The below is CFJ 3754. I assign it to G.
=============================== CFJ 3754 ===============================
Rule 2598 has been repealed.
==========================================================================
Caller: twg
Judge: G.
==========================================================================
History:
Called by twg: 05 Jul 2019 14:03:40
Assigned to G.: [now]
==========================================================================
Caller's Arguments:
Argument for FALSE - R2598 says/said:
8. Any player CAN with Agoran Consent trigger this Rule. When
this Rule is triggered, the following events happen in order:
(a) the Politics Rules are automatically repealed in ascending
numerical order (unless Politics has been Revived), (b) the
Spaaace Rules are automatically repealed in ascending numerical
order (unless Spaaace has been Revived), and (c) this Rule is
automatically repealed.
It's not clear to me that those events can/could actually occur - the
rule is/was just stating that they happen, rather than stating that it
(or something else with Power >= 3.0) makes them happen. R105 is pretty
unambiguous that rule changes can only be caused by instruments, which
is why we have verbose things like this in R106:
When a decision about whether to adopt a proposal is resolved, if
the outcome is ADOPTED, then the proposal in question is adopted,
and unless other rules prevent it from taking effect, its power is
set to the minimum of four and its adoption index, and then it
takes effect. Except as prohibited by other rules, a proposal that
takes effect CAN and does, as part of its effect, apply the
changes that it specifies.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gratuitous Arguments by Jason Cobb:
This was already brought up by omd [0], and Aris gave a response arguing
that it would work [1].
[0]:
https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2019-June/040615.html
[1]:
https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-discussion/2019-June/054363.html
==========================================================================
