Re: DIS: Proto: Fairer judge rotation

2007-11-06 Thread Ian Kelly
On 11/6/07, Zefram <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Ian Kelly wrote: > >Why does it need to be in that paragraph? > > Interaction of terminology. "unqualified" should be defined with > "qualified", at least. I still don't follow. R1868 already uses "unqualified" without a local definition. > >the o

Re: DIS: Proto: Fairer judge rotation

2007-11-06 Thread comex
A simple self-ratifying clause would fix that. On 11/6/07, Zefram <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > There's a problem here which I forgot to mention: fatigue isn't > self-correcting, which posture presently is. An incorrect fatigue value > stays incorrect indefinitely. Discovery of an old error has e

Re: DIS: Proto: Fairer judge rotation

2007-11-06 Thread Zefram
Ian Kelly wrote: >Why does it need to be in that paragraph? Interaction of terminology. "unqualified" should be defined with "qualified", at least. >the only operations to be performed on the set are sorting and >incrementing. There's a problem here which I forgot to mention: fatigue isn't self

Re: DIS: Proto: Fairer judge rotation

2007-11-06 Thread Ian Kelly
On 11/6/07, Zefram <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Ian Kelly wrote: > > A player is well qualified to be assigned as judge of a judicial > > case if and only if e is neither unqualified nor poorly > > qualified to be assigned as its judge. > > This needs to be merged into the "Except wh

Re: DIS: Proto: Fairer judge rotation

2007-11-06 Thread Zefram
Ian Kelly wrote: > A player is well qualified to be assigned as judge of a judicial > case if and only if e is neither unqualified nor poorly > qualified to be assigned as its judge. This needs to be merged into the "Except where modified ..." paragraph, which uses the term "qualifi

Re: DIS: Proto: Fairer judge rotation

2007-11-05 Thread Ian Kelly
On 11/5/07, Ed Murphy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > root wrote: > > > Fatigue is a standing player switch, the possible values of > > which are the natural numbers, and the default of which is the > > maximum fatigue value ever set. Fatigue is tracked by the Clerk > > of the

Re: DIS: Proto: Fairer judge rotation

2007-11-05 Thread Ed Murphy
root wrote: Fatigue is a standing player switch, the possible values of which are the natural numbers, and the default of which is the maximum fatigue value ever set. Fatigue is tracked by the Clerk of the Courts, as is the maximum fatigue value ever set. A standi

DIS: Proto: Fairer judge rotation

2007-11-05 Thread Ian Kelly
Proto-proposal: Fairer judge rotation (AI=2) Amend Rule 1868 (Judge Assignment Generally) by appending the text: A player is well qualified to be assigned as judge of a judicial case if and only if e is neither unqualified nor poorly qualified to be assigned as its judge. Amen