very least, we can combine these two into a single new office?