n.b. you should retract these.
Sent from my iPhone
On May 27, 2012, at 9:14 AM, FKA441344 <441...@gmail.com> wrote:
> I CFJ, linked(both inquiry):
> *Rule 2350 contains the text
> "which places the proposal in the Proposal Pool".
>
> *Rule 2350 contains the text "A proposal is a type of entity"
>
>
> Arguments: Proposal 7216 purportedly added the second text and removed
> the first, but this leaves no way to add proposals to the Pool, which
> would make Agora ossified, so Rule 1698 (Agora Is A Nomic) should have
> cancelled it. However, the next published Full Logical Ruleset gives a
> version of Rule 2350 that contains both.
>
> Evidence:
> Short Logical Ruleset, May 3:
> {
> Rule 2350/1 (Power=3)
> Proposals
>
> A proposal is a fixed body of text which has been made into a
> proposal using a process specifically described in the Rules.
>
> A player CAN create a proposal by publishing ("submitting") a
> body of text and an associated title with a clear indication
> that it is intended to become a proposal, which places the
> proposal in the Proposal Pool. The author (syn. proposer) of a
> proposal is the player who submitted it. A player CAN remove
> (syn. retract, withdraw) a proposal e authored from the Proposal
> Pool by announcement.
>
> A co-author of a proposal is a person (other than its author)
> unambiguously identified as such by its author when it was
> submitted.
> }
> Full Logical Ruleset, May 5:
> {
> Rule 2350/2 (Power=3)
> Proposals
>
> A proposal is a type of entity consisting of a body of text. A
> player CAN create a proposal by announcement, specifying its
> text and optionally specifying the following attributes:
>
> * An associated title.
> * A list of co-authors (which must be persons other than the
> author).
> * An adoption index and Chamber.
>
> Once a proposal is created, none of its attributes can be
> changed. The author (syn. proposer) of a proposal is the person
> who submitted it.
>
> A proposal is a fixed body of text which has been made into a
> proposal using a process specifically described in the Rules.
>
> A player CAN create a proposal by publishing ("submitting") a
> body of text and an associated title with a clear indication
> that it is intended to become a proposal, which places the
> proposal in the Proposal Pool. The author (syn. proposer) of a
> proposal is the player who submitted it. A player CAN remove
> (syn. retract, withdraw) a proposal e authored from the Proposal
> Pool by announcement.
>
> A co-author of a proposal is a person (other than its author)
> unambiguously identified as such by its author when it was
> submitted.
>
> History:
> Created by Proposal 7083 (Walker), 4 July 2011
> Amended(1) by Proposal 7086 (G., omd), 23 July 2011
> Amended(2) by Proposal 7216 (omd), 4 May 2012
> }
> Short Logical Ruleset, May 10:
> {
> Rule 2350/2 (Power=3)
> Proposals
>
> A proposal is a type of entity consisting of a body of text. A
> player CAN create a proposal by announcement, specifying its
> text and optionally specifying the following attributes:
>
> * An associated title.
> * A list of co-authors (which must be persons other than the
> author).
> * An adoption index and Chamber.
>
> Once a proposal is created, none of its attributes can be
> changed. The author (syn. proposer) of a proposal is the person
> who submitted it.
> }
>
>
>
> Without paying a ruble, I submit a proposal with AI 2, coauthor
> Murphy, title {Effective Ballot Fees}, and text {Change the power of
> Rule 2364 (Ballot Fees) to 2.}.
>
>
>
> I CFJ, linked:
> *(Criminal) Earlier in this message, FKA441344 violated Rule 2365
> by submitting a proposal without paying the cost.
> *(Inquiry) Earlier in this message, FKA441344 submitted a proposal
> without paying a cost.
>
> Arguments: Rule 2350(either version) says "A player CAN create a
> proposal[...]". If Rule 2365 is interpreted as making it IMPOSSIBLE to
> create a proposal without paying a cost, it conflicts with Rule 2350
> which takes precedence due to higher power.
