Now with more information!
RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 8322-8341 ================================= I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals. The quorum for all below decisions was 6. Voting Strengths ================ Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted. $: player has voting strength 4 %: player has voting strength 5 ^: player has voting strength 6 &: player has voting strength 7 *: player has voting strength 8 +: player has voting strength 9 PROPOSALS ========= PROPOSAL 8322 (Unrepetition v1.1) CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (7): Aris, Bernie, Falsifian, Jason$, Murphy, Rance, twg AGAINST (0): PRESENT (3): Alexis, Warrigal, sukil BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 22/0 (AI=3.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Endorsement of Falsifian ] PROPOSAL 8323 (Secure Ribbons) CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (9): Alexis, Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, G., Jason$, Murphy, Rance, o AGAINST (0): PRESENT (4): Bernie, Warrigal, sukil, twg BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 28/0 (AI=3.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Falsifian: Endorsement of Jason Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Conditional resolved: Jason did not vote AGAINST ] PROPOSAL 8324 (Democratic unassignment) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: LEGISLATION FOR (8): Aris%, Bernie, Falsifian, Jason*, Murphy, Rance, Warrigal, twg% AGAINST (0): PRESENT (2): Alexis, sukil BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 33/0 (AI=2.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Endorsement of Falsifian ] PROPOSAL 8325 (Inflation Vote) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: ECONOMY FOR (4): Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Murphy AGAINST (5): Alexis, G., Jason$, Rance, o PRESENT (4): Bernie, Warrigal, sukil, twg+ BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 12/16 (AI=2.0) OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Conditional resolved: Falsifian did not vote AGAINST ] PROPOSAL 8326 (Attempted cleanup) CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (11): Alexis, Aris, Bernie, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Jason$, Murphy, Rance, Warrigal, sukil, twg AGAINST (2): G., o PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 34/6 (AI=3.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Endorsement of Falsifian ] PROPOSAL 8327 (Blink test v1.2) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: LEGISLATION FOR (8): Alexis, Aris%, Bernie, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Murphy, Warrigal, twg% AGAINST (3): G., o, sukil PRESENT (2): Jason*, Rance BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 28/9 (AI=1.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Falsifian: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Endorsement of Falsifian ] PROPOSAL 8328 (The Eternal Sprit) CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (7): Aris, Bernie, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Murphy, Warrigal, twg AGAINST (4): Alexis, G., o, sukil PRESENT (2): Jason$, Rance BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 21/12 (AI=3.0) OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Endorsement of Falsifian ] PROPOSAL 8329 (RtRW Reschedule) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: PARTICIPATION FOR (7): Alexis%, Bernie, Cuddle Beam, Jason^, Rance, sukil, twg& AGAINST (4): Aris, G., Warrigal, o PRESENT (2): Falsifian, Murphy BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 30/12 (AI=1.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Falsifian: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Endorsement of Alexis ] PROPOSAL 8330 (No looting white ribbons) CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (7): Alexis, Aris, Falsifian, Jason$, Murphy, Rance, Warrigal AGAINST (0): PRESENT (3): Bernie, sukil, twg BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 22/0 (AI=3.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Inextricable: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Inextricable: Endorsement of non-voter G. ] PROPOSAL 8331 (Promissory cleanliness) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: JUSTICE FOR (7): Alexis, Aris, Falsifian, Jason$, Murphy, Rance, Warrigal AGAINST (0): PRESENT (3): Bernie, sukil, twg& BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 22/0 (AI=1.7) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Conditional resolved: Warrigal did not vote AGAINST ] PROPOSAL 8332 (Switch Responsibility Responsibility) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: EFFICIENCY FOR (3): Alexis, Warrigal, sukil AGAINST (5): Aris, Bernie, Jason^, Rance, twg% PRESENT (2): Falsifian%, Murphy% BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 9/20 (AI=1.0) OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Falsifian: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Rance: Endorsement of Jason ] PROPOSAL 8333 (Meaningful extra votes) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: LEGISLATION FOR (3): Alexis, Murphy, Warrigal AGAINST (6): Aris%, Bernie, Falsifian, Jason*, Rance, twg% PRESENT (1): sukil BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 9/27 (AI=2.0) OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Falsifian: Endorsement of twg: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Rance: Endorsement of Jason ] PROPOSAL 8334 (Meaningless extra coins) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: ECONOMY FOR (5): Alexis, Cuddle Beam, Murphy, Warrigal, sukil AGAINST (8): Aris, Bernie, Falsifian, G., Jason$, Rance, o, twg+ PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 15/31 (AI=2.0) OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason ] PROPOSAL 8335 (Consistent ADoP duties) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: EFFICIENCY FOR (2): Warrigal, sukil AGAINST (6): Alexis, Aris, Bernie, Jason^, Rance, twg% PRESENT (2): Falsifian%, Murphy% BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 6/23 (AI=2.0) OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason ] PROPOSAL 8336 (Define "publicly") CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (10): Alexis, Aris, Bernie, Falsifian, Jason$, Murphy, Rance, Warrigal, sukil, twg AGAINST (0): PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 31/0 (AI=3.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Falsifian: Endorsement of Jason Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Endorsement of Jason ] PROPOSAL 8337 (Fix Auctions) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: ECONOMY FOR (3): Aris, Murphy, Warrigal AGAINST (4): Alexis, Bernie, Falsifian, twg+ PRESENT (3): Jason$, Rance, sukil BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 9/18 (AI=1.0) OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason ] PROPOSAL 8338 (Clarify quorum (option 1)) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: LEGISLATION FOR (9): Alexis, Aris%, Bernie, Falsifian, Jason*, Murphy, Rance, Warrigal, twg% AGAINST (1): sukil PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 36/3 (AI=2.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Endorsement of Murphy ] PROPOSAL 8339 (Clarify quorum (option 2)) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: LEGISLATION FOR (0): AGAINST (7): Alexis, Aris%, Falsifian, Jason*, Rance, Warrigal, sukil PRESENT (3): Bernie, Murphy, twg% BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 0/28 (AI=2.0) OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Rance: Endorsement of Jason Warrigal: Proposal 8338 has sufficient votes to be adopted twg: Conditional resolved: Murphy did not vote AGAINST ] PROPOSAL 8340 (The Paradox of Self-Appointment) CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: PARTICIPATION FOR (8): Alexis%, Aris, Bernie, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Murphy, Warrigal, twg& AGAINST (2): G., o PRESENT (3): Jason^, Rance, sukil BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 30/6 (AI=1.0) OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Falsifian: Endorsement of Alexis: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Rance: Endorsement of Jason twg: Endorsement of Alexis ] PROPOSAL 8341 (Support of the Person) CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (2): Alexis, Falsifian AGAINST (4): Aris, Bernie, sukil, twg PRESENT (4): Jason$, Murphy, Rance, Warrigal BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 6/12 (AI=3.0) OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Bernie: Endorsement of twg Falsifian: Endorsement of Alexis Rance: Endorsement of Jason ] The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below: ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8322 Title: Unrepetition v1.1 Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Falsifian Co-authors: Alexis, twg For each of Proposals 8287-8307, if the proposal took effect more than once, then any changes to rule text caused by the second and later times the proposal took effect are considered "extra" for the purposes of this proposal. Reverse all such "extra" changes, in the reverse of the order in which they occurred. [Comment: See https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-discussion/2020-February/056587.html for context. I think the changes this undoes are relatively benign, but it's nice to have certainty about the state of the ruleset.] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8323 Title: Secure Ribbons Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Jason Co-authors: Amend Rule 2438 (Ribbons) by replacing the text "Ribbon Ownership is a person switch" with the text "Ribbon Ownership is a secured person switch". ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8324 Title: Democratic unassignment Adoption index: 2.0 Author: Falsifian Co-authors: If Proposal 8320 (Promotorial Assignment) has been adopted, then amend the rule entitled "Proposal Chambers" by replacing "If a proposal in the Proposal Pool has its chamber unset" with "If the chamber of an ordinary proposal in the Proposal Pool is unset". ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8326 Title: Attempted cleanup Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Falsifian Co-authors: Repeal Rule 2604 ("Nothing to see here, Rule 1030,") and Rule 2600 ("Boo!!"). ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8327 Title: Blink test v1.2 Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Falsifian Co-authors: Amend Rule 2601 to read in full: If this is the only paragraph in this rule, and it has been at least one week since this rule was last amended, then any player CAN Close the Eye by announcement. When that happens, this rule repeals itself. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8329 Title: RtRW Reschedule Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Alexis Co-authors: Amend Rule 2327 (Read the Ruleset Week) by adding the following paragraph: { The above notwithstanding, due to serious uncertainty surrounding the state of the rules during the scheduled Read the Ruleset Week, in the year 2020, Read the Ruleset Week is, instead, the week of February 24 - March 1 } ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8330 Title: No looting white ribbons Adoption index: 3.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Amend Rule 2438 (Ribbons) by replacing: A player who has been registered for at least 30 days and has never caused another person to gain a White Ribbon (including under a previous ruleset) CAN award a White Ribbon to another person by announcement. with: A player who has been registered for at least 30 days and has never acted on eir own behalf to cause another person to gain a White Ribbon (including under a previous ruleset) CAN act on eir own behalf to award a White Ribbon to another person by announcement. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8331 Title: Promissory cleanliness Adoption index: 1.7 Author: Warrigal Co-authors: Append the following paragraph to Rule 2450 "Pledges": The Notary CAN destroy a pledge Without Objection, and SHOULD do so if and only if the pledge no longer serves any significant purpose. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8336 Title: Define "publicly" Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Jason Co-authors: Amend Rule 478 by appending to the paragraph beginning "A public message is" the following sentence: To do something "publicly" is to do that thing within a public message. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8338 Title: Clarify quorum (option 1) Adoption index: 2.0 Author: Murphy Co-authors: If the author's proposal "Clarify quorum (option 2)" has been or would be adopted with a greater proportion of support, then this proposal has no effect. Otherwise: Amend Rule 879 (Quorum) by replacing "Agoran decision to adopt a proposal" with "Agoran decision on whether to adopt a proposal". ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8340 Title: The Paradox of Self-Appointment Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Alexis Co-authors: Amend Rule 103 (The Speaker) by inserting { If the Prime Minister is emself Laureled, eir power to appoint a Speaker continues for the entirety of a message in which e resigns as Prime Minister, and if e is the only Laureled player, e CAN void that power, and thereby discharge the obligation to use it, by announcing that e declines to take the office. } at the end of the second paragraph, and by moving the first two sentences of the second paragraph to the first paragraph. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// -- Jason Cobb
