status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#3542
(This document is informational only and contains no game actions).
============================== CFJ 3542 ==============================
All Players except Cuddlebeam now have enough Trust Tokens to win
the game.
========================================================================
Caller: CuddleBeam
Judge: Quazie
Judgement: FALSE
========================================================================
History:
Called by CuddleBeam: 20 Jul 2017
Assigned to Quazie: 21 Jul 2017
Judged FALSE by Quazie: 25 Aug 2017
========================================================================
Caller's Arguments:
This isn't consequential to other actions/offices, it's just related to
Trust Tokens which people have been hardly using lately anyway. Here, I
attempt to grant Trust Tokens via that "a Trust Token" means any kind of
Trust Token, much how "a banana" can be a rotten banana, my banana, your
banana, a ripe banana, etc.
Note that this treads into fairly abstract territory due to how open "a X"
can be via the banana reasoning.
--------*------
Note R2452: "Any player can issue a Trust Token to another person by
announcement."
Be a TrustToken[A, B] a Trust Token such that player A would issue to
player B if A posted a message of "I grant a Trust Token to B", where B is
Player B's name, to a-b;
Once, for each player except Murphy, I issue a Trust Token[A, B] to Murphy,
where A is that player and B is Murphy, to Murphy.
Then, I do the same, again, but for the beneficiary to be another player
instead of Murphy (for example, "Once, for each player except Ais523, I
issue a Trust Token[A, B] to Ais523, where A is that player and B
is Ais523, to Ais523."), until I have done the sequence for all Players
(except myself, because I can't issue myself Trust Tokens).
========================================================================
Judge's Arguments:
[delivered on behalf of Quazie by G.]
If I issue you a trust token, you have been issued a trust token by me,
even if I claim it was issued by someone else (excepting situations like
Agencies, for which there is no evidence in this case). This is
straightforward language use. FALSE.
========================================================================
