Per my usual custom, I voted via private email to the Speaker (and my
votes were correctly recorded for 342-343 and 345-347). Fool's report does
have Walker listed as voting against, so if he just switched my vote with
Walker's, that doesn't affect passage of the proposal, but does affect
points.
> Proposal 344 (Yally) passes 5:3 with ehird, Steve, Michael, Yally, and
> Chuck FOR; Walker, Goethe, and omd AGAINST. This amends rule 343. It
> basically restores this poor rule to the original winning condition
> (most points), and adds a clause to resume the game next year. Yally
> gets 10 poin
Yes, it had occurred to me that Rule 219 is unclear if the "move" under
consideration has to be an actual or at least attempted move, or if a
hypothetical move is sufficient. If the latter, well, here it is. If the
former, then I needed to get the ball rolling by making a CFJ anyway.
(Although I su
I invoke judgement on the following statement: The selection of a Judge
for this statement is a move whose legality cannot be determined with
finality.
Reasoning: Rule 331 reads, "The Speaker shall choose Judges randomly from
the set of qualified players. The players qualified to judge a statemen
I propose that the following rule be created:
No rule may award or penalize players based on their votes on proposals
whose voting period ended before or at the same time as the time at which
the current form of said rule took effect.
Chuck
I figured I could spare some time to play as long as it's just for a few
weeks. :) And it seemed fitting.
Chuck
> On 18/06/2013 7:58 AM, Chuck Carroll wrote:
>> I join Agora XX.
>>
>> Chuck
>>
>
> Well, hog tie me to a TTY and set my wizard bit, look who's here!
>
> -Dan
>
>
I vote in favor of my own proposal.
Chuck
> I propose that Rule 211 be amended to read:
>
>
>
> "Voters who voted against proposals which are adopted receive 2 points
> apiece. Players whose proposals are adopted shall receive a random number
> of
> points in the range 1-10 inclusive."
>
>
>
> C
I propose that Rule 110 be transmuted to mutable.
Chuck
8 matches
Mail list logo
