On Mon, 2017-05-22 at 12:57 -0700, Kerim Aydin wrote: > > Oops, forgot something... I withdraw my most recent CFJ. > > > I CFJ on: In a message dated Mon, 22 May 2017 15:31:30 -0400, > Publius Scribonius Scholasticus initiated an Agoran > Decision.
I think I missed this earlier? Assuming I haven't already numbered it, this is CFJ 3513 and I assign it to nichdel. > I Bar Publius Scribonius Scholasticus. [this is the only difference] > > > Caller's Arguments: > > Given my recent attempt to "announce" OscarMeyr, I wonder if "announced non- > players" is ambiguous? In past, listing "all members of set S" without > specifying the individual set members has been seen as ambiguous, IF it > is beyond a reasonable effort of an average player to dig back and find that > list (as opposed to the officer doing it, as it's eir job) or IF there's > some uncertainty on membership (e.g. OscarMeyr). > > For players, there's a handy Registrar's report to refer to, so it's not > beyond a reasonable effort for average players to find that. For non- > players, not so much (and if the rules are silent here, consider there > is an "unfair" burden on non-players who are not clearly listed for > informed voting - especially listing it as "Ørjan and others"!). > > It is also unclear if the election is limited to "announced" non-players, > given R2482: "non-player persons can also become valid options during the > voting period by announcement." If this clause is non-functional due to > conflicts with R107, it would be good to identify the problem and correct > R2482. If the clause is *not* non-functional, then the announcement > limiting options to "announced" players is simply incorrect and therefore > invalid. > > Caller's Evidence: > (Message in question) > On Mon, 22 May 2017, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus wrote: > > True, the CoE having been successful, I hereby initiate a Victory Election > > with all players, announced non-players, and PRESENT as valid options and > > the Herald as the vote collector. I would be in favor of all watchers > > (Ørjan and others) and G. putting emselves into the race. The ballots > > should be cast in an instant runoff format. -- ais523 Arbitor
