The below CFJ is 4018. I assign it to Murphy.
status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#4018
=============================== CFJ 4018 ===============================
I currently own the Radiance stone.
==========================================================================
Caller: snail
Barred: Janet
Judge: Murphy
==========================================================================
History:
Called by snail: 15 Mar 2023 03:13:52
Assigned to Murphy: [now]
==========================================================================
Caller's Arguments:
Arguments for TRUE:
The Radiance stone is the same stone as the Score stone, just with
different attributes, and so falls under Rule 1586 (Definition and
Continuity of Entities):
If the entity that defines another entity is amended such that it
defines the second entity both before and after the amendment, but
with different attributes, then the second entity and its
attributes continue to exist to whatever extent is possible under
the new definitions.
Caller's Evidence:
>From adopted proposal 8919:
Amend R2645 by replacing:
- Score Stone (Weekly, 3): When wielded, a specified player's
(defaulting to the wielder if not specified) Score is increased
by 3.
with:
- Radiance Stone (Weekly, 3): When wielded, a specified player
(defaulting to the wielder if not specified) gains 3 radiance.
>From Rule 2645 (The Stones):
The following stones are defined, one per paragraph, with the
following format: Stone Name (Frequency, Smoothness): Description.
It seems like the different attributes that were changed are just the Stone
Name and Description, and common sense indicates they're the same stone.
==========================================================================
